☛ Jury selection underway in Gundersen case 7/17/08
Jury selection got underway Wednesday for the trial of former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen, the first step in what's expected to be a long, arduous process.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8 and now faces 28 felony charges, remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail. The charges include allegations of spousal rape, forcible rape of a second victim and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer. Gundersen, who has pleaded not guilty, made a brief public court appearance Wednesday.
He sat next to his attorney, Russell Clanton, dressed in slacks and a dress shirt.
A flock of potential jurors were called in and spent the morning filling out hardship questionnaires designed to determine if spending eight to 10 weeks hearing the case would cause them an undue financial or personal burden. Based on the forms, prospective jurors were either excused or retained, with a small number who gave ambiguous answers being called before Judge Bruce Watson for more information.
The retained jurors were then asked to fill out a questionnaire -- prepared by Clanton and District Attorney Paul Gallegos -- seeking to weed out potentially biased jurors from the pool.
Of the 10 potential jurors questioned before the judge, six were excused due to hardship concerns, three were asked to fill out the second questionnaire and one was excused for bias after telling the court he felt Gundersen was guilty.
Gallegos said filling a jury for a long trial is generally more time consuming due to hardship concerns.
”The longer the trial, the more you lose because it has a bigger impact on their lives,” he said.
The case is likely to lose some more potential jurors after they fill out the second questionnaire, which asks a litany of personal questions seeking to uncover potential prejudices.
The 11-page questionnaire begins by asking potential jurors about their personal histories, including questions about their education and employment histories, marital status and experiences with crime and law enforcement.
Then, the questionnaire moves into questions more pertinent to Gundersen's case.
”The defendant is the former police chief of Blue Lake and Trinidad. Is there anything about this fact that affects your ability to remain impartial?” it asks.
The questionnaire then asks jurors about their views of the Eureka Police Department and if they believe “law enforcement would alter the truth in order to protect a fellow officer.”
Those questions may be in reference to Jane Doe 2, who testified during Gundersen's preliminary hearing that she first reported her allegations that Gundersen raped her in 1999 to the EPD shortly after the alleged offense. She testified her report was never followed up on.
There are also some questions regarding Jane Doe 1, Gundersen's wife, whom the defendant faces 24 counts of allegedly raping while she was under the influence of the sleep aid Lunesta or other drugs. The questionnaire asks potential jurors a series of questions about sleep aid usage.
Potential jurors are also asked if they would be comfortable hearing testimony describing sexual acts, what they have read about the case, if what they have read has affected their opinions of Gundersen's innocence or guilt and their opinions of Gallegos and Clanton.
It also includes a list of potential witnesses in the case, and asks potential jurors to circle the names of people they know.
On Tuesday, Watson deferred any ruling on Clanton's motion for a change of venue until jury selection is underway. If at any point during the jury selection process Watson believes the court won't be able to impanel an impartial jury, he could grant the motion. In that case, the trial would be held in another county or a jury from another county would be brought in to hear the case locally.
Jury selection is scheduled to continue today.
Jury questions:
* Do you believe law enforcement has a greater duty to follow the law than a civilian? If yes, please describe:
* Who do you believe should have control over the strategic and tactical missions of a police department?
* Will your ability to remain impartial be compromised if you hear testimony of sexual habits you find disagreeable? If yes, please explain:
* Have you read anything about this case? If yes: What have you read? Where did you read it? When did you read it?
* Would you be more likely to find the defendant guilty or innocent because of the fact of the media's coverage of this case? Yes, No, Possibly, No effect.
Source: Questionnaire given to prospective jurors
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/17/2008 01:16:30 AM PDT
7.23.2008
7.22.2008
TS Ltr - "Hogwash, Mr. Gallegos."
TS - Letter to the Editor
On July 11, District Attorney Paul Gallegos appeared before Humboldt County's Code Enforcement Task Force and shared what the press reported as “his frustrations about” a “mutant” structure where he has no authority over code officers, yet all the responsibility for their actions in the field” (Eureka Reporter, 7-12), and he isn't “comfortable with deputizing code enforcement investigators if they are not his employees” (Times-Standard, 7-12). As is often the case with Mr. Gallegos, the truth is otherwise.
For over seven years I was employed by the California District Attorneys Association as a “circuit prosecutor,” in which I was deputized by elected district attorneys in three counties, including by Gallegos. As my legal authority flowed from these elected DA's to me, at all times I answered in my actions as a deputy DA directly to them. On numerous occasions I pointed out this fact to my supervisors in Sacramento, who sometimes felt that they, as my employer, could direct me in my exercise of the DA's authority.
Mr. Gallegos seeks to have it both ways. He has deputized these peace officers, who act under his authority as code enforcement officers, yet claims he cannot control them as his deputies. This is hogwash. The solution is obvious: Insist that these deputies operate subject to his oversight or remove their authority.
It remains unfortunate that our chief law enforcement officer refuses to take responsibility for his actions, placing blame elsewhere. Citizens should rightly expect leadership and honesty, not platitudes and excuses.
