Pages

4.24.2007

TS - Board axes Gallegos' request for help in lawsuit

Board axes Gallegos' request for help in lawsuit
By James Tressler The Times-Standard
March 12, 2003

EUREKA -- Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos and his assistant Tim Stoen may have to go it alone in their lawsuit against Pacific Lumber Co.

After listening to more than three hours of public debate, the Board of Supervisors Tuesday by a 4-1 vote rejected the district attorney's request to contract a San Francisco Bay area law firm to act as special counsel in the lawsuit.

The board's decision was made before a packed chamber divided between PL employees and contractors, who defended the timber company, and PL critics who are standing by the district attorney's lawsuit.

The district attorney sued the timber giant last month, alleging the company concealed key information during the 1999 Headwaters negotiations that allowed it to cut timber on steep slopes that otherwise would have been off limits. The district attorney alleges PL subsequently harvested more trees than it was allowed under the agreement. The lawsuit seeks tens of millions of dollars in damages.

On Tuesday, Gallegos was asking the board to give him the OK to hire Cotchett, Pitre, Simon and McCarthy, a Burlingame firm with extensive experience in corporate fraud litigation. Although the details of the proposal were still being finalized, the firm would have kept 14.5 percent of any recovered damages. The District Attorney's Office, as was proposed Tuesday, would have paid most of the legal expenses out of its own budget.

The board, in refusing to let him contract with the firm, cited California government code 25203, which gives the board by a two-thirds vote authority to employ or not to employ outside counsel in matters of litigation affecting the county.

The majority of the board members who voted against the proposal said they didn't feel comfortable committing county dollars to the lawsuit in a year when the county faces severe state budget cuts. Also, several board members said they weren't certain the district attorney had made a convincing case against PL -- and in fact, that they had serious questions about the validity of the lawsuit.

Prior to the meeting, the board received copies of a letter the California Department of Fish and Game sent Monday to Stoen. In the letter, department officials said they believe there are factual errors in the facts presented in the lawsuit.

Chairman Jimmy Smith voiced similar doubts. He said that by supporting the outside counsel, the board risked taking a position against state agencies like Fish and Game, which has stood firm behind PL's practices since the Headwaters deal.

"I'm not being critical of the district attorney," Smith said after the meeting. "He has a big job and he makes his decisions and we'll all live by that. But ... in a case of this magnitude, we all needed individually to do what research we could to find if it's a prudent decision. We represent all of the county. The risk is there and it could be substantial."

The controversial proposal put a heavy spotlight on two of the supervisors, Roger Rodoni and Bonnie Neely. Rodoni was asked by some to recuse himself from the vote due to a perceived conflict of interest because Rodoni rents land from the timber company. Rodoni, prior to the vote, displayed comments from the Fair Political Practices Commission, which Rodoni said had no problem with him voting on the matter.

Neely is the wife of former District Attorney Terry Farmer, who Gallegos upset in last year's election. After the board's vote, Neely said her decision was not personal, but made in the interest of the county, which faces a severe budget crisis over the next year. The Fish and Game letter also influenced Neely, who said the letter affirms that the state's regulatory agencies don't appear to support the lawsuit.

"What I'm seeing is that you're standing alone," Neely said, to Gallegos and Stoen.

Neely ended her argument against the proposal by urging the district attorney to get in line behind other departments if it wants any of the county's money to pay for the lawsuit.

"You have to compete along with them in terms of money being allocated," she said.

Third District Supervisor John Woolley cast the lone vote in support of the district attorney's proposal. Before the board's vote, Woolley put forth a motion to continue the discussion for two weeks, to allow the district attorney to bring forth a finalized proposal. Fifth District Supervisor Jill Geist supported that motion, but the rest of the board voted it down.

Woolley argued unsuccessfully that while he had some serious questions himself about the lawsuit, he said the board shouldn't reject the proposal outright until they'd seen the final version.

The board's rejection for special counsel won't stop Gallegos from pursuing his lawsuit using his own budget. Nevertheless, he and Stoen tried to convince the board Tuesday that they need outside counsel to handle some of the workload so that the lawsuit won't drain too much time and resources from other cases.

After the board's vote, Gallegos seemed disappointed but unfazed.

When asked what happens next, he said, "Time for lunch."

Earlier, Gallegos stood by his controversial lawsuit, arguing that the financial cost shouldn't outweigh his responsibility to pursue what he believes are serious charges against PL. Otherwise, companies like PL, backed by high-priced corporate lawyers, would seem to be given a double standard, Gallegos said.

"Do you make decisions to prosecute a wrong based on cost? No," he said. "What is the price of the integrity of our government system?"

PL officials said they were pleased with the board's decision, saying it reinforced other support that the company has received, including from the state Attorney General's Office.

