Pages

5.23.2008

A measure of courage

A measure of courage
by Shane Wilson

The Rio Dell Volunteer Fire Department and the Rio Dell Fire Protection District would like to offer our deepest condolences to the Rodoni family for the tremendous loss they have suffered. Roger was a true friend to our department and we will miss him. His smiling face and humorous persona while volunteering during our Wildwood Days Bar-B-Que will be a lasting memory for all of us.

I find this column very difficult to write, even though many days have past since that tragic afternoon. I wanted to say these things during Roger's memorial service; however, I knew that I would have been too emotional to speak. Putting this into words will be difficult, but here it goes:

I will start by saying how proud I am of our volunteer firefighters who were at the scene of the accident that day. Four people from our department just happened to be passing by, and stopped to assist the victims in this fairly large accident. Their actions that day are an inspiration to volunteers and Samaritans everywhere.

This was a test of courage that cannot be measured, but can be greatly appreciated by everyone in our community. I am truly honored to be a member of a fire department with such selfless and professional personnel.

Rogers last seconds were the epitome of strength and courage.

Everyone has heard the main ingredients in this tragic story: Roger was going to his rally in Fortuna. He was talking to his beloved wife Johanna on his cell phone. Johanna and Roger had just passed each other going opposite directions seconds before the accident.

Here are some of the details that only a few people know about:

Roger's Ford F250 came to rest over the bank on its wheels after rolling numerous times. The cab of the pickup was severely crushed, and the trauma that Roger sustained was immense. He was also trapped in the driver's side doorway of the vehicle.
Amber Bowlds, one of the above-mentioned firefighters, was the first to make contact with Roger. Shockingly, she found that he had a pulse. However, he was not breathing.

Feeling helpless, Amber could not initiate CPR due to Roger's position in the vehicle. She tried to manage his airway by holding his head a position to breathe. Within a few minutes, Amber saw someone standing beside the vehicle who she recognized immediately. It was Johanna.

Johanna, sensing something was wrong, had turned her vehicle around and returned to check on her husband. She asked Amber about the condition Roger was in. Amber told her that it was not good.

Johanna asked if she could go to him, and Amber told her that it was her decision, but she should know that he was hurt very badly.

Bravely, Johanna went to her husband's side and held his hand. She spoke to him in private for the last time. Johanna told him that she loved him, and his pulse was soon lost. I do not know the words that she chose, but I know that Roger waited to hear them before he let go.

Roger Rodoni is the utmost measure of courage. This impact should have caused his death immediately, but Roger knew that his wife would soon return. He was strong enough to hold on for several minutes so they could share one last goodbye. He gave her that final moment with him, truly an inspiring moment for us all.

Roger was many different things to many different people: Friend, colleague, mentor and teacher, just to name a few. For me, in those final minutes of his life, he also became an inspiration.

Shane Wilson is chief of the Rio Dell Volunteer Fire Department.

5.01.2008

ER - Gallegos sidesteps questions about possible conflict of interest in Bowman charges

Gallegos sidesteps questions about possible conflict of interest in Bowman charges

A large contribution to the successful 2006 re-election campaign of Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos has raised questions the DA has so far declined to answer, after it was learned that the son of the man chiefly responsible for the contribution subsequently escaped punishment on numerous criminal charges, including one alleging the statutory rape of a 14-year-old girl.

According to Fair Political Practices Commission filings, the donation, in the amount of $10,000, was the single largest monetary contribution received by the campaign of the incumbent DA from any contributor whose last name was not Gallegos.

FPPC documents indicate that the contribution was recorded April 29, and attributed to the Bear River Band of Rohnerville Rancheria, which is chaired by Leonard Bowman, father of Derek Bowman, 25, both of Loleta.

The younger Bowman’s association with law enforcement spans two states and 11 years, and includes as many as 40 criminal charges ranging from assault with a deadly weapon as a juvenile to three charges alleging violence against one adult and two juvenile females in 2006.

But on July 19, less than six weeks after Gallegos was re-elected, the DA’s Office gathered nine felonies and a handful of misdemeanors pending against Derek, and dismissed or suspended sentence on all of them in a single day.

According to publicly available court documents, recent charges against Derek included felony statutory rape, five counts of felony check fraud against local businesses, felony burglary, felony threats, felony battery, misdemeanor battery and misdemeanor resisting arrest.