Paul Hagen
Eureka
***
Update: July 22, 2008 Well! That drew a response from the long dormant Salzman Communications Director, once again struggling to defend Paul Gallegos. What don't you know? The Emperor's clothes are spun of the finest silk! With 24 karat gold embroidery on the hem, and the finest jewels on the bodice. Can't you see it? If you can't, according to the chief deceptor Michael Twombly, you must be a "disgruntled" ex-employee. One who was FIRED thanks to Gallegos. Michael Twombly must be the last rat on this sinking ship. Looks like he's trying to thwart anyone running against his boy.
Hagen should do his homework - Letter to the Editor
Mr. Hagen's screed about the District Attorney's problems with Humboldt's code officers (Hogwash, Mr. Gallegos) a is little but a disgruntled ex-employee's self-serving run-up to challenging Gallegos in the next DA election.
Mr. Hagen's circuit prosecutor position with the DA's Association in years past is not comparable to the “mutant structure” in which Gallegos has no legal authority over code enforcers, but as DA has official responsibility for their irresponsible, dangerous and provocative activities.
This is an obviously intolerable position for any district attorney and needs to be fixed.
In fact, Gallegos states that that deputies must either operate responsibly under his authority or lose their deputy status under the DA's office.
This seems pretty reasonable.
Mr. Hagen needs to do his homework before throwing his hogwash hat in the ring.
Michael Twombly
Bayside
Scared, Mr. Twombly. So quick to jump to the defense. Of the utterly indefensible.
On July 11, District Attorney Paul Gallegos appeared before Humboldt County's Code Enforcement Task Force and shared what the press reported as “his frustrations about” a “mutant” structure where he has no authority over code officers, yet all the responsibility for their actions in the field” (Eureka Reporter, 7-12), and he isn't “comfortable with deputizing code enforcement investigators if they are not his employees” (Times-Standard, 7-12). As is often the case with Mr. Gallegos, the truth is otherwise.
For over seven years I was employed by the California District Attorneys Association as a “circuit prosecutor,” in which I was deputized by elected district attorneys in three counties, including by Gallegos. As my legal authority flowed from these elected DA's to me, at all times I answered in my actions as a deputy DA directly to them. On numerous occasions I pointed out this fact to my supervisors in Sacramento, who sometimes felt that they, as my employer, could direct me in my exercise of the DA's authority.
Mr. Gallegos seeks to have it both ways. He has deputized these peace officers, who act under his authority as code enforcement officers, yet claims he cannot control them as his deputies. This is hogwash. The solution is obvious: Insist that these deputies operate subject to his oversight or remove their authority.
It remains unfortunate that our chief law enforcement officer refuses to take responsibility for his actions, placing blame elsewhere. Citizens should rightly expect leadership and honesty, not platitudes and excuses.
Paul Hagen
Eureka
***
Update: July 22, 2008 Well! That drew a response from the long dormant Salzman Communications Director, once again struggling to defend Paul Gallegos. What don't you know? The Emperor's clothes are spun of the finest silk! With 24 karat gold embroidery on the hem, and the finest jewels on the bodice. Can't you see it? If you can't, according to the chief deceptor Michael Twombly, you must be a "disgruntled" ex-employee. One who was FIRED thanks to Gallegos. Michael Twombly must be the last rat on this sinking ship. Looks like he's trying to thwart anyone running against his boy.
Hagen should do his homework - Letter to the Editor
Mr. Hagen's screed about the District Attorney's problems with Humboldt's code officers (Hogwash, Mr. Gallegos) a is little but a disgruntled ex-employee's self-serving run-up to challenging Gallegos in the next DA election.
Mr. Hagen's circuit prosecutor position with the DA's Association in years past is not comparable to the “mutant structure” in which Gallegos has no legal authority over code enforcers, but as DA has official responsibility for their irresponsible, dangerous and provocative activities.
This is an obviously intolerable position for any district attorney and needs to be fixed.
In fact, Gallegos states that that deputies must either operate responsibly under his authority or lose their deputy status under the DA's office.
This seems pretty reasonable.
Mr. Hagen needs to do his homework before throwing his hogwash hat in the ring.
Michael Twombly
Bayside
Scared, Mr. Twombly. So quick to jump to the defense. Of the utterly indefensible.
7.16.2008
TS - Gundersen turns down plea deal
Gundersen turns down plea deal
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen, who is facing 28 felony charges, turned down a plea deal that could have landed him in prison for anywhere from nine to 26 years, attorneys said in court Tuesday.
”We rejected it in its entirety,” Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton said of the deal, in which Gundersen would have pleaded guilty to one count of spousal rape and another of forcibly raping a second victim. “Our position is that the defendant has no criminal liability.”
After Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson asked for a progress report on settlement discussions, District Attorney Paul Gallegos said he had offered the plea deal and Clanton said the defense declined it.
The defense, Clanton said, would only be agreeable to a deal in which Gundersen would plead guilty to one of the misdemeanor counts he is facing in exchange for dismissing the remaining 30 charges.
Watson asked Gundersen if he had been informed of the plea bargain discussions and if Clanton had accurately represented them.
”Yes, sir,” replied Gundersen, who sat next to Clanton during his brief court appearance Tuesday clad in a red jumpsuit.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8 and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail, again pleaded not guilty to all charges Tuesday after Gallegos filed amended charges with 31 counts, including 24 charges of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, forcible rape of a second victim with a firearm enhancement, attempting to dissuade a witness, violating a court order and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer.