"The facts are on our side," said Jim Branham, PL's director of government relations.

Branham added that the district attorney's failure to present a convincing case to the board Tuesday could prove a telling statement "on their ability to prosecute this case."

Even before the board convened Tuesday, the outside of the courthouse was jammed with log trucks and timber industry workers, who held what they called a "right-to-work" demonstration. Some even held up "Recall the D.A." signs.

"We have to stand up for our rights," said Tony Leonardo, owner of Leonardo Trucking, which contracts with PL. "Besides putting us out of work, this lawsuit is going to cost taxpayers a lot of money whether he wins or loses.

Petrolia resident Ellen Taylor said that while she sympathized with the timber workers, she still supports the lawsuit. Taylor owns a ranch which she maintains suffered from erosion as a result of PL's logging practices.

"These workers have suffered, but in reality they cut themselves out of a job," Taylor said. "The D.A. is just performing his responsibility. ... It's very brave of him to do this."

TS - Gallegos wants Bay area firm to help with PL suit (Cotchett)

Gallegos wants Bay area firm to help with PL suit
By James Tressler The Times-Standard March 07, 2003

EUREKA -- Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos is expected to ask the Board of Supervisors next week to let him hire a powerful Bay area law firm to assist in his lawsuit against Pacific Lumber Co.

The reason he's going before supervisors is to ask them to pony up some money to help pay at least some of the legal bills. His own department's budget can't handle all of them.

The request is on the board's agenda next Tuesday. It'll likely be heard fairly early in the morning.

The Burlingame firm, Cotchett, Pitre, Simon & and McCarthy, represents California Public Employees Retirement System, the Regents of the University of California, and has represented the state Senate and Assembly. The firm has also sued Enron, WorldCom and other companies associated with corporate fraud.

According to a March 5 draft proposal signed by Joseph W. Cotchett and sent to Assistant District Attorney Tim Stoen, the firm is asking for a fee of 14.5 percent of any recovery should the district attorney's office prevail against the timber company.

The district attorney launched a suit against PL last month, alleging the timber company didn't hand over important data on landslides before the $480 million Headwaters Forest deal was signed in March 1999. That alleged deception allowed the company access to more timber each year than it would otherwise have been allowed.

It also has caused damage to slopes and streams, filled in the Humboldt Bay shipping channel with sediment, and harmed bridges, roads, homes and the property rights of Humboldt County residents, the suit claims.

In the lawsuit, Gallegos is asking PL pay damages of up to $2,500 per tree for every one cut as a result of its alleged deception surrounding the Headwaters deal. The district attorney's office has estimated the company cut 30,000 trees it shouldn't have been allowed to cut, which appears to mean the damages the district attorney is seeking are in the neighborhood of $75 million. Of that, the Bay area firm would want more than $10 million plus expenses.

According to the firm's draft proposal, the firm would serve as special counsel, while the district attorney's office would be the lead attorney and retain full control over the lawsuit.

County officials Thursday were reviewing Gallegos' request to retain the firm, and asking Gallegos supply figures on how much, if any, money would have to come out of the county's pocket. The firm will have to be paid for its time and expenses and that's likely to add up to a hefty amount if the litigation drags on and depending on how much of the work is turned over to the Burlingame firm.

County Administrative Officer Loretta Nickolaus said while the county regularly retains outside counsel on lawsuits, it's highly unusual for such counsel to be retained for the district attorney's office.

Nickolaus indicated that it's likely the district attorney's office will have to pick up the tab for retaining the firm out of its own roughly $880,000 annual budget. That might be tough to do.

The Board of Supervisors hasn't yet taken any official stance on the lawsuit. Fourth District Supervisor Bonnie Neely, wife of former District Attorney Terry Farmer, who Gallegos beat in last year's election, has criticized the new district attorney for not consulting the board before moving forward with this litigation.

The high-profile lawsuit has sparked a wide range of opinions from the public. Some, including the Environmental Protection Information Center in Garberville, which has a similar lawsuit against PL, have praised Gallegos for challenging the timber company. But others, including county supervisors Roger Rodoni and Neely, have accused Gallegos of political grandstanding and serving as a dupe for environmental special interests.

PL officials have called the suit another step toward trying to put the timber company out of business, and have said the suit is based on allegations that have already failed in the courts before.

Attempts to reach Gallegos for comment Thursday were unsuccessful. But in the wake of controversy, he has stood by his decision to file suit, telling reporters he feels obligated to respond to public concerns about environmental violations.

