Blue Lake changed policy to allow Gundersen, wife to work together
The city of Blue Lake changed its policy on spouses working together in the same department three years ago to avoid finding new supervisors for the police department, officials said.
Although it is unclear if Chief David Gundersen, who is facing 12 counts of spousal rape in addition to seven other charges, and his current wife, a Blue Lake police department sergeant, were married at the time, the City Council felt it was necessary to address their personal relationship with an ordinance, said City Manager Wiley Buck.
Gundersen has pleaded not guilty to all of the charges.
”The whole issue was we had no mechanism, if there was a problem, to avoid any problems with relationships,” Buck said.
He said he was not sure if they were married at the time the ordinance was passed, but even a live-in situation can lead to issues that would affect a couple who work together.
Blue Lake hired its police sergeant in September 1999 and hired Gundersen in November 1999.
Marriage licenses are recorded in individual counties and can be confidential. There is no public record of their marriage in Humboldt County.
The ordinance, which was put in place in February 2005, removed restrictions on spouses working together in the same department, but also gave the City Council authority to take action if problems did arise.
”If it wasn't working professionally then we had options in terms of changing the employment status of one or the other,” said Councilwoman Marlene Smith. She said Buck brought the matter before the council because Gundersen and his wife had been working outside of the policy.
”It was suggested that we revisit the policy and see if we could make it fit the situation,” said Smith, adding that it would have been hard for Blue Lake to replace one or both of its only supervising officers.
The city is currently facing the difficulties of a lack of supervising officers. Since Gundersen and his wife are both on administrative leave, the remaining two officers have been unable to do regular patrolling duties without a supervisor, officials said.
”It's one of those issues that we felt that we were kind stuck in the middle,” said Mayor Sherman Shapiro of the 2005 ordinance. Being a small city, Shapiro said it would have been harder to find replacements, but the ordinance is something the council will be reviewing.
Smith agreed.
”We're going to revisit this and see if we can't do something that's a little bit different, a little bit better,” Smith said. “In my opinion, it was a decision we made that in hindsight proved to be not wise.”
Donna Tam can be reached at 441-0532 or dtam@times-standard.com.
Donna Tam/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/28/2008 01:27:20 AM PST
2.27.2008
‘Fatal funnel’ for law enforcement in Cheri Lyn Moore stand off
Last November, during the criminal grand jury investigation into the death of Cheri Lyn Moore, Eureka Police Department Detective and acting SWAT team commander Todd Wilcox referred to Moore’s doorway as the “fatal funnel in law enforcement.”
“We don’t know what’s inside,” he said.
EPD Officer and SWAT assistant team-leader Rodrigo Reyna-Sanchez told the grand jury that SWAT was acting as an arrest-react team when they entered Moore’s apartment.
The rules of engagement — according to EPD policy — are not to use lethal force unless necessary to protect a hostage, innocent bystanders, the police or the suspect, he said.
According to the officers who testified, Moore had threatened citizens with fire and the police by pointing her flare gun at them.
At 12:33 p.m. on April 14, 2006 — the day Moore was killed — EPD Officer Robert Mengel radioed to SWAT that Moore’s hands were empty. Sanchez breached the door, and four armed EPD officers entered.
Officer Rocky Harpham entered first with a Benelli semiautomatic 12-gauge shotgun — followed by Sgt. Mike Johnson, carrying an AR15 rifle.
Officer Tim Jones was next with a FN303 less-lethal kinetic energy projectile, and Officer Terrance Liles — also carrying a Benelli — entered fourth. After grabbing a handgun, Sanchez followed.
Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos asked why the team had maximum firepower up-front.
“It’s a credible threat and we want to go in there behind as much firepower as we can to protect ourselves,” Sanchez said.
Jones testified that a long gun — such as a rifle or shotgun — has a better chance of stopping a threat more quickly.
Gallegos asked why the less-lethal weapon wasn’t fired first.
“(Using a less-lethal weapon without lethal cover) really puts the less-lethal operator at risk of losing his-or-her life or being injured,” Jones said. “Commands had been given, but at the time when she pointed (the weapon) at us, we were kind of out-of-time at that
point, in fear for our safety.”
On Dec. 3, the grand jury handed up indictments for then-acting EPD Chief David Douglas and Lt. Antonio Zanotti, incident commander, determining that their actions may have been negligent — resulting in manslaughter. No charges have yet been filed against either.
Gallegos questioned why SWAT entered Moore’s apartment before negotiations were exhausted.
EPD Dispatcher Keziah Moss testified that Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services - Mental Health Branch employee Craig Pasquini requested a welfare check on Moore that day.
The EPD routinely performs welfare checks on MHB patients when the public or another agency is concerned about their welfare.
Moss testified that Pasquini told her, “(Moore) was despondent over — suicidal over — the death of her son 12 years ago (and) that she had purchased a 12-gauge flare gun. ... She (Moore) was threatening to burn down the building and kill everyone inside.”
The SWAT team was not informed that EPD conducted a welfare check on Moore four days earlier, or other information about her welfare, such as threats to burn down the building down on Mothers’ Day.
Individual officers were aware of Moore’s behavior and health based on their own experiences, not information that the Crisis Negotiation Team provided.
Harpham told the grand jury that he was not aware that Moore intended to go to a court hearing at 1 p.m. that day. Nor did he know that Moore’s friend had delivered cigarettes to the EPD that she had requested.
“Did you understand that Ms. Moore had indicated that if she was provided those cigarettes she would come out peacefully?” Gallegos asked.
Harpham replied, no.
Would the information about Moore wanting cigarettes and to make a court appearance at 1 p.m. have been helpful information in formulating a plan? Gallegos asked Sanchez.
“If we had gotten that information, we would have incorporated that into our plans,” Sanchez said.
Sanchez testified that the CNT information was given to Zanotti, and he gives it to Wilcox — who informs the SWAT team.