Jury selection was slated to start Tuesday, but was pushed back until today in order to allow Clanton and Gallegos time to put together a jury questionnaire that would probe potential jurors on their general ability to hear the case fairly. Watson also asked court staff to put together a hardship questionnaire for potential jurors and, in doing so, estimated the trial would take up to 10 weeks.
Watson also heard oral arguments regarding two motions Clanton filed last month seeking a change of venue and to have the charges of spousal rape tried separately from the charges of forcibly raping a second victim.
Watson essentially put the change of venue motion on hold, saying he would wait to see if it looks like an impartial jury can be seated in the case before ruling on the motion.
On the second motion, Clanton argued that the spousal rape charges concerning Jane Doe 1 are inherently different than the forcible rape charge regarding Jane Doe 2. The alleged acts are separated by seven or eight years, involve two different victims and two distinct sets of circumstances, Clanton argued.
Clanton also argued that Jane Doe 2 is an unreliable witness and, consequently, the forcible rape charge is much weaker than those concerning Gundersen's alleged conduct with Jane Doe 1.
”I've been a defense attorney for years and I can honestly say I don't think I've ever seen a case with such a weak set of facts brought before a jury,” Clanton said of the forcible rape charge.
He said the potential for prejudice in trying the charges together is “just overwhelming,” as the stronger Jane Doe 1 charges would likely buttress the weaker Jane Doe 2 charge in the jury's eyes.
In response, Gallegos argued that the charges are related as they both involve “the use of another person's body against their will for one's own sexual gratification.”
Further, Gallegos argued that if the charges were tried separately, the evidence would be admissible anyway.
Watson took the matter under submission, but did not say when he would issue a ruling.
After Tuesday's court appearance, Clanton said he was glad Watson checked in on settlement talks because it helps ensure both sides are communicating about the case. However, Clanton said he and Gallegos are far apart in plea discussions and reiterated that the only plea Gundersen would accept is a misdemeanor charge, and that would only be to avoid a trial in which the defendant faces virtually a life sentence if convicted on all charges.
”That's the only thing we would ever plea to,” Clanton said. “There is no chance in the world we would plea to anything that involves felony culpability. He has no criminal liability in any of this.”
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/16/2008 01:30:31 AM PDT
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen, who is facing 28 felony charges, turned down a plea deal that could have landed him in prison for anywhere from nine to 26 years, attorneys said in court Tuesday.
”We rejected it in its entirety,” Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton said of the deal, in which Gundersen would have pleaded guilty to one count of spousal rape and another of forcibly raping a second victim. “Our position is that the defendant has no criminal liability.”
After Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson asked for a progress report on settlement discussions, District Attorney Paul Gallegos said he had offered the plea deal and Clanton said the defense declined it.
The defense, Clanton said, would only be agreeable to a deal in which Gundersen would plead guilty to one of the misdemeanor counts he is facing in exchange for dismissing the remaining 30 charges.
Watson asked Gundersen if he had been informed of the plea bargain discussions and if Clanton had accurately represented them.
”Yes, sir,” replied Gundersen, who sat next to Clanton during his brief court appearance Tuesday clad in a red jumpsuit.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8 and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail, again pleaded not guilty to all charges Tuesday after Gallegos filed amended charges with 31 counts, including 24 charges of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, forcible rape of a second victim with a firearm enhancement, attempting to dissuade a witness, violating a court order and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer.
Jury selection was slated to start Tuesday, but was pushed back until today in order to allow Clanton and Gallegos time to put together a jury questionnaire that would probe potential jurors on their general ability to hear the case fairly. Watson also asked court staff to put together a hardship questionnaire for potential jurors and, in doing so, estimated the trial would take up to 10 weeks.
Watson also heard oral arguments regarding two motions Clanton filed last month seeking a change of venue and to have the charges of spousal rape tried separately from the charges of forcibly raping a second victim.
Watson essentially put the change of venue motion on hold, saying he would wait to see if it looks like an impartial jury can be seated in the case before ruling on the motion.
On the second motion, Clanton argued that the spousal rape charges concerning Jane Doe 1 are inherently different than the forcible rape charge regarding Jane Doe 2. The alleged acts are separated by seven or eight years, involve two different victims and two distinct sets of circumstances, Clanton argued.
Clanton also argued that Jane Doe 2 is an unreliable witness and, consequently, the forcible rape charge is much weaker than those concerning Gundersen's alleged conduct with Jane Doe 1.
”I've been a defense attorney for years and I can honestly say I don't think I've ever seen a case with such a weak set of facts brought before a jury,” Clanton said of the forcible rape charge.
He said the potential for prejudice in trying the charges together is “just overwhelming,” as the stronger Jane Doe 1 charges would likely buttress the weaker Jane Doe 2 charge in the jury's eyes.
In response, Gallegos argued that the charges are related as they both involve “the use of another person's body against their will for one's own sexual gratification.”
Further, Gallegos argued that if the charges were tried separately, the evidence would be admissible anyway.
Watson took the matter under submission, but did not say when he would issue a ruling.