4.23.2007

NCJ - on Jason Singleton

I figure since I refer to predatory litigious groups like "Humboldt Baykeeper" and EPIC and the so-called "Ecological Rights Foundation" (ERF) as the environmental version of Jason Singleton, it's a good idea to keep this article to illustrate exactly what that means. Singleton is another predator, using the high ideals and good intentions of the Americans with Disabilities Act as a cash cow. These are new age con men, and predatory lawsuits are a cottage industry in Humboldt County. I suspect we are not unique.


ACCESS & DOLLARS
By Bob Doran North Coast Journal

ARMED WITH THE 10-YEAR-OLD AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, attorneys for the disabled have been breaking down barriers to access -- and collecting big fees in the process. No one knows for sure exactly how many lawsuits have been filed on behalf of clients in Humboldt County since the law took effect in 1993 because they are usually settled out of court before they ever go to trial. And once a case is settled, the parties are usually prevented from commenting publicly about it.

What is clear is that the number of ADA lawsuits is increasing, the targets of the lawsuits are changing, and attorneys welcome these types of suits in part because they always get paid.

At first the defendants tended to be deep-pocket corporate chain stores, restaurants and motels, including those operated by franchisees. Among the known past lawsuit targets are Gottschalk's, Kentucky Fried Chicken, Marie Callender's, Days Inn and the former Thunderbird Inn (Best Western) -- all in Eureka. More recently defendants have included government agencies; there are pending lawsuits against the county, College of the Redwoods and the Humboldt Bay Harbor, Recreation and Conservation District. And at least one non-profit is on the list, the Eureka Chamber of Commerce.

But the lawsuits against locally owned, private businesses with no deep pockets -- including at least one mom-and-pop operation -- are what has the business community quaking in its boots. No one is immune. Defendants with pending or recently settled ADA action include the Broadway Cinema, Café Marina, Mad River Community Hospital -- and the tiny Café Waterfront in Old Town Eureka.

When an ADA suit lands on your desk, a business owner does not have a lot of options. You either negotiate and settle -- or you fight and then settle. In extremely rare cases, the battle makes it to court.

A court fight is rare for a very good reason. The cases are virtually bullet-proof -- impossible to fight -- and defendants absorb all of the costs: They pay their own attorney, the plaintiff's attorney, court costs and the cost to correct items out of compliance. The lawyer for the plaintiff does not work on a contingency basis, a suit where they only get a share of successful settlements. They are paid regardless as long as there is a demonstrated violation.

Dan Johnson, owner of Arcata-based Danco Builders, became embroiled in an ADA suit after his company built the Days Inn on Broadway in Eureka. The Justice Department got involved when its attorneys discovered a pattern in a series of ADA suits against Days Inn franchises.

"A suit was placed on all Days Inns in America," said Johnson. "What happened was the federal inspectors came out and inspected every Days Inn in the country. They came back with a list of things that didn't meet compliance."

After the local owner of the Days Inn in Eureka was served, he brought Johnson and architect George Keating into the suit. Johnson said he was not aware that the building was not in compliance.

"The hard part from our standpoint was that we built the building per the plans and specs, and the city of Eureka signed the building off. But the plans and specs didn't meet the damn code."

The Justice Department's suit detailed five violations of ADA regulations. Among the problems was the slope of the driveway at the entry. Danco and the Eureka inspector interpreted the rules one way, but the federal inspector saw it another way and the whole area had to be redone.

At least he thought it was done. But then Eureka attorney Jason Singleton (photo below) came into the picture and filed a second ADA suit on behalf of one of his clients when he determined there were additional things out of compliance.

"The stuff that Singleton brought forth was so minute," said Johnson. "One thing was a grab bar that was 1/8th of an inch too low. Another was the location of a light that blinks when the fire alarm is going off in case a person is deaf. I think it was supposed to be something like 48 inches from the floor, and it was 52.


"Then there was a problem with the table lamp," Johnson said. "The knob that you turn it on with was supposed to be 5/8ths of an inch in circumference for people who have arthritis and such, and it was only 3/8th of an inch."

Compared to the cost of the major changes required by the first suit, bringing the motel into compliance the second time was relatively inexpensive. But this time Johnson and the other defendants also had to pay Singleton.

"The cost of the repairs we had to do based on his lawsuit were minimal; I think it was $1,000. But we spent another $50,000 in attorney fees.

"It's extortion, there's no doubt about it," said Johnson. "It was my first experience in court, let alone the federal court. We went down to the federal court in San Francisco for the hearing. The judge came in and told us point blank when we started, `You may as well settle this because you're going to lose. You might as well not fight it.' But being the macho men that we think we are, we figured we were going to fight the sucker. We stayed until 8 o'clock at night going back and forth and we ended up losing."

"It's a bounty-hunter law," said Dick Smith, Johnson's attorney and the attorney for several other defendants in local ADA suits. "It can be enforced by the Justice Department, but it has become a cottage industry for private lawyers."