Restitution orders for the check fraud cases were part of the July 19 deals, but the documents show that no jail time for any of the alleged offenses was requested by the DA’s Office.

For violation of probation on a previous charge, Derek was sentenced in July to 180 days, less time served, in the Humboldt County jail.

FOLLOWING THE MONEY

In a declaration in support of an arrest warrant on one of the charges against Derek, Humboldt County Sheriff’s Deputy Troy Garey wrote on June 26 that Cheree Bowie, the mother of Derek’s 17-year-old wife, told him that Derek had “been bragging that even if he was arrested, his dad would get him out of jail.”

In his report, Garey stated that he asked Bowie how she knew this.

“Bowie said the suspect’s father, Leonard Bowman, is the tribal chairperson on the Bear River reservation,” Garey wrote, “and he and the tribe and the Bear River Casino gave District Attorney Paul Gallegos $10,000 in his recent re-election campaign for DA. Bowie then hung up the phone.”

When The Eureka Reporter attempted to contact Bowman at the tribal office, a woman who answered the phone said that Bowman had no comment when he was told the call was regarding campaign contributions.

In all, the Bowmans, the tribe and an attorney employed by the casino contributed $11,100 to Gallegos’ campaign coffers, just under 10 percent of the total of all funds raised by the incumbent during the campaign, according to FPPC filings.

In addition to the $10,000 contribution in the name of the Rancheria, Leonard and his wife personally contributed $100, the FPPC documents show.

The same documents indicate Bear River attorney Michael Acosta contributed $1,000.

Contained in the court records is a letter to the Humboldt County Probation Department, dated Aug. 7 and written on Bear River Gaming Agency letterhead, in which Acosta requested that Derek be granted probation in lieu of the 180-day sentence.

Acosta stated in the letter that he would recommend reinstatement of Derek’s employment in the casino’s surveillance department should probation be granted.

Court documents state that Derek has been charged with violating the terms of his probation seven times in the past nine years.

FOLLOWING THE RULES

While there is no direct evidence that indicates Derek was treated differently because of the contributions, neither did Gallegos exercise any of the options available to him to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest.

The simple explanation may be that he was not legally required to do so.

According to Del Norte County District Attorney Mike Riese, there is no rule requiring the removal or “recusal” of a DA from cases in which a possible conflict of interest is perceived.

Riese, who has no involvement in the Bowman cases and spoke only in general terms about recusal, said, “District attorneys have unfettered discretion under the government code. If we choose, we can recuse ourselves, we can ask the attorney general to come in or we can appoint a special prosecutor.”

But Riese reiterated that no district attorney in California would be under any legal obligation to choose any of those alternatives.

It is not known if Gallegos attempted to recuse himself from Derek’s criminal cases, but none of the 232 pages of court documents contained in the court files makes reference to a recusal.

Neither does Gallegos appear to have referred Derek’s cases for prosecution by the California State Attorney General’s Office, which retains concurrent jurisdiction in all cases prosecuted by California district attorneys and their deputies.

FOLLOWING COURT PRECEDENT

There is no evidence in any of the files that Gallegos was personally involved in Derek’s prosecution. However, according to numerous legal precedents, in cases in which there exists a possible conflict of interest, an entire DA’s Office is commonly recused.

In a recent example that presented a possible conflict for the Los Angeles County District Attorney, Deputy DA Matthew Monforton wrote a memorandum to county officials demanding recusal of all L.A. County prosecutors and referral of the case to the attorney general.

When a district attorney suffers from a conflict of interest, Monforton wrote, “appellate courts have imputed the conflict to all deputy district attorneys in the same county.”

Monforton cited People v. Lepe, a 1985 Imperial County case in which a conflict was perceived between District Attorney Thomas Storey and a defendant he had once represented as a defense attorney. The California Court of Appeals disqualified Storey, but didn’t stop there.

“As the deputies are hired by Storey, promoted by Storey and fired by Storey,” the court concluded, “we cannot say the office can be sanitized such to assume the deputy who prosecutes the case will not be influenced by the considerations that bar Storey himself from participation in the case.”

Again, in People v. Choi, Monforton wrote, San Francisco County District Attorney Terrence Hallinan recused himself to avoid a potential conflict, but the California Court of Appeals went further, stating that Hallinan’s entire office should have been recused because prosecutors are “hired, evaluated and promoted by the district attorney.”