After Tuesday's court appearance, Clanton said he was glad Watson checked in on settlement talks because it helps ensure both sides are communicating about the case. However, Clanton said he and Gallegos are far apart in plea discussions and reiterated that the only plea Gundersen would accept is a misdemeanor charge, and that would only be to avoid a trial in which the defendant faces virtually a life sentence if convicted on all charges.
”That's the only thing we would ever plea to,” Clanton said. “There is no chance in the world we would plea to anything that involves felony culpability. He has no criminal liability in any of this.”
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/16/2008 01:30:31 AM PDT
7.15.2008
ER - Two charges against Gundersen dismissed
ER Two charges against Gundersen dismissed
The Humboldt County Superior Court dismissed two of the 26 counts of spousal rape charged against former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen in a ruling filed Monday.
The court also upheld a ruling from Gundersen’s preliminary hearing that reduced a kidnapping to commit rape charge, with a firearm enhancement, to forcible rape with said enhancement — one of two charges that involve Jane Doe 2.
The ruling came in response to a motion filed by Russell Clanton, Gundersen’s defense attorney, to dismiss all the charges against his client during a hearing on July 9.
News of the ruling came Monday morning at the start of Gundersen’s trial, with two motions awaiting a decision by the new presiding judge, Superior Court Judge W. Bruce Watson, and the expectation that the jury selection process will be a long one.
The charges against Gundersen have varied over the months, as the Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office tacked on more and as judges reduced or dismissed some.
Gundersen is now being charged with 24 counts of alleged spousal rape with an intoxicant, along with seven other charges, including two related to firearms, for a total of 31 charges.
Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles, who originally presided over the case, dismissed two counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant charged against Gundersen after reviewing transcripts from his preliminary hearing in April.
Miles said in her ruling that the time period discussed by both the prosecution and defense went as far as 2007.
During the preliminary hearing, Jane Doe 1 testified that Gundersen had non-consensual sex with her about once a month between 2005 and 2007.
Since two of the counts of alleged spousal rape against Gundersen occurred in January 2008 and February 2008, she dismissed both of them.
As for the charge against Gundersen of kidnapping to commit rape, Miles agreed with Superior Court Judge John T. Feeney’s ruling that there was insufficient evidence to hold him to that charge.
“While the evidence shows that Jane Doe was forcibly moved from the front room to the bedroom ... the evidence does not show that this movement substantially increased the risk of physical harm (over and above that) necessarily present in the commission of rape,” Miles wrote in her ruling.
Although Clanton thought Miles’ decision was accurate, he believed there were other counts that could have been dismissed.
He said he still has two pending motions for the court to consider: one requesting a change of venue and another asking to try the charges pertaining to Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 separately.
Due to the expected length of time of the trial, the availability of courtrooms and Superior Court Judge Paul Cissna being disqualified, Watson will now preside over the trial.
The jury selection process, which District Attorney Paul Gallegos said could take three to four weeks, begins this morning.
He said he would like a pool of at least 70 jurors, 12 of whom would eventually hear the case.
A pool of jurors will be asked if they have any hardships that may interfere with the trial, which is expected to last about a month.
Those that move on will be individually questioned to determine if there are any pre-established biases to the case. The possible corruption of the juror pool due to extensive media coverage was among the reasons Clanton requested the trial be conducted elsewhere.
***
Same day TS Judge dismisses three charges facing Gundersen
Related coverage, with links to all stories
The Humboldt County Superior Court dismissed two of the 26 counts of spousal rape charged against former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen in a ruling filed Monday.
The court also upheld a ruling from Gundersen’s preliminary hearing that reduced a kidnapping to commit rape charge, with a firearm enhancement, to forcible rape with said enhancement — one of two charges that involve Jane Doe 2.
The ruling came in response to a motion filed by Russell Clanton, Gundersen’s defense attorney, to dismiss all the charges against his client during a hearing on July 9.
News of the ruling came Monday morning at the start of Gundersen’s trial, with two motions awaiting a decision by the new presiding judge, Superior Court Judge W. Bruce Watson, and the expectation that the jury selection process will be a long one.
The charges against Gundersen have varied over the months, as the Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office tacked on more and as judges reduced or dismissed some.
Gundersen is now being charged with 24 counts of alleged spousal rape with an intoxicant, along with seven other charges, including two related to firearms, for a total of 31 charges.
Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles, who originally presided over the case, dismissed two counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant charged against Gundersen after reviewing transcripts from his preliminary hearing in April.
Miles said in her ruling that the time period discussed by both the prosecution and defense went as far as 2007.
During the preliminary hearing, Jane Doe 1 testified that Gundersen had non-consensual sex with her about once a month between 2005 and 2007.
Since two of the counts of alleged spousal rape against Gundersen occurred in January 2008 and February 2008, she dismissed both of them.
As for the charge against Gundersen of kidnapping to commit rape, Miles agreed with Superior Court Judge John T. Feeney’s ruling that there was insufficient evidence to hold him to that charge.
“While the evidence shows that Jane Doe was forcibly moved from the front room to the bedroom ... the evidence does not show that this movement substantially increased the risk of physical harm (over and above that) necessarily present in the commission of rape,” Miles wrote in her ruling.
Although Clanton thought Miles’ decision was accurate, he believed there were other counts that could have been dismissed.
He said he still has two pending motions for the court to consider: one requesting a change of venue and another asking to try the charges pertaining to Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 separately.