Gallegos asked CNT supervisor Lt. Lynne Soderberg, if there were any attempts to tell Moore that her cigarettes had arrived before the SWAT team went in.
“I don’t believe we had any communication with her to be able to start that,” Soderberg said. She testified that postponing the plan until that was communicated was not an option.
In other stand-offs, when the suspect had put their handgun down, negotiations continued and SWAT did not enter, Soderberg said, according to the transcripts. This case was different because of the threat of fire, she said.
Wilcox’s testimony mirrored that statement. Even if he knew Moore planned on attending court, the plan to enter when she put the gun down would have stood, he said, according to the transcripts.
“We were trying to deal with what we felt was an emergency potential threat,” Wilcox told the grand jury.
Despite how negotiations were going, the plan was for SWAT to enter the building because Moore’s threats affected innocent citizens, and she had threatened police during the welfare check, according to several officers’ testimonies.
“We essentially were ready to go regardless of what the negotiations are,” Sanchez said, according to the transcripts.
Harpham testified that he didn’t think SWAT needed a warrant to enter Moore’s apartment, based on his understanding of Penal Code 835 (A).
“If a peace officer has a reasonable suspicion that a crime has occurred, he is allowed to use reasonable force to effect an arrest,” he said.
Under the circumstances, the EPD felt they had a hot pursuit situation, Harpham continued. A hot pursuit is an exigent circumstance where the Supreme Court has said that officers don’t need a warrant, he explained to the grand jury.
When the EPD arrived to conduct a welfare check that morning, Moore’s landlord unlocked her door for them, and according to several officers’ testimonies, she pointed the flare gun at them.
“They had a firearm brandished at them which was a serious felony,” Harpham testified.
By EMILY WILSON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Feb 26 2008, 11:19 PM
List of Cheri Moore related coverage with links
here
Last November, during the criminal grand jury investigation into the death of Cheri Lyn Moore, Eureka Police Department Detective and acting SWAT team commander Todd Wilcox referred to Moore’s doorway as the “fatal funnel in law enforcement.”
“We don’t know what’s inside,” he said.
EPD Officer and SWAT assistant team-leader Rodrigo Reyna-Sanchez told the grand jury that SWAT was acting as an arrest-react team when they entered Moore’s apartment.
The rules of engagement — according to EPD policy — are not to use lethal force unless necessary to protect a hostage, innocent bystanders, the police or the suspect, he said.
According to the officers who testified, Moore had threatened citizens with fire and the police by pointing her flare gun at them.
At 12:33 p.m. on April 14, 2006 — the day Moore was killed — EPD Officer Robert Mengel radioed to SWAT that Moore’s hands were empty. Sanchez breached the door, and four armed EPD officers entered.
Officer Rocky Harpham entered first with a Benelli semiautomatic 12-gauge shotgun — followed by Sgt. Mike Johnson, carrying an AR15 rifle.
Officer Tim Jones was next with a FN303 less-lethal kinetic energy projectile, and Officer Terrance Liles — also carrying a Benelli — entered fourth. After grabbing a handgun, Sanchez followed.
Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos asked why the team had maximum firepower up-front.
“It’s a credible threat and we want to go in there behind as much firepower as we can to protect ourselves,” Sanchez said.
Jones testified that a long gun — such as a rifle or shotgun — has a better chance of stopping a threat more quickly.
Gallegos asked why the less-lethal weapon wasn’t fired first.
“(Using a less-lethal weapon without lethal cover) really puts the less-lethal operator at risk of losing his-or-her life or being injured,” Jones said. “Commands had been given, but at the time when she pointed (the weapon) at us, we were kind of out-of-time at that
point, in fear for our safety.”
On Dec. 3, the grand jury handed up indictments for then-acting EPD Chief David Douglas and Lt. Antonio Zanotti, incident commander, determining that their actions may have been negligent — resulting in manslaughter. No charges have yet been filed against either.
Gallegos questioned why SWAT entered Moore’s apartment before negotiations were exhausted.
EPD Dispatcher Keziah Moss testified that Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services - Mental Health Branch employee Craig Pasquini requested a welfare check on Moore that day.
The EPD routinely performs welfare checks on MHB patients when the public or another agency is concerned about their welfare.
Moss testified that Pasquini told her, “(Moore) was despondent over — suicidal over — the death of her son 12 years ago (and) that she had purchased a 12-gauge flare gun. ... She (Moore) was threatening to burn down the building and kill everyone inside.”
The SWAT team was not informed that EPD conducted a welfare check on Moore four days earlier, or other information about her welfare, such as threats to burn down the building down on Mothers’ Day.
Individual officers were aware of Moore’s behavior and health based on their own experiences, not information that the Crisis Negotiation Team provided.
Harpham told the grand jury that he was not aware that Moore intended to go to a court hearing at 1 p.m. that day. Nor did he know that Moore’s friend had delivered cigarettes to the EPD that she had requested.
“Did you understand that Ms. Moore had indicated that if she was provided those cigarettes she would come out peacefully?” Gallegos asked.
Harpham replied, no.
Would the information about Moore wanting cigarettes and to make a court appearance at 1 p.m. have been helpful information in formulating a plan? Gallegos asked Sanchez.
“If we had gotten that information, we would have incorporated that into our plans,” Sanchez said.
Sanchez testified that the CNT information was given to Zanotti, and he gives it to Wilcox — who informs the SWAT team.
Gallegos asked CNT supervisor Lt. Lynne Soderberg, if there were any attempts to tell Moore that her cigarettes had arrived before the SWAT team went in.
“I don’t believe we had any communication with her to be able to start that,” Soderberg said. She testified that postponing the plan until that was communicated was not an option.
In other stand-offs, when the suspect had put their handgun down, negotiations continued and SWAT did not enter, Soderberg said, according to the transcripts. This case was different because of the threat of fire, she said.
Wilcox’s testimony mirrored that statement. Even if he knew Moore planned on attending court, the plan to enter when she put the gun down would have stood, he said, according to the transcripts.