The court documents indicate that Derek was at various times defended by what is called “conflict counsel,” meaning an alternative defense attorney was assigned to a particular case after the original public defender disclosed a possible conflict in handling the case.

But the same documents show that similar steps were not taken by prosecutors. Derek’s charges were handled by several prosecutors in the DA’s Office, including Assistant District Attorney Wes Keat, Deputy District Attorneys Maggie Fleming and Max Cardoza and former Deputy District Attorneys Nicole Hansen and Heather Gimle.

Gallegos declined to return repeated phone calls requesting comment for this report, and also declined to answer questions about the matter by e-mail.

In response to several specific inquiries regarding the $10,000 campaign contribution and the subsequent handling of Derek’s criminal cases, Gallegos stated in an e-mail only the following: “This office operates without fear or favor.”

FOLLOWING UP

During the 2006 DA campaign, former Deputy District Attorney Worth Dikeman, Gallegos’ opponent, called on the incumbent to recuse the DA’s Office in the Cheri Moore homicide and refer the case to the attorney general, accusing Gallegos of “making political hay” of the investigation.

“(Gallegos) has a history of rewarding his allies and punishing those who oppose him,” Dikeman said at a May 25 press conference.

“His history of questionable practices, his failure to expeditiously resolve this matter and his strained relationship with the rest of the law enforcement community, including the Eureka Police Officers Association, make this an appropriate case for the attorney general to exercise his discretion under the government code and take full charge of the investigation,” Dikeman said.

Dikeman has acknowledged that one possible factor in his most recent defeat by Gallegos was the extended protest in front of the Courthouse staged by Ellie Bowman, who is Derek’s mother and Leonard’s wife.

“It certainly isn’t helping,” Dikeman said in June.

Ellie was protesting comments Dikeman had made about prospective Native American jurors in the now infamous 1992 murder case against former Fortuna resident Richard Kesser.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals found Sept. 11 in a six-to-five vote that some of Dikeman’s statements contained racial bias, and Kesser’s conviction could be headed for retrial as a result.

But Dikeman said at the time that Ellie had another reason to protest his candidacy. The deputy DA successfully prosecuted Ellie’s other son, Jeffrey Bowman, for the 1999 murder of Trinidad Rancheria member Julius Aubrey.

Jeffrey is currently serving a prison term of 25 years to life.

Jail officials said Friday that Derek was no longer in custody. Technically still booked, he was released Sept. 11 to serve the balance of his 180-day sentence in the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Work Alternative Program.

(Diane M. Batley, Rebecca S. Bender and Megan McCulloch contributed to this report.)
By Heather Muller, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Sep 26 2006, 12:19 AM · Updated: Sep 26 2006, 9:38 AM
Related stories:
ER - Bear River members seek chairperson's recall
ER - Gallegos sidesteps questions about possible conflict of interest in Bowman charges
ER - Questions without answers hinder our newsgathering
ER - Bowman story not accurate
ER - Contribution made because Gallegos was the better of the two
ER - Questions remain in DA's handling of Bowman charges
ER - Bear River official discusses financial contributions from tribe
ER - Tribe's contribution to DA's campaign was made by the Tribal Council, not Bowman
ER - Gallegos is 'public servant,' not Legal Spiegel
ER - It's telling that Gallegos witch hunt didn't start until firing of Dikeman
ER - Writer appreciates editor's note that identifies writers
ER - Residents deserve answers to questions asked of DA's Office
ER - Bitter? You bet!
TS - Donations not improper, says Bear River Band
TS - DA's office: State OK'd handling of plea deal
Why DA's Palco suit was ill-advised

”All good things must come to an end” is an old saying we all know. With any luck, the same could be said of all bad things, and so it is with the People v. Pacific Lumber Company lawsuit filed by the Humboldt County district attorney.

After being dismissed by the trial court and then having been unanimously rejected by the appeals court, the California Supreme Court has driven a stake through the heart of this ill-advised lawsuit. On April 24, the Supreme Court denied District Attorney Gallegos' petition for review. It also denied his request to have the appellate court decision depublished.

The public deserves an explanation of what all this means.

Before that, I would like to make it clear that I in no way approve of Palco's behavior. I personally prosecuted them twice criminally (obtaining literally every last penny available as penalties under the 15 counts I charged collectively) and once civilly (against Scopac, actually), receiving $80,000 in a settlement, $35,000 of which I sent to schools in the Van Duzen watershed.