Due to the expected length of time of the trial, the availability of courtrooms and Superior Court Judge Paul Cissna being disqualified, Watson will now preside over the trial.
The jury selection process, which District Attorney Paul Gallegos said could take three to four weeks, begins this morning.
He said he would like a pool of at least 70 jurors, 12 of whom would eventually hear the case.
A pool of jurors will be asked if they have any hardships that may interfere with the trial, which is expected to last about a month.
Those that move on will be individually questioned to determine if there are any pre-established biases to the case. The possible corruption of the juror pool due to extensive media coverage was among the reasons Clanton requested the trial be conducted elsewhere.
***
Same day TS Judge dismisses three charges facing Gundersen
Related coverage, with links to all stories
TS - Judge dismisses three charges facing Gundersen
TS Judge dismisses three charges facing Gundersen
Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles dismissed three of the 33 charges facing former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen in a written ruling issued Monday.
Miles dismissed two of the 26 spousal rape charges as well as the charge of transporting a second victim for the purpose of rape. She left room for District Attorney Paul Gallegos to file a lesser charge, saying evidence presented during Gundersen's preliminary hearing supports a charge of forcible rape with a firearm enhancement.
After reading Miles' decision, Gallegos notified the court of his intent to add the forcible rape charge to his case against the former police chief.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8, will now face 31 charges, including 29 felonies, assuming Gallegos adds the forcible rape charge. He has pleaded not guilty and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail.
In a motion filed with the court June 27, Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton sought the dismissal of all the charges facing his client, arguing there was not enough evidence presented during Gundersen's preliminary hearing to support them.
In her ruling, Miles agreed on two of the counts, finding the prosecution failed to present evidence to warrant holding Gundersen to stand trial on charges that he raped his wife with the use of an intoxicant in January 2008 and on Feb. 7, 2008. Miles found sufficient evidence to hold Gundersen to stand trial on the other 24 counts of spousal rape, one count for every month in 2006 and 2007.
After Gundersen's preliminary hearing, Judge John Feeney reduced the charge of kidnapping or transporting a second victim for the purpose of rape to forcible rape, but Gallegos said he respectfully disagreed with the court's decision and re-filed the count as initially charged. In her ruling Monday, Miles agreed with Feeney.
”The court finds that the evidence presented at the preliminary hearing does not show such a state of facts as would leave a person of ordinary caution and prudence to believe and conscientiously entertain a strong suspicion of the guilt of the defendant of an aggravated kidnapping,” Miles states in the ruling. “The court agrees with the magistrate that the evidence is sufficient to support a charge of forcible rape under Penal Code section 261(a)(2), and the firearm enhancement.”
If Gallegos files the new charge, Gundersen will face a total of 31 counts: 24 charges of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, forcible rape of a second victim, attempting to dissuade a witness, violating a court order, acting unlawfully with department records, possessing a controlled substance without a prescription and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer attached.
Clanton said Monday he felt Miles' ruling was accurate regarding the actions she took, but that he obviously felt there were other actions she could have taken but did not. For his part, Gallegos said he agreed with the ruling.
Jury selection, which was slated to begin Monday, was also pushed back a day and is scheduled to begin this morning.
The case was moved to Judge Bruce Watson's courtroom because Miles' courtroom is currently occupied with an ongoing trial.
The court suggested having Judge Timothy Cissna hear the case, but Clanton issued a preemptory challenge on the grounds that Cissna is prejudiced against he or his client, leaving the case in Watson's hands.
That means Watson will also be left to rule on two motions filed by Clanton late last month seeking a change of venue and to have the spousal rape charges tried separately from the count concerning a second victim.
Generally, courts wait to hear change of venue motions until the jury selection process begins and potential jurors are questioned for possible bias. Gallegos said he expects jury selection to begin today with jurors filling out hardship forms and questionnaires regarding media coverage and other issues that may create bias toward the case.
Gallegos said he expects jury selection to take around one month.
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/15/2008 01:27:41 AM PDT
***
Same day ER Two charges against Gundersen dismissed
Related coverage, with links to all stories
Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles dismissed three of the 33 charges facing former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen in a written ruling issued Monday.
Miles dismissed two of the 26 spousal rape charges as well as the charge of transporting a second victim for the purpose of rape. She left room for District Attorney Paul Gallegos to file a lesser charge, saying evidence presented during Gundersen's preliminary hearing supports a charge of forcible rape with a firearm enhancement.
After reading Miles' decision, Gallegos notified the court of his intent to add the forcible rape charge to his case against the former police chief.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8, will now face 31 charges, including 29 felonies, assuming Gallegos adds the forcible rape charge. He has pleaded not guilty and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail.
In a motion filed with the court June 27, Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton sought the dismissal of all the charges facing his client, arguing there was not enough evidence presented during Gundersen's preliminary hearing to support them.
In her ruling, Miles agreed on two of the counts, finding the prosecution failed to present evidence to warrant holding Gundersen to stand trial on charges that he raped his wife with the use of an intoxicant in January 2008 and on Feb. 7, 2008. Miles found sufficient evidence to hold Gundersen to stand trial on the other 24 counts of spousal rape, one count for every month in 2006 and 2007.