“We were trying to deal with what we felt was an emergency potential threat,” Wilcox told the grand jury.
Despite how negotiations were going, the plan was for SWAT to enter the building because Moore’s threats affected innocent citizens, and she had threatened police during the welfare check, according to several officers’ testimonies.
“We essentially were ready to go regardless of what the negotiations are,” Sanchez said, according to the transcripts.
Harpham testified that he didn’t think SWAT needed a warrant to enter Moore’s apartment, based on his understanding of Penal Code 835 (A).
“If a peace officer has a reasonable suspicion that a crime has occurred, he is allowed to use reasonable force to effect an arrest,” he said.
Under the circumstances, the EPD felt they had a hot pursuit situation, Harpham continued. A hot pursuit is an exigent circumstance where the Supreme Court has said that officers don’t need a warrant, he explained to the grand jury.
When the EPD arrived to conduct a welfare check that morning, Moore’s landlord unlocked her door for them, and according to several officers’ testimonies, she pointed the flare gun at them.
“They had a firearm brandished at them which was a serious felony,” Harpham testified.
By EMILY WILSON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Feb 26 2008, 11:19 PM
List of Cheri Moore related coverage with links
here
2.26.2008
Larry Glass, Mark Lovelace and CREG
Interesting looking back at Larry Glass' involvement and statements about the Marina Center... and look, there's Mark Lovelace in a prominent position... it's all the usual suspects, "Baykeeper" too...
From: "Mark Lovelace" mailto:mail@healthyhumboldt.org
Date: March 22, 2006 9:47:02 AM PST
To: "Healthy Humboldt Coalition" mail@healthyhumboldt.org
Subject: Home Depot poses economic, cleanup concerns
Reply-To: "Mark Lovelace" mail@healthyhumboldt.org
Development poses economic, cleanup concerns, group says
Thadeus Greenson
March 22, 2006
EUREKA -- Members of the newly formed Citizens for Real Economic Growth expressed concerns about the environmental and economic impacts of the proposed Balloon Tract development Tuesday night during a presentation at the Humboldt County Democratic Central Committee (HCDCC) headquarters.
About 45 people attended the presentation and the following question and answer period, both of which were rushed along due to the time constraints of a following HCDCC business meeting.
Citing an array of economic studies, as well as city and county planning documents, Citizens for Real Economic Growth members Larry Glass and Mark Lovelace argued that the proposed Balloon Tract development goes against city and county plans for development and would irrevocably harm the local economy.
Security National owners Rob and Cherie Arkley are proposing to build a 400,000-square-foot development on the Balloon Tract that will include shops, restaurants, office space, a Home Depot, the Discovery Museum and lofts on an adjacent parcel. The Arkleys will be asking the city to change the site's zoning from public to commercial and industrial to pave the way for the project.
”Why are we pursuing this?” Lovelace asked rhetorically. “It goes against everything that's on paper about economic development in Humboldt County and the use of this property and it goes directly against the will of the voters.”
The will of the voters to which Lovelace referred, was a 1999 ballot measure in which Wal-Mart tried to obtain a similar zoning change that was rejected by a 61 percent margin.
Lovelace cited a number of economic studies regarding the impact of Home Depot stores on competing hardware businesses. He said not only would a Home Depot take major amounts of business away from some 200 local retailers, but it would siphon that money directly out of the local economy.
”There's a wealth of information on the Web, and I would really encourage people to go out there and seek it out,” Lovelace said. “Don't just take my word for it, go out and do your homework.”
During his portion of the presentation, Glass said he feels like the public is being left out of the Balloon Tract decision-making process and lambasted the city of Eureka for not aggressively pursuing the clean-up of the site that was left contaminated by Union Pacific Railroads.
Pete Nichols, director of Humboldt Bay Keeper, was in attendance and said major issues remain surrounding the contamination of the site that will be addressed either during negotiations with Union Pacific in the coming weeks or ultimately with a lawsuit.
Security National Senior Vice President Brian Morrissey attended the presentation and said afterward that, while he didn't agree with everything being said, he thinks these types of public information meetings are important. He added that Security National is confident that the majority of Eureka supports this project.
Security National will hold an open house today focusing on environmental issues. Panelists who have worked on the site or have brownfield expertise will be available to answer questions at the open house, which will be held from 6 to 9 p.m. at the Red Lion in Eureka.
From: "Mark Lovelace" mailto:mail@healthyhumboldt.org
Date: March 22, 2006 9:47:02 AM PST
To: "Healthy Humboldt Coalition" mail@healthyhumboldt.org
Subject: Home Depot poses economic, cleanup concerns
Reply-To: "Mark Lovelace" mail@healthyhumboldt.org
Development poses economic, cleanup concerns, group says
Thadeus Greenson
March 22, 2006
EUREKA -- Members of the newly formed Citizens for Real Economic Growth expressed concerns about the environmental and economic impacts of the proposed Balloon Tract development Tuesday night during a presentation at the Humboldt County Democratic Central Committee (HCDCC) headquarters.
About 45 people attended the presentation and the following question and answer period, both of which were rushed along due to the time constraints of a following HCDCC business meeting.
Citing an array of economic studies, as well as city and county planning documents, Citizens for Real Economic Growth members Larry Glass and Mark Lovelace argued that the proposed Balloon Tract development goes against city and county plans for development and would irrevocably harm the local economy.
Security National owners Rob and Cherie Arkley are proposing to build a 400,000-square-foot development on the Balloon Tract that will include shops, restaurants, office space, a Home Depot, the Discovery Museum and lofts on an adjacent parcel. The Arkleys will be asking the city to change the site's zoning from public to commercial and industrial to pave the way for the project.
”Why are we pursuing this?” Lovelace asked rhetorically. “It goes against everything that's on paper about economic development in Humboldt County and the use of this property and it goes directly against the will of the voters.”