And I found Palco's behavior in the recall election astounding and shameful, an incredibly bad set of decisions to fund petition signers and more in an effort to drive out an elected official.

That said, Gallegos' decision to prosecute Palco was a political one, make no mistake. Political prosecutions are never a good idea.

Within days of taking office, Gallegos directed his chief investigator to conduct an investigation. When his investigators reported they could not find evidence of a crime, the suit was filed civilly instead. The day before it was filed, a member of a local watchdog organization sat in the DA's library and read the complaint.

The civil complaint was poorly charged, forcing Gallegos' office to twice amend it during trial. Even so, the trial court ultimately dismissed it on a “demurrer,” which is a motion asserting the case lacks the basic essentials to get to trial. The dismissal was “without leave to amend,” meaning the trial court found the allegations incapable of proceeding. The appellate court was even less kind.
Stating the rule that it must “give the complaint a reasonable interpretation, and treat the demurrer as admitting all material facts properly pleaded,” the appellate court examined the only two arguments Gallegos made: (1) the “litigation privilege” in Civil Code section 47(b), which is “absolute,” and (2) the Gallegos-named “right-to-lie” argument (the Noerr-Pennington doctrine, actually). Both went down in flames.

The idea in the “litigation privilege” is that those honestly in court should be allowed to make whatever claims they may without fear of then being sued simply for having made those claims. The principles are (1) protecting access to the courts, and (2) the “chilling effect” that such a fear would have on those with legitimate claims.

The appellate court looked at many cases, as well as the facts of the Palco case, and found that “the same chilling effect would occur here, we fear, were this (Palco) lawsuit to proceed.”

The “Noerr-Pennington doctrine” gives those who attempt to influence the government immunity from liability under federal antitrust law. There is a “sham exception” to this immunity, which Gallegos argued applied to Palco.

The appellate court “decline(d) to hold that the state's fraud-based allegations meet the requirements of the sham exception,” and held that Palco was “undoubtedly immune from liability under Noerr-Pennington.”

The appellate court closed its opinion noting that the court “must determine whether plaintiffs [the state] have demonstrated evidence which, if credited, would justify their prevailing at trial.” It then held that “for the reasons discussed above, we conclude the state's evidence, even if credited, would not justify its prevailing at trial. Further, we conclude the state has failed to prove, on its third try, a reasonable possibility that the (complaint)'s defect can be cured by amendment.”

In short, all arguments advanced by District Attorney Gallegos, both at trial and on appeal, were shot down in their entirety.
It is said that “bad facts make bad law.” And so Gallegos asked to have the appellate court's decision “depublished,” meaning that it would no longer be law. The Supreme Court declined, and we are left with “The People ex rel Paul V. Gallegos, as District Attorney v. the Pacific Lumber Company.”

Some may celebrate the end of this case, finding it bad, while others may lament, seeing the case as good. We are all still left deciding if we approve of further political prosecutions That, I submit, is bad.

Paul Hagen is an attorney in Eureka. He previously served as a deputy district attorney in four northern California counties, including Humboldt county. He resides in Eureka.

Paul Hagen
Article Launched: 05/01/2008 01:27:25 AM PDT

4.26.2008

TS - Police chief's wife feared he'd hurt her

Police chief's wife feared he'd hurt her

John Driscoll and Thadeus Greenson The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 04/25/2008 01:24:19 AM PDT

EUREKA -- Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's wife testified at Gundersen's preliminary hearing Thursday that he threatened to “take her fishing” if she went to law enforcement with her allegations of rape.

”Did you think he was going to take you to catch some fish?” District Attorney Paul Gallegos asked Jane Doe 1.

”No,” she responded.

”What do you think he meant?” Gallegos asked.

”That he was going to take me fishing to hurt me,” Jane Doe 1 testified.

Gallegos continued Thursday to make his case to Humboldt County Superior Court Judge John Feeney that there is sufficient evidence for Gundersen to stand trial on 19 charges, including 12 counts of spousal rape, kidnapping a second victim with the intent to rape, violating a court order, dissuading a victim from reporting a crime, possessing a controlled substance without a prescription, and possessing a machine gun and a pistol with a silencer attached.

Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all counts and is being held on $1.25 million bail. The Blue Lake City Council recently voted to terminate his employment as chief of police effective May 5.

On Thursday, the fourth day of the preliminary hearing, Gallegos and Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, continued questioning Jane Doe 1 and three investigators involved in the case.

Under cross examination, Jane Doe 1 testified that she never claimed to sheriff's department investigators that she didn't consent to sex with her husband on Feb. 7 -- the day before Gundersen's arrest. That's why she refused a sexual assault test the next day, she said.

Clanton thoroughly questioned Jane Doe 1 on whether she feared prosecution by the District Attorney's Office and if she had been promised any leniency in exchange for testifying. Investigators told her they believed she had committed multiple felonies, she said, but offered her no leniency in exchange for testifying in this case.

She maintained her testimony from the day before, that Gundersen had sex with her without her consent once a month in 2006 and 2007 while she was incapacitated by sleeping aids and/or other drugs. Clarifying her answer from Wednesday, Jane Doe 1 testified that while she had previously told Gundersen it was OK to have sex with her while she slept, she later told him to stop the practice.

She also testified that she “fears” her husband.

Gallegos also questioned Jane Doe 1 about a telephone conversation she had Wednesday night with Gundersen's brother, Gary Gundersen. He asked if she had assured Gary Gundersen that she was doing her best to help her husband, but she denied that was true. Clanton objected to the line of questioning, and it was stricken from the court record.

Jane Doe 1 also testified that she'd been called into a meeting with Gallegos and his investigator, Wayne Cox, on Wednesday afternoon. Clanton asked if they had “coached” her on responses to his questions, and Jane Doe 1 said she wouldn't use that term.

”They just said that I need to be more forthcoming -- not just simple yes or no. That I could elaborate on my answers,” she testified.

Gallegos and Cox hadn't made her any promises or threats with regard to her testimony in this case, she testified. They asked her to testify honestly and to be forthcoming, she said.

On the stand, Cox testified that he was part of the team that served a search warrant on Gundersen's McKinleyville home, which turned up 16 pill bottles prescribed to people other than residents of the home.

Other pill bottles at Gundersen's home were found in paper bags with Blue Lake Police Department evidence numbers on them, Cox testified.

Under cross examination, Cox testified the pill bottles were found in the master bathroom of Gundersen's home, which appeared to be used by both him and Jane Doe 1, who is a sergeant in the Blue Lake Police Department. Some were also found in a black bag in the bathroom, Cox testified, which also contained small baggies with pills and a bottle prescribed for Jane Doe 1. He also said Jane Doe 1 had informed investigators she was constructing a “drug kit” for educational and training purposes.

Gallegos showed Cox pictures of a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer attached, and Cox confirmed the firearms had been seized from a gun safe in Gundersen's garage.

To buttress the charge that Gundersen had violated a court order, Gallegos called Humboldt County Sheriff's Office Detective Troy Garey to the stand. Garey testified that he served Gundersen with an emergency protective order while he was in custody that required him to refrain from any contact with Jane Doe 1.

Garey then testified that he monitored phone conversations made by Gundersen from jail, in which he told Jane Doe 1 to contact the District Attorney's Office to say she didn't want to testify and to ask that the charges against her husband be dropped.

The preliminary hearing is scheduled to continue Wednesday, when District Attorney's Office Chief Investigator Mike Hislop is expected to retake the stand.

Related coverage, with links

ER - Doe 1: ‘I don’t think I would have ever come forward’

Four witnesses testified today at David Gundersen’s preliminary hearing, where topics ranged from seized prescription drugs to what happened at the Eureka Police Department on March 26, 1999.

“Jane Doe 1” finished testimony today, clarifying why she didn’t report the alleged non-consensual sex by Gundersen.

Law enforcement also officials took the stand to talk about the results of a search warrant on Gundersen’s home and of contact between him and Doe 1 while in jail.

Gundersen, currently the police chief for the Blue Lake Police Department, may face trial on suspicion of 19 charges, including 12 counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant, one count of kidnapping to commit another crime and possession of a machine gun.

Gundersen is being held at the Humboldt County jail with a $1.25 million bail.

At the end of Wednesday’s session, Doe 1 made it clear that it was never her intention to press charges on Gundersen. She also said she “felt coerced” by the several people at Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office to make statements she would otherwise not have made during a seven-hour interview.