After Gundersen's preliminary hearing, Judge John Feeney reduced the charge of kidnapping or transporting a second victim for the purpose of rape to forcible rape, but Gallegos said he respectfully disagreed with the court's decision and re-filed the count as initially charged. In her ruling Monday, Miles agreed with Feeney.
”The court finds that the evidence presented at the preliminary hearing does not show such a state of facts as would leave a person of ordinary caution and prudence to believe and conscientiously entertain a strong suspicion of the guilt of the defendant of an aggravated kidnapping,” Miles states in the ruling. “The court agrees with the magistrate that the evidence is sufficient to support a charge of forcible rape under Penal Code section 261(a)(2), and the firearm enhancement.”
If Gallegos files the new charge, Gundersen will face a total of 31 counts: 24 charges of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, forcible rape of a second victim, attempting to dissuade a witness, violating a court order, acting unlawfully with department records, possessing a controlled substance without a prescription and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer attached.
Clanton said Monday he felt Miles' ruling was accurate regarding the actions she took, but that he obviously felt there were other actions she could have taken but did not. For his part, Gallegos said he agreed with the ruling.
Jury selection, which was slated to begin Monday, was also pushed back a day and is scheduled to begin this morning.
The case was moved to Judge Bruce Watson's courtroom because Miles' courtroom is currently occupied with an ongoing trial.
The court suggested having Judge Timothy Cissna hear the case, but Clanton issued a preemptory challenge on the grounds that Cissna is prejudiced against he or his client, leaving the case in Watson's hands.
That means Watson will also be left to rule on two motions filed by Clanton late last month seeking a change of venue and to have the spousal rape charges tried separately from the count concerning a second victim.
Generally, courts wait to hear change of venue motions until the jury selection process begins and potential jurors are questioned for possible bias. Gallegos said he expects jury selection to begin today with jurors filling out hardship forms and questionnaires regarding media coverage and other issues that may create bias toward the case.
Gallegos said he expects jury selection to take around one month.
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/15/2008 01:27:41 AM PDT
***
Same day ER Two charges against Gundersen dismissed
Related coverage, with links to all stories
7.14.2008
TS Gallegos: Doing 'more with less' Jan 18, 2006
Posted on Gallegos' campaign site, contains all the Gallegos talking points including glossing over the loss of prosecutors. Now we know that he hasn't been able to fill those vacant positions, and, we also know a bit more about why those prosecutors left.
Currently, seven deputy district attorneys have been with the office longer than three years: Andrew Isaac, Maggie Flemming, Max Cardoza, Stacey Eades, Wes Keat, Worth Dikeman and Zachary Bird. was the statement then. Who is left now? Maggie Fleming, Max Cardoza, and Wes Keat.
Gallegos: Doing 'more with less'
EUREKA -- District Attorney Paul Gallegos recently lost his seventh attorney since taking office in January 2003, but he said it hasn't affected prosecutions.
”In fact, since I've been in office, Humboldt County has experienced the lowest rate of violent crime since 1990,” Gallegos stated in an e-mail. “In addition, based on the information I have from the Department of Corrections, we also have had Humboldt County's highest level of prison commitments since I've been in office.”
There are currently two open positions, which Gallegos anticipates filling “relatively soon.”
Currently, seven deputy district attorneys have been with the office longer than three years: Andrew Isaac, Maggie Flemming, Max Cardoza, Stacey Eades, Wes Keat, Worth Dikeman and Zachary Bird.
Four deputy district attorneys have been in the office less than three years: Amanda Penny, Jeff Schwartz, Jose Mendes and Nicole Hanson, although Hanson is on two-month leave studying to become a solicitor in England.
Of the five deputies who have quit -- Rob Wade, Heather Gimle, Ed Borg, Tim Stoen and Shane Hauschild -- four took jobs as prosecutors in other counties and one went into private practice. Wade took a job in Napa County, and Borg and Hauschild now work in Lake County. In June of last year, Stoen accepted a position as the financial crime prosecutor in Mendocino County.
Another attorney, Allison Jackson, was fired from the office in June 2004. Gimle and Jackson now work for the Harlan Law Firm. In May 2003, Gloria Albin Sheets was laid off from the office.
”We don't have a problem with attorneys wanting to stay,” Gallegos wrote. “Most district attorney's offices, just like most large- and medium-sized law firms, experience and expect a certain amount of attrition.”
Gallegos said the reasons for attorneys leaving include that they can make more money in private practice and as prosecutors elsewhere.
”Deputies that leave our office to practice as prosecutors elsewhere make more money and have significantly reduced caseloads,” Gallegos wrote.
He did write that it's hard to attract younger attorneys to the area.
”A challenge we face with younger attorneys is that they are far from home and/or friends from college and/or law school and there are few of the attractions that a larger urban area provides,” Gallegos said.
from The Times-Standard | News Articles | by Chris Durant | Jan 18, 2006
Related:
They tried to tell you
Seeking excellence?
Whistling in the dark
Gallegos Loses FOUR More
And so it goes...
Question, really, is "Who's left?" w/update
Lost another one...