The will of the voters to which Lovelace referred, was a 1999 ballot measure in which Wal-Mart tried to obtain a similar zoning change that was rejected by a 61 percent margin.
Lovelace cited a number of economic studies regarding the impact of Home Depot stores on competing hardware businesses. He said not only would a Home Depot take major amounts of business away from some 200 local retailers, but it would siphon that money directly out of the local economy.
”There's a wealth of information on the Web, and I would really encourage people to go out there and seek it out,” Lovelace said. “Don't just take my word for it, go out and do your homework.”
During his portion of the presentation, Glass said he feels like the public is being left out of the Balloon Tract decision-making process and lambasted the city of Eureka for not aggressively pursuing the clean-up of the site that was left contaminated by Union Pacific Railroads.
Pete Nichols, director of Humboldt Bay Keeper, was in attendance and said major issues remain surrounding the contamination of the site that will be addressed either during negotiations with Union Pacific in the coming weeks or ultimately with a lawsuit.
Security National Senior Vice President Brian Morrissey attended the presentation and said afterward that, while he didn't agree with everything being said, he thinks these types of public information meetings are important. He added that Security National is confident that the majority of Eureka supports this project.
Security National will hold an open house today focusing on environmental issues. Panelists who have worked on the site or have brownfield expertise will be available to answer questions at the open house, which will be held from 6 to 9 p.m. at the Red Lion in Eureka.
2.24.2008
TS - Police commanders' defense to file motion for dismissal
Police commanders' defense to file motion for dismissal
Defense attorneys for former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Tony Zanotti weighed in last week on what they perceive to be flaws in the case against their clients, and their intent to file multiple motions to dismiss the case in the near future.
The two defendants were indicted Dec. 3 by a criminal grand jury on charges of involuntary manslaughter stemming from their decision making roles in an April 2006 standoff, which left 48-year-old Cheri Lyn Moore riddled with police bullets.
Transcripts of the grand jury proceedings -- unsealed by a superior court judge this week after a series of legal motions on behalf of the Times-Standard -- show District Attorney Paul Gallegos' case hinges in part on the defendants' having failed to get a Ramey warrant before entering Moore's apartment and the concept of criminal negligence.
The defense argued against the judge's unsealing the documents, saying Gallegos' instructions to the grand jury contained erroneous statements of law that could prejudice the entire jury pool if widely disseminated. Friday, William Rapoport, Zanotti's attorney, and Bill Bragg, who is representing Douglas, elaborated on their stance.
”You have bad law being argued to citizens by the chief law enforcement officer in the county [Gallegos], so citizens are bound to think he knows what he's talking about,” Rapoport said, adding that a variety “fundamental” and “esoteric” errors
Advertisement
in Gallegos' interpretation of the law would be the subject of an upcoming motion to dismiss by the defendants.
Bragg said Friday one of the larger flaws in Gallegos' argument is that he fails to thoroughly instruct the jury on the topic of exigent circumstances, or whether the standoff situation posed a grave and immediate enough threat to the community to justify forcing a warrant-less entry into Moore's apartment.
Moore, who had a history of mental illness and was reportedly distraught over the anniversary of her son's death, brandished a flare gun at officers, threw things out of her second-story apartment window and threatened to burn the building down during the two-hour standoff that preceded her April 14, 2006 death.
Officers have said they believed Moore had put down the flare gun when the decision was made to storm her apartment but, upon entering, SWAT team members said Moore pointed the weapon at them. She was shot nine times.
While instructing the grand jury, Gallegos calls into question whether such exigent circumstances really existed.
That police set up the SWAT command center in the same building, failed to fully evacuate the building and didn't evacuate adjacent buildings, Gallegos said, shows the police did not perceive Moore as an imminent threat.
”These are things which you can all consider to determine whether they thought there was a risk that this building was going to suddenly burn down and they needed to get in there,” Gallegos told the jury. “That is important because if you don't need to get in there, there are no exigent circumstances.”
Bragg said Friday Gallegos failed to instruct the jury explicitly on what exigent circumstances are, and how they are evaluated by a SWAT team operation.
”My recollection is that there was nothing represented to the grand jury as to what the standard of care would be in a SWAT response scenario,” Bragg said.
Drawing a parallel to medical malpractice cases, Bragg said SWAT operations are so far out of an average juror's knowledge base that Gallegos needed to provide a SWAT team standard for the jury to compare the Eureka team's actions against.
The question, Bragg said, is not just what the jurors would have done in their shoes, but what another, rational, trained professional would do in their shoes.
”There has to be some evidence presented for what the standard of care is for that particular profession, and the instance in which that professional was operating,” Bragg said. “There are standards for SWAT conduct, and there are experts in SWAT procedures out there that could have been presented.”
The general topic of experts is also a point of contention for the defense.
Gallegos called expert witness George Williams to testify during the proceedings. Williams, a police training specialist, called the case a “clear case of suicide by cop,” and went on to call the SWAT operation “extraordinarily” well handled.
In his concluding grand jury instructions, Gallegos tears apart Williams credentials as an expert, and essentially asks the grand jury to disregard the expert witness' testimony.
”This is a gentleman who has never been a police officer,” Gallegos told the jury. “He has never been a SWAT officer. He has never been in a supervisory role that we are aware of. He was never trained in SWAT tactics. Quite simply... his summary of qualifications though impressive as to particular things is lacking as it relates to the facts that he gave an opinion as to, and that is the appropriateness and the decision making of the supervisorial staff, Chief Douglas and Lt. Zanotti on April 14, 2006.”
Bragg and Rapoport seemed to disagree on why Gallegos called Williams to testify. Bragg said it was based on Rapoport's suggestion, and Rapoport said it was because Williams had submitted a report to the coroner's office on the case. Either way, both agreed that if Gallegos didn't think Williams was a qualified expert witness, the district attorney should have called someone else.