Doe 1 had fears about coming forward about alleged non-consensual sex that occurred while she and Gundersen dealt with marital problems, starting in late 2005.

“I don’t think I would have ever come forward,” she said, adding she didn’t want to be responsible for Gundersen losing his job, his kids and going to prison. She also didn’t want this in the press.

Because of their busy schedules, Doe 1 testified that she allowed Gundersen to have sex with her while she slept before they started having martial problems. At that point, she asked him to stop.

“He wasn’t being honest with me about some personal things,” she said.

Doe 1 testified that she feared for her safety when talking with HCSO, but her fears “became worse because of what was said to me during the interview.”

At one point, Doe 1 recalled being told that Gundersen would take her “fishing.”

Doe 1 said she interpreted it as “he was going to take me fishing and hurt me.”

During the second interview with investigators from the district attorney’s office, Doe 1 testified that they claimed she committed felonies that she hadn’t.

She said she feared prosecution and going to prison.

“You’d like to avoid going to prison wouldn’t you?” Gundersen’s attorney Russell Clanton said.

“Of course,” she said.

After the court excused Doe 1, Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos called three law enforcement officials to the stand for a variety of topics.

Investigator Wayne Cox of the district attorney’s office testified that 16 bottles of prescription drugs that were not in Gundersen or Doe 1’s name were found at their home after executing a search warrant.

Among them were drugs prescribed for Donna Chaffin, Ben Hoff and Elizabeth Pageant.

“There were so many bottles of pills seized,” Cox said.

On the topic of Chaffin, Cox testified that they investigated it further and found that when Chaffin died, Gundersen and Doe 1 were involved in a death investigation at her home. The pills disappeared from the home after that investigation.

HCSO Detective Troy Garey testified about contact between Gundersen and Doe 1 after an Emergency Protective Order was signed by Doe 1.

Doe 1 said in previous testimony that she didn’t realize what the order entailed until after she signed it, and wanted it reversed.

The order prohibited Gundersen from direct and third-party contact in any way with Doe 1, and is the source of two of the 19 charges against him.

Garey testified that on Feb. 9, Gundersen contacted Doe 1 and asked her not to testify and to contact Cox, Hislop and/or Gallegos to have the charges dropped.

Garey monitored phone conversations with Gundersen to make sure the EPO was enforced.

There were also three letters intercepted by Garey and jail staff in April.

Toward the end of the day, testimony by Chief DA Investigator Michael Hislop focused on why there wasn’t a report from EPD about Doe 2’s visit on March 26, 1999.

Hislop also located a private MySpace account under Gundersen’s name, called “Gundy Bros.,” which featured a picture of an assault rifle and “live, laugh … love, weapon systems/sales and services” on the main page.

Now, Lt. Len Johnson talked with Doe 2, according to court documents.

When interviewed by Hislop, Johnson vaguely recalled the encounter, but couldn’t remember specifics.

When asked what he would have done as a sergeant, Hislop, who was sergeant there at the time — testified that since it occurred outside EPD’s jurisdiction, he would file out a critical incident report and send it to EPD’s chief.

“I find it unusual that (Johnson) didn’t do that,” Hislop said of the strong allegations against a police chief.

Due to schedule conflicts, the hearing resumes April 29.


Doe 1: ‘I don’t think I would have ever come forward’
Karen Wilkinson contributed to this story.
By JOHN C. OSBORN , The Eureka Reporter
Published: Apr 24 2008, 10:38 PM

(For more coverage of David Gundersen’s hearing, along with more detailed testimony from witnesses, go to http://eurekareporter.com/article/080422-gundersens-hearing.)

Related coverage, with links

4.25.2008

TS - Supreme Court won't reverse Palco case decision

The California Supreme Court has refused to hear Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos' major fraud case against the Pacific Lumber Co.

The court turned down the DA's request to review a scalding decision handed down in January by the California Court of Appeals' First District.

”Further, we conclude the state has failed to prove, on its third try, a reasonable possibility that the operative pleading's defect can be cured by amendment,” the three-judge panel wrote for the First District.

The Supreme Court ruled without comment. It also denied Gallegos' request that the First District decision be depublished, which would have prevented it from being a precedent-setting opinion.