Tuesday's BOS meeting w/UPDATE
Currently, seven deputy district attorneys have been with the office longer than three years: Andrew Isaac, Maggie Flemming, Max Cardoza, Stacey Eades, Wes Keat, Worth Dikeman and Zachary Bird. was the statement then. Who is left now? Maggie Fleming, Max Cardoza, and Wes Keat.
Gallegos: Doing 'more with less'
EUREKA -- District Attorney Paul Gallegos recently lost his seventh attorney since taking office in January 2003, but he said it hasn't affected prosecutions.
”In fact, since I've been in office, Humboldt County has experienced the lowest rate of violent crime since 1990,” Gallegos stated in an e-mail. “In addition, based on the information I have from the Department of Corrections, we also have had Humboldt County's highest level of prison commitments since I've been in office.”
There are currently two open positions, which Gallegos anticipates filling “relatively soon.”
Currently, seven deputy district attorneys have been with the office longer than three years: Andrew Isaac, Maggie Flemming, Max Cardoza, Stacey Eades, Wes Keat, Worth Dikeman and Zachary Bird.
Four deputy district attorneys have been in the office less than three years: Amanda Penny, Jeff Schwartz, Jose Mendes and Nicole Hanson, although Hanson is on two-month leave studying to become a solicitor in England.
Of the five deputies who have quit -- Rob Wade, Heather Gimle, Ed Borg, Tim Stoen and Shane Hauschild -- four took jobs as prosecutors in other counties and one went into private practice. Wade took a job in Napa County, and Borg and Hauschild now work in Lake County. In June of last year, Stoen accepted a position as the financial crime prosecutor in Mendocino County.
Another attorney, Allison Jackson, was fired from the office in June 2004. Gimle and Jackson now work for the Harlan Law Firm. In May 2003, Gloria Albin Sheets was laid off from the office.
”We don't have a problem with attorneys wanting to stay,” Gallegos wrote. “Most district attorney's offices, just like most large- and medium-sized law firms, experience and expect a certain amount of attrition.”
Gallegos said the reasons for attorneys leaving include that they can make more money in private practice and as prosecutors elsewhere.
”Deputies that leave our office to practice as prosecutors elsewhere make more money and have significantly reduced caseloads,” Gallegos wrote.
He did write that it's hard to attract younger attorneys to the area.
”A challenge we face with younger attorneys is that they are far from home and/or friends from college and/or law school and there are few of the attractions that a larger urban area provides,” Gallegos said.
from The Times-Standard | News Articles | by Chris Durant | Jan 18, 2006
Related:
They tried to tell you
Seeking excellence?
Whistling in the dark
Gallegos Loses FOUR More
And so it goes...
Question, really, is "Who's left?" w/update
Lost another one...
Tuesday's BOS meeting w/UPDATE
TS - Gundersen trial jury selection slated to begin
TS Gundersen trial jury selection slated to begin
Jury selection is slated to start today in former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's rape trial, and it's expected to be a long, thorough process.
”It would be mind-boggling if it only took two weeks,” District Attorney Paul Gallegos said Friday, adding that he expects the selection process to last about a month.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8, faces 30 felony charges, including 26 counts of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, kidnapping or transporting a second victim with the purpose of rape, attempting to dissuade a victim of a crime, violating a court order and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a an attached silencer.
Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all counts and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail.
After Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, recently filed a motion seeking a change of venue for the trial, Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles deferred any decision on the motion until the start of jury selection, but said she would allow Clanton to question jurors for potential bias.
Gallegos said he and Clanton likely will work together to craft a jury questionnaire to pass out in addition to the hardship questionnaire that will be given out to potential jurors because the trial is expected to last longer than a month.
Clanton was not immediately available for comment.
In his motion for a change of venue, Clanton argues that Gundersen's and the alleged victim's stature in the community, the sordid nature of the allegations and the intense media coverage of the case combine to necessitate a change of venue to ensure a fair hearing.
The questionnaires are likely to follow those lines and ask questions about potential jurors' views of law enforcement, their personal history with rape, what newspapers they read, how closely they've followed the case and if they have an opinion as to Gundersen's guilt or innocence.
Responses to the last question likely will hold the key to whether Miles grants the change of venue, according to University of California Hastings School of Law professor David Levine.
”Just because you heard a little bit about (the case) doesn't mean you can't hear the case,” Levine said in a previous interview with the Times-Standard. “The question is, can you put aside what you've heard and judge the case solely on the evidence?”
Gallegos said the first stages of jury selection will likely just consist of streams of potential jurors coming in and filling out the questionnaires, which the prosecution and defense will then pore through to determine if an unbiased jury can be formed.
It's also possible Miles could issue a ruling today on the defense's motion to have some of the charges facing Gundersen dismissed.
After hearing brief arguments on the motion from both sides at a hearing last week, Miles took the matter under submission and said she would issue a ruling before the trial begins. It remains unclear if she intends to file the ruling before the start of jury selection or the start of the actual trial.
Miles may also issue a ruling Monday on the defense's motions to have the charge of transporting or kidnapping a second victim with the purpose of rape tried separately from the spousal rape charges.
In his motion, Clanton argued that the charges are unrelated and that trying them together would strengthen the prosecution's case. In his opposition, Gallegos countered that even if the cases were tried separately, the testimony of both alleged victims would be admissible in both trials according to the California Evidence Code.