”There in fact should be someone who is qualified,” Bragg said. “If (Gallegos) felt that fellow wasn't qualified, why didn't he bring in someone he did feel was qualified to discuss SWAT procedures so the grand jury could have had a better understanding?”
Declining to elaborate too much on the defense strategy, saying he wanted to try the case in the courtroom and not in the newspapers, Rapoport said Williams' testimony will also be the subject of a future motion to dismiss the case.
”The DA chooses his witness,” Rapoport said. “He obviously did in this case. ... That's something that again is going to be the subject of a legal motion in the future.”
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/24/2008 01:34:12 AM PST
Defense attorneys for former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Tony Zanotti weighed in last week on what they perceive to be flaws in the case against their clients, and their intent to file multiple motions to dismiss the case in the near future.
The two defendants were indicted Dec. 3 by a criminal grand jury on charges of involuntary manslaughter stemming from their decision making roles in an April 2006 standoff, which left 48-year-old Cheri Lyn Moore riddled with police bullets.
Transcripts of the grand jury proceedings -- unsealed by a superior court judge this week after a series of legal motions on behalf of the Times-Standard -- show District Attorney Paul Gallegos' case hinges in part on the defendants' having failed to get a Ramey warrant before entering Moore's apartment and the concept of criminal negligence.
The defense argued against the judge's unsealing the documents, saying Gallegos' instructions to the grand jury contained erroneous statements of law that could prejudice the entire jury pool if widely disseminated. Friday, William Rapoport, Zanotti's attorney, and Bill Bragg, who is representing Douglas, elaborated on their stance.
”You have bad law being argued to citizens by the chief law enforcement officer in the county [Gallegos], so citizens are bound to think he knows what he's talking about,” Rapoport said, adding that a variety “fundamental” and “esoteric” errors
Advertisement
in Gallegos' interpretation of the law would be the subject of an upcoming motion to dismiss by the defendants.
Bragg said Friday one of the larger flaws in Gallegos' argument is that he fails to thoroughly instruct the jury on the topic of exigent circumstances, or whether the standoff situation posed a grave and immediate enough threat to the community to justify forcing a warrant-less entry into Moore's apartment.
Moore, who had a history of mental illness and was reportedly distraught over the anniversary of her son's death, brandished a flare gun at officers, threw things out of her second-story apartment window and threatened to burn the building down during the two-hour standoff that preceded her April 14, 2006 death.
Officers have said they believed Moore had put down the flare gun when the decision was made to storm her apartment but, upon entering, SWAT team members said Moore pointed the weapon at them. She was shot nine times.
While instructing the grand jury, Gallegos calls into question whether such exigent circumstances really existed.
That police set up the SWAT command center in the same building, failed to fully evacuate the building and didn't evacuate adjacent buildings, Gallegos said, shows the police did not perceive Moore as an imminent threat.
”These are things which you can all consider to determine whether they thought there was a risk that this building was going to suddenly burn down and they needed to get in there,” Gallegos told the jury. “That is important because if you don't need to get in there, there are no exigent circumstances.”
Bragg said Friday Gallegos failed to instruct the jury explicitly on what exigent circumstances are, and how they are evaluated by a SWAT team operation.
”My recollection is that there was nothing represented to the grand jury as to what the standard of care would be in a SWAT response scenario,” Bragg said.
Drawing a parallel to medical malpractice cases, Bragg said SWAT operations are so far out of an average juror's knowledge base that Gallegos needed to provide a SWAT team standard for the jury to compare the Eureka team's actions against.
The question, Bragg said, is not just what the jurors would have done in their shoes, but what another, rational, trained professional would do in their shoes.
”There has to be some evidence presented for what the standard of care is for that particular profession, and the instance in which that professional was operating,” Bragg said. “There are standards for SWAT conduct, and there are experts in SWAT procedures out there that could have been presented.”
The general topic of experts is also a point of contention for the defense.
Gallegos called expert witness George Williams to testify during the proceedings. Williams, a police training specialist, called the case a “clear case of suicide by cop,” and went on to call the SWAT operation “extraordinarily” well handled.
In his concluding grand jury instructions, Gallegos tears apart Williams credentials as an expert, and essentially asks the grand jury to disregard the expert witness' testimony.
”This is a gentleman who has never been a police officer,” Gallegos told the jury. “He has never been a SWAT officer. He has never been in a supervisory role that we are aware of. He was never trained in SWAT tactics. Quite simply... his summary of qualifications though impressive as to particular things is lacking as it relates to the facts that he gave an opinion as to, and that is the appropriateness and the decision making of the supervisorial staff, Chief Douglas and Lt. Zanotti on April 14, 2006.”
Bragg and Rapoport seemed to disagree on why Gallegos called Williams to testify. Bragg said it was based on Rapoport's suggestion, and Rapoport said it was because Williams had submitted a report to the coroner's office on the case. Either way, both agreed that if Gallegos didn't think Williams was a qualified expert witness, the district attorney should have called someone else.
”There in fact should be someone who is qualified,” Bragg said. “If (Gallegos) felt that fellow wasn't qualified, why didn't he bring in someone he did feel was qualified to discuss SWAT procedures so the grand jury could have had a better understanding?”
Declining to elaborate too much on the defense strategy, saying he wanted to try the case in the courtroom and not in the newspapers, Rapoport said Williams' testimony will also be the subject of a future motion to dismiss the case.
”The DA chooses his witness,” Rapoport said. “He obviously did in this case. ... That's something that again is going to be the subject of a legal motion in the future.”
Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/24/2008 01:34:12 AM PST
2.22.2008
TS - Judge continues Douglas-Zanotti arraignment

Judge continues Douglas-Zanotti arraignment
Superior Court Judge Timothy Cissna agreed Thursday to continue the arraignment of former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Tony Zanotti on involuntary manslaughter charges for the shooting death of Cheri Lyn Moore until April 1.
Deputy District Attorney Maggie Fleming said District Attorney Paul Gallegos and the defense agreed to the continuation to give the defense time to receive and review copies of the evidence exhibits presented during the criminal grand jury proceedings.