The 2002 suit alleged that Palco secured a overly liberal long-term logging plan when it agreed to sell the 7,400-acre Headwaters Forest and other groves for $480 million. The company submitted false data on landslides in one watershed and didn't correct the record until the last minute -- which prompted the California Department of Forestry to adopt a less stringent logging strategy, the complaint held.

The suit was filed shortly before an effort was launched to recall Gallegos, a campaign that was largely funded by Palco. The recall failed.

Palco is now in bankruptcy.

”The trial court, the appellate court and now the California Supreme Court have all recognized this case to be more an exercise in spite and sloganeering than an action of any substance or legal merit,” said Palco Vice President and General Counsel Frank Bacik.

Gallegos did not return the Times-Standard's phone call by deadline.

Humboldt County Superior Court visiting Judge Richard Freeborn threw out an amended complaint in 2005, writing that Gallegos didn't prove that Palco had scammed the government to gain an advantage over a competitor.

The appellate court determined that Palco's lobbying efforts with the state during the 1999 Headwaters negotiations led CDF to drop a stricter logging plan and adopt a more liberal one.

The so-called Noerr-Pennington Doctrine protects anyone petitioning the government or government agencies against civil liability. That doctrine prevails unless the actions taken during lobbying are a “sham.” Since Palco's efforts weren't intended to affect a competitor's business relationship, the appellate court determined, it didn't meet the definition of a sham.

Palco's communications with the CDF during the Headwaters negotiations -- whether fraudulent or not -- are privileged under state unfair competition laws, the appeals ruling reads. California Environmental Quality Act proceedings at the time were the right means to ferret out any false evidence, the First District judges wrote.

Supreme Court won't reverse Palco case decision
John Driscoll The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 04/25/2008 01:15:42 AM PDT

ER - District Attorney Paul Gallegos' fraud lawsuit halted by California Supreme Court

Ending a five-year legal odyssey through the state’s court system, the California Supreme Court has refused to review Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos’ appeal of his fraud lawsuit against The Pacific Lumber Co.

The Supreme Court acted on Wednesday to deny the petition from Gallegos to review his appeal of the First District Court of Appeal’s ruling in January, which upheld a Humboldt County Superior Court ruling that tossed out his lawsuit.

The Supreme Court also denied his petition seeking depublication of the Appellate Court’s lengthy written ruling, which now becomes established case law.

With the high court’s ruling, Gallegos has no further ability to appeal.

Gallegos alleged in his original lawsuit filed in Humboldt County Superior Court in 2003 that PALCO intentionally committed fraud to increase timber harvesting when it manipulated reports during the environmental review phase of PALCO’s Sustained Yield Plan for the historic Headwaters Deal in 1999.

But in a 2005 decision, visiting Judge Richard Freeborn sustained a previous court ruling that Gallegos’ lawsuit had no legal basis and that PALCO’s submission of an allegedly erroneous report and the subsequent resubmission of corrected data were protected under California Civil Code “litigation privilege.”

Gallegos appealed Freeborn’s ruling to California’s First District Court of Appeals, which upheld the ruling that the fraud charges brought against PALCO under unfair competition laws weren’t legally sufficient to warrant a trial.

But going beyond just affirming the lower courts ruling, the appellate court justices published a rare and critical 23-page decision and opinion that stated Gallegos failed to prove that his case could be fixed to move forward and even if it did, the evidence presented “would not justify their prevailing at trial.”

Following that ruling, Gallegos held a news conference and adamantly defended his decision to pursue the lawsuit despite it being dismissed twice because the court found it had no legal merit.

Gallegos did not return a phone call to comment Thursday.

In a written statement Thursday, a PALCO official said Gallegos could not state a single valid legal claim even after the court gave him numerous opportunities to amend his complaint.

“The trial court, the appellate court and now the California Supreme Court have all recognized this case to be more an exercise in spite and sloganeering than an action of any substance or legal merit,” stated Frank Bacik, PALCO’s vice president and general counsel, who responded to the news in a statement Thursday.

“There’s nothing left now but to marvel at the truly irresponsible waste of public money, time and energy this case represents.”

District Attorney Paul Gallegos' fraud lawsuit halted by California Supreme Court
By NATHAN RUSHTON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Apr 24 2008, 5:59 PM · Updated: Apr 25 2008, 12:31 AM

Last night Gallegos was on Channel 3 TV News saying that The Supreme Court didn't really reject his appeal, that they were just "too busy" to hear it. I'm not kidding.