Timeline
November 1999 -- David Gundersen is hired on as the chief of police in Blue Lake.
Feb. 8, 2008 -- Gundersen is arrested on suspicion of raping his spouse, who at the time was a sergeant with the Blue Lake Police Department.
Feb. 12, 2008 -- Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, decries the investigation into his client as a witch hunt, says it stems out of Gundersen's custody dispute with his ex-wife and accuses the state of sticking its nose into Gundersen's bedroom.
Feb. 13, 2008 -- The District Attorney's Office charges Gundersen with 12 counts of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, as well as charges of dissuading a witness, violating a court order and possessing a controlled substance without a prescription. He pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Feb. 27, 2008 -- The DA's Office files four new charges against Gundersen, including kidnapping or transporting a second victim for the purpose of rape and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer.
April 30, 2008 -- Humboldt County Superior Court Judge John Feeney holds Gundersen to stand trial on 19 charges after his preliminary hearing.
May 5, 2008 -- The City of Blue Lake officially terminates its contract with Gundersen as the city's chief of police after a unanimous vote by the City Council.
May 12, 2008 -- Gundersen is re-arraigned on 33 charges, including 30 felonies, after the DA's Office files additional counts
based on information presented in the preliminary hearing. Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all counts.
Today -- Jury selection is scheduled to begin in Gundersen's trial.
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/14/2008 01:31:34 AM PDT
Related coverage, with links
Jury selection is slated to start today in former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's rape trial, and it's expected to be a long, thorough process.
”It would be mind-boggling if it only took two weeks,” District Attorney Paul Gallegos said Friday, adding that he expects the selection process to last about a month.
Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8, faces 30 felony charges, including 26 counts of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, kidnapping or transporting a second victim with the purpose of rape, attempting to dissuade a victim of a crime, violating a court order and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a an attached silencer.
Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all counts and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail.
After Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, recently filed a motion seeking a change of venue for the trial, Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles deferred any decision on the motion until the start of jury selection, but said she would allow Clanton to question jurors for potential bias.
Gallegos said he and Clanton likely will work together to craft a jury questionnaire to pass out in addition to the hardship questionnaire that will be given out to potential jurors because the trial is expected to last longer than a month.
Clanton was not immediately available for comment.
In his motion for a change of venue, Clanton argues that Gundersen's and the alleged victim's stature in the community, the sordid nature of the allegations and the intense media coverage of the case combine to necessitate a change of venue to ensure a fair hearing.
The questionnaires are likely to follow those lines and ask questions about potential jurors' views of law enforcement, their personal history with rape, what newspapers they read, how closely they've followed the case and if they have an opinion as to Gundersen's guilt or innocence.
Responses to the last question likely will hold the key to whether Miles grants the change of venue, according to University of California Hastings School of Law professor David Levine.
”Just because you heard a little bit about (the case) doesn't mean you can't hear the case,” Levine said in a previous interview with the Times-Standard. “The question is, can you put aside what you've heard and judge the case solely on the evidence?”
Gallegos said the first stages of jury selection will likely just consist of streams of potential jurors coming in and filling out the questionnaires, which the prosecution and defense will then pore through to determine if an unbiased jury can be formed.
It's also possible Miles could issue a ruling today on the defense's motion to have some of the charges facing Gundersen dismissed.
After hearing brief arguments on the motion from both sides at a hearing last week, Miles took the matter under submission and said she would issue a ruling before the trial begins. It remains unclear if she intends to file the ruling before the start of jury selection or the start of the actual trial.
Miles may also issue a ruling Monday on the defense's motions to have the charge of transporting or kidnapping a second victim with the purpose of rape tried separately from the spousal rape charges.
In his motion, Clanton argued that the charges are unrelated and that trying them together would strengthen the prosecution's case. In his opposition, Gallegos countered that even if the cases were tried separately, the testimony of both alleged victims would be admissible in both trials according to the California Evidence Code.
Timeline
November 1999 -- David Gundersen is hired on as the chief of police in Blue Lake.
Feb. 8, 2008 -- Gundersen is arrested on suspicion of raping his spouse, who at the time was a sergeant with the Blue Lake Police Department.
Feb. 12, 2008 -- Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, decries the investigation into his client as a witch hunt, says it stems out of Gundersen's custody dispute with his ex-wife and accuses the state of sticking its nose into Gundersen's bedroom.
Feb. 13, 2008 -- The District Attorney's Office charges Gundersen with 12 counts of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, as well as charges of dissuading a witness, violating a court order and possessing a controlled substance without a prescription. He pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Feb. 27, 2008 -- The DA's Office files four new charges against Gundersen, including kidnapping or transporting a second victim for the purpose of rape and possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer.
April 30, 2008 -- Humboldt County Superior Court Judge John Feeney holds Gundersen to stand trial on 19 charges after his preliminary hearing.
May 5, 2008 -- The City of Blue Lake officially terminates its contract with Gundersen as the city's chief of police after a unanimous vote by the City Council.
May 12, 2008 -- Gundersen is re-arraigned on 33 charges, including 30 felonies, after the DA's Office files additional counts
based on information presented in the preliminary hearing. Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all counts.
Today -- Jury selection is scheduled to begin in Gundersen's trial.
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 07/14/2008 01:31:34 AM PDT
Related coverage, with links