Meanwhile, experts on law and police procedure gave the Times-Standard their views about the case, and information contained in recently unsealed transcripts of the grand jury proceedings that led to the indictment of the two commanding officers.
The District Attorney's Office officially announced on Dec. 10 that the criminal grand jury convened to look into the April 14, 2006 police shooting death of Moore indicted Douglas and Zanotti for their decision-making roles in the incident.
Moore, who had a history of mental illness and was reportedly distraught over the anniversary of her son's death, brandished a flare gun, threw items out the window of her second-story apartment and threatened to burn the building down during the more than two-hour standoff.
Officers have said they believed Moore put down the flare gun when the decision was made to storm her apartment but, upon entering, SWAT team members said Moore pointed the weapon at them. She was shot nine times.
Nearly two dozen uniformed officers were on hand for Douglas and Zanotti's court appearance, in addition to a handful of Eureka city officials, including Mayor Virginia Bass and City Manager David Tyson. Almost every seat in the courtroom was taken.
The two defendants were briskly escorted through the hallway and into the courtroom prior to the hearing, and left immediately after its conclusion.
Cissna presided over Thursday's hearing, but made clear it is Superior Court Judge John Feeney's case.
”I will not handle this case -- I'm handling the arraignment because my colleague is sick,” Cissna said, adding that he otherwise would disqualify himself, as he has known Douglas for years.
Gallegos' case
Transcripts from the grand jury proceedings, obtained Tuesday by the Times-Standard after Feeney granted the paper's motion to unseal the nearly 2,000 document, indicate Gallegos' case hinges on the SWAT team's decision not to get a Ramey warrant before entering Moore's apartment, and the concept of criminal negligence.
A Ramey warrant is issued before a suspect is charged with a crime, sometimes with the intent to get more evidence on a suspected crime. It is a warrant issued by a judge, and does not require a case to be sent to a prosecutor first.
While instructing the grand jury on how to consider whether to indict Douglas and Zanotti, Gallegos raises the subject of a welfare check, where officers can legally enter a residence to check on a person's well-being.
”If they have to break in your door to get you, we want them to do that,” Gallegos told the jury. “But, if their objective is to arrest an individual or to seize evidence, the United States Constitution puts a requirement on them.”
In this case, Gallegos argues that requirement is a Ramey warrant.
Gallegos also spends a good portion of his instructions to the grand jury going over the concept of criminal negligence.
”A person acts with criminal negligence when he or she acts in a reckless way that creates a high risk of death or great bodily injury, and a reasonable person would have known that acting that way would create such a risk,” Gallegos told the jury.
Gallegos goes on to state his belief that a reasonable person would conclude that sending officers into Moore's apartment would create a “high risk of death or great bodily injury.”
Taking on the concept of exigent circumstances, or the idea that the situation represented a grave and immediate danger to the community, Gallegos tells the jury that the police made a variety of decisions on April 14, 2006 that show that was not the case. Police actions that day, Gallegos argues, show police commanders did not believe the threat of a flare-ignited fire to be grave.
That police set up the SWAT command center in the same building, failed to fully evacuate the building and didn't evacuate adjacent buildings, Gallegos said, shows the police did not perceive Moore as an imminent threat.
”These are things which you can all consider to determine whether they thought there was a risk that this building was going to suddenly burn down and they need to get in there,” Gallegos told the jury. “That is important because if you don't need to suddenly get in there, there are no exigent circumstances.”
Defense attorneys Bill Bragg and William Rapoport were not immediately available for comment.
A police perspective
Police experts interviewed by the Times-Standard offered different opinions on how the circumstances of the Moore standoff played out, and whether commanders should have sought a warrant.
Ronald R. Scott, a former commanding officer of the Massachusetts State Police Ballistics Section who has spent 25 years investigating shootings and police-related shootings, said seeking a warrant may have allowed a higher authority to raise concerns about how police wanted to proceed.
He questioned how concerned police were about a fire and why the SWAT team was ordered into the apartment before negotiations were considered over. Scott said it is impossible to know, however, if the outcome would be any different if a warrant had been obtained.
”I just think it's a small step that could have possibly influenced what the commander on the scene did,” Scott said.
One of the cases Gallegos used in his arguments to the grand jury was a hostage scenario that unfolded in Fortuna in September 2005. Michael Allman was barricaded in his Newell Drive home along with his young son. Fortuna Police first responded, then the Eureka SWAT team arrived, and later the county SWAT team. After about 12 hours, Allman released the boy, but the standoff lasted almost another 20 hours.
Officers were unable to see Allman inside the house, Fortuna Police Chief Kris Kitna testified before the grand jury, and determined it was too dangerous to enter the residence. Sometime after the boy was released, Kitna and other law enforcement officials decided to get a Ramey warrant to enter the house. When the SWAT team went inside, they found Allman dead, shot by his own gun.
Kitna also said there are circumstances in which police can enter without a warrant.
”Certainly we can enter without the warrant under exigent circumstances, when it is life or death or when evidence is being destroyed, but normally you need that Ramey warrant to enter absent any special circumstances,” Kitna said.
The Fortuna case is substantially different than the Moore case, and experts disagree about whether special circumstances existed during the Eureka standoff.
Lou Reiter has been a consultant on police misconduct for 27 years, and is a former deputy chief of the Los Angeles Police Department, now based in Rhode Island. He said the Eureka case is strange because of the criminal charges being brought, and questioned what could be criminal about inadequate supervision. There are civil remedies in those types of cases, he said.
To prosecute the commanding officers, Reiter said, it would seem that the district attorney would have to convince a jury that they directly ordered the SWAT officers to kick in Moore's door and shoot her.
A warrant is not usually obtained in the early hours of a standoff, he said.
”For the most part it's rarely done, particularly when you're dealing with an emotionally disturbed person,” Reiter said.
A legal perspective
University of California Hastings College of Law professor David Levine said he's often heard of similar cases being dealt with in civil and administrative arenas, but criminal charges are a different ball game.
”It just seems to me when it's criminal, you really want to be able to point to chapter and verse and say, 'No good police officer would do X, Y and Z,” Levine said.
The decision not to get a warrant, Levine said, amounts to a judgment call -- one that can certainly be second-guessed, but one that will be hard to prove is a criminal act.
While Levine said it sounds like commanding officers could have better handled the events of that April day, he said the prosecution will likely have to show that the defendants showed a conscious disregard of the risks of their actions -- no easy task. Levine said judgment calls that appear poor in hindsight probably won't cut it.
”Without being an expert in police procedure, it just seems like it's really hard to second guess something like that,” he said.
Levine said it is far more common for officers to be criminally charged when it's clear they acted with malice.
As an example, he pointed to a 1997 New York case where officers were convicted after they pinned down a man in a New York precinct and sodomized him with a broomstick. In that case, two officers were convicted of assault and four were convicted of lying to investigators.
Another example Levine pointed to was a 1999 case where a criminal grand jury returned second degree murder and reckless endangerment indictments against officers who fired 41 shots at an unarmed New York man, hitting him 19 times. Those officers were acquitted of all charges, but the case garnered widespread public outrage.
”Those are the kinds of extreme cases that lead to criminal charges,” Levine said.
University of Nebraska at Omaha Criminal Justice professor emeritus Samuel Walker, an expert on police accountability, said it sounds like officers could have done a lot of things differently, but also questioned whether the case belonged in the criminal arena.
”Criminal conviction of a police officer is very difficult to achieve in any event, unless it's a corruption charge where you can prove that money went from one hand to another,” Walker said.
John Driscoll and Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/22/2008 01:31:03 AM PST
ER - Arraignment continued second time, charges exposed
Arraignment continued second time, charges exposed
The arraignment scheduled on Thursday in the Humboldt County Courthouse for former Eureka Police Department Chief David Douglas and EPD Lt. Antonio Zanotti was continued until April 1.
Their original arraignment date was set for Jan. 1, but it was continued until Feb. 21 — when it was continued again.
When arraigned, defendants are read the charges against them and enter a plea. A not-guilty plea activates a citizen’s right to a trial by their peers.
A Humboldt County criminal grand jury handed up an indictment for Douglas and Zanotti on Dec. 3 — accusing them of involuntary manslaughter — an alleged violation of Penal Code Section 192 (b) — for their leadership roles in the death of Cheri Lyn Moore on April 14, 2006.
Douglas’ attorney, Bill Bragg and Zanotti’s attorney, William Rapoport requested the continuance because they have not received more than 100 exhibits admitted to the grand jury as evidence.
The majority of men and women in the packed courtroom indicated they were in support of the defendants — many wore law enforcement uniforms with some displaying badges.
EPD Sgt. Steve Watson was present during Moore’s death and said he was in court to support the defendants.
Speaking for all the uniformed officers he said, “They have our absolute support — without a doubt.”
Presiding Superior Court Judge Timothy P. Cissna granted the continuance to give the defense time to review all the evidence.
Deputy District Attorney Maggie Fleming — representing District Attorney Paul Gallegos — did not object.
EPD Chief Garr Nielsen said he doesn’t think the case will make it trial. “I don’t believe that the case is strong enough to warrant going to trial,” he said.
The judge may throw the case out at any time.
Transcripts from the grand jury investigation — unsealed Tuesday — include more than 1,600 pages of testimony that took place over about 10 days last fall.
Nielsen said he agreed with the defense who argued Tuesday against unsealing the portion of the transcripts where Gallegos’ instructed the jury and explained how the law applies.
Bragg wrote in a court document, “Coverage of erroneous statements of the law given by the district attorney without immediate and accurate rebuttal from an authoritative figure could very well impact my client’s ability to get a fair trial in his community.”
In a grand jury proceeding, the jury does not hear from the defense council.
According to the transcripts, Gallegos alleged that Douglas and/or Zanotti committed three acts with criminal negligence and two crimes.
The first act allegedly committed with criminal negligence, was failing to adequately supervise or direct the EPD SWAT team members in relation to Moore — a barricaded subject.
The second act alleged against the defendants is failing to adequately supervise the EPD Crisis Negotiation Team.
The third states that they failed to provide adequate communication between the EPD, SWAT and CNT — to enable them to plan and/or prepare how to respond to Moore.
Gallegos explained that a person acts with criminal negligence when their actions are so different from the way an ordinarily careful person would act in the same situation that his or her acts amount to a disregard for human life or indifference to the consequences of
that act.
The first alleged crime reportedly committed by the defendants is unauthorized destruction of property — a misdemeanor under California Penal Code Section 603.
According to the transcripts, “(It applies) to every person, other than a peace officer engaged in the performance of his duties as such who forcibly and without consent ... enters a dwelling house ... and who damages, injures or destroys any property of value in, around or appertaining to such (a) dwelling. ...”
The second alleged crime is reportedly home invasion, PC 602.5 (a). “(The law states) every person other than a public officer or employee acting within the course and scope of his or her employment in performance of a duty imposed by law, who enters or remains in any ... residential place without the consent of the owner ... or the person in lawful possession thereof is guilty of a misdemeanor.”
“The question is not whether the officers had other alternatives available to them; it is whether or not the officers acted reasonably,” Gallegos told the grand jury, according to the transcripts.
All of the grand jury members had to agree that at least one act was committed to issue an indictment — and jurors had to be in agreement about the same act or acts.
By EMILY WILSON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Feb 21 2008, 11:34 PM · Updated: Feb 22 2008, 12:10 AM
The arraignment scheduled on Thursday in the Humboldt County Courthouse for former Eureka Police Department Chief David Douglas and EPD Lt. Antonio Zanotti was continued until April 1.
Their original arraignment date was set for Jan. 1, but it was continued until Feb. 21 — when it was continued again.
When arraigned, defendants are read the charges against them and enter a plea. A not-guilty plea activates a citizen’s right to a trial by their peers.
A Humboldt County criminal grand jury handed up an indictment for Douglas and Zanotti on Dec. 3 — accusing them of involuntary manslaughter — an alleged violation of Penal Code Section 192 (b) — for their leadership roles in the death of Cheri Lyn Moore on April 14, 2006.
Douglas’ attorney, Bill Bragg and Zanotti’s attorney, William Rapoport requested the continuance because they have not received more than 100 exhibits admitted to the grand jury as evidence.
The majority of men and women in the packed courtroom indicated they were in support of the defendants — many wore law enforcement uniforms with some displaying badges.
EPD Sgt. Steve Watson was present during Moore’s death and said he was in court to support the defendants.
Speaking for all the uniformed officers he said, “They have our absolute support — without a doubt.”
Presiding Superior Court Judge Timothy P. Cissna granted the continuance to give the defense time to review all the evidence.
Deputy District Attorney Maggie Fleming — representing District Attorney Paul Gallegos — did not object.
EPD Chief Garr Nielsen said he doesn’t think the case will make it trial. “I don’t believe that the case is strong enough to warrant going to trial,” he said.
The judge may throw the case out at any time.
Transcripts from the grand jury investigation — unsealed Tuesday — include more than 1,600 pages of testimony that took place over about 10 days last fall.
Nielsen said he agreed with the defense who argued Tuesday against unsealing the portion of the transcripts where Gallegos’ instructed the jury and explained how the law applies.
Bragg wrote in a court document, “Coverage of erroneous statements of the law given by the district attorney without immediate and accurate rebuttal from an authoritative figure could very well impact my client’s ability to get a fair trial in his community.”
In a grand jury proceeding, the jury does not hear from the defense council.
According to the transcripts, Gallegos alleged that Douglas and/or Zanotti committed three acts with criminal negligence and two crimes.
The first act allegedly committed with criminal negligence, was failing to adequately supervise or direct the EPD SWAT team members in relation to Moore — a barricaded subject.
The second act alleged against the defendants is failing to adequately supervise the EPD Crisis Negotiation Team.
The third states that they failed to provide adequate communication between the EPD, SWAT and CNT — to enable them to plan and/or prepare how to respond to Moore.
Gallegos explained that a person acts with criminal negligence when their actions are so different from the way an ordinarily careful person would act in the same situation that his or her acts amount to a disregard for human life or indifference to the consequences of
that act.
The first alleged crime reportedly committed by the defendants is unauthorized destruction of property — a misdemeanor under California Penal Code Section 603.
According to the transcripts, “(It applies) to every person, other than a peace officer engaged in the performance of his duties as such who forcibly and without consent ... enters a dwelling house ... and who damages, injures or destroys any property of value in, around or appertaining to such (a) dwelling. ...”
The second alleged crime is reportedly home invasion, PC 602.5 (a). “(The law states) every person other than a public officer or employee acting within the course and scope of his or her employment in performance of a duty imposed by law, who enters or remains in any ... residential place without the consent of the owner ... or the person in lawful possession thereof is guilty of a misdemeanor.”
“The question is not whether the officers had other alternatives available to them; it is whether or not the officers acted reasonably,” Gallegos told the grand jury, according to the transcripts.
All of the grand jury members had to agree that at least one act was committed to issue an indictment — and jurors had to be in agreement about the same act or acts.
By EMILY WILSON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Feb 21 2008, 11:34 PM · Updated: Feb 22 2008, 12:10 AM
2.21.2008
TS - Commanders' arraignment in Moore case continued
Commanders' arraignment in Moore case continued
Superior Court Judge Timothy Cissna agreed today to continue the arraignment of former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Tony Zanotti on involuntary manslaughter charges until April 1.
Deputy District Attorney Maggie Fleming said District Attorney Paul Gallegos and the defense agreed to the continuation before Thursday's arraignment hearing to allow the defense time to receive and review copies of the evidence exhibits presented during the criminal grand jury proceedings.
Fleming said both sides agreed on the April 1 date.
The District Attorney's Office officially announced on Dec. 3 that a criminal grand jury convened to look into the April 14, 2006 police shooting death of Cheri Lyn Moore handed up indictments stemming from Douglas and Zanotti's decision-making roles in the incident.
Moore, who had a history of mental illness and was reportedly distraught over the anniversary of her son's death, brandished a flare gun, threw items out the window of her second-story apartment and threatened to burn the building down during the more than two-hour standoff.
Officers have said they believed Moore had put down the flare gun when the decision was made to storm her apartment but, upon entering, SWAT team members said Moore had the weapon pointed at them. Moore was shot nine times.
The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/21/2008 02:25:58 PM PST
Superior Court Judge Timothy Cissna agreed today to continue the arraignment of former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Tony Zanotti on involuntary manslaughter charges until April 1.
Deputy District Attorney Maggie Fleming said District Attorney Paul Gallegos and the defense agreed to the continuation before Thursday's arraignment hearing to allow the defense time to receive and review copies of the evidence exhibits presented during the criminal grand jury proceedings.
Fleming said both sides agreed on the April 1 date.
The District Attorney's Office officially announced on Dec. 3 that a criminal grand jury convened to look into the April 14, 2006 police shooting death of Cheri Lyn Moore handed up indictments stemming from Douglas and Zanotti's decision-making roles in the incident.
Moore, who had a history of mental illness and was reportedly distraught over the anniversary of her son's death, brandished a flare gun, threw items out the window of her second-story apartment and threatened to burn the building down during the more than two-hour standoff.
Officers have said they believed Moore had put down the flare gun when the decision was made to storm her apartment but, upon entering, SWAT team members said Moore had the weapon pointed at them. Moore was shot nine times.
The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/21/2008 02:25:58 PM PST