Singleton, whose business card is embossed with a wheelchair symbol, says his primary focus as an attorney is on accessibility issues. He sees himself as a defender of civil rights for the disabled. He didn't set out to specialize in disability law. After attending McKinleyville High School and studying law at John F. Kennedy University in Walnut Creek, he returned to Humboldt in 1994 to open a practice in civil litigation and personal injury work. In 1998 he was working on a case involving a fall in a parking lot.

"The ADA issues kind of bled over because the parking lot wasn't laid out as the ADA requires," said Singleton. "The issues were peripheral, really, to the personal injury suit. You couldn't say that her injury was caused by the ADA violation, but I was looking into that as an option. I started getting into that area of the law researching it and I realized that there was an opportunity there to make a difference for the disabled," he said.

"I think it's pretty obvious what the goal of the law is -- it's to make our society accessible to the disabled. The arguments I hear, people say, `Well, it's so expensive. All of this is so expensive. It's such a drain on our economy to make our businesses accessible.'

"My counter to that is, if our society is not accessible, these people have to be either on permanent public dole or institutionalized. There's a cost in not making it accessible."

Singleton knows that once he brings in an access consultant to lay out the facts and he files a lawsuit, he is going to win and he will get paid.

"There is very little in the way of the defense," he admits. "In most of other civil litigation there's some wiggle room. They're he said/she said cases where there are disputed issues of fact like who ran the red light. It's up to the jury to decide whose testimony to believe.

"These are not he said/she said cases. We have color photographs. Either the ramp is there or it's not. Either they were in violation or they were not. And those issues are not subject to dispute.

"In a personal injury suit, the insurance company knows they will eventually have to pay. And if it's a large claim, they may drag it out in litigation for two or three years just so they can collect the interest on the money for that much longer. You won't do that with an ADA suit because the defendant is responsible for [all] attorneys' fees. The meter is running.

"Most defendants try to settle right at the outset. And I want to facilitate that because the sooner they settle it, the less it costs the defendant and that leaves more resources for them to make the changes."

Those who choose to fight it out in court often fare far worse than Danco Builders. Minor Theater Corp.'s owner, David Phillips, found out the hard way. His case became a virtual tar baby that ended in costs that multiplied 10-fold by the time the case was settled.

When Phillips put the Broadway Cinema multiplex together, he designed it with a number of features for the disabled. He included handicapped parking spaces and ramps, wheelchair-accessible bathrooms, spaces in the theaters for wheelchairs and a sound system with headphone plug-ins for the hearing impaired.

"Every one of those details was challenged," said Phillips, who was sued in 1999 by Singleton on behalf of his client. For example, the telephone was placed too high -- by Pacific Bell -- and handicapped parking is still not close enough to the front door.

Phillips made the required changes and he hired a Los Angeles attorney, Greg Hurley, who not only specializes in fighting disability access suits, he wrote a book about it. Settlements were rejected, the stakes kept rising, and a protracted legal battle ensued.

In the end Phillips had to concede. According to Singleton, if Phillips had settled at the start he would have paid $8,000-$10,000 in fees and a settlement award of around $9,000. By Singleton's account, the extended battle cost the Minor Theater Corp. an additional $200,000.

Phillips said the problem with the ADA regulations is that there are gray areas and the only way to resolve them is to take a case to court. But "No one can take an ADA case to a jury. It's too expensive."

One notable exception is the most famous ADA case of all -- the one starring actor/tough guy Clint Eastwood.

The case -- Zum Brunnen v. Mission Ranch -- contended that in Eastwood's multimillion dollar conversion of a historic Monterey County dairy ranch into a resort, he failed to bring restrooms, the office entryway, the parking lot and guest rooms into compliance with ADA and California's Title 24.

Last summer Eastwood testified in Washington before a judicial subcommittee in support of a bill to modify ADA law so that businesses shown to be in violation of regulations would have a 90-day grace period to make changes before a suit could be filed.

"Who in America gives these lawyers the right to be the self-appointed vigilantes to enforce the law?" Eastwood said. "Why can we not just have some decency and give persons notice that there is some problem going on?"

The bill failed and Eastwood went home to have his day in court. Ultimately a jury found they were not sure that the wheelchair bound plaintiff ever intended on staying at the resort when she visited and took photographs of ADA violations. Eastwood won his case, but because he had subsequently made modifications to bring the facility into full compliance, he still has to pay some or all of the plaintiff's attorney fees -- as well as his own.

While the majority of Singleton's ADA suits dealt with private businesses and Title III (see box), two recent cases focus attention on Title II -- access to public buildings -- and Humboldt County. One involves access to the Department of Social Services building and the other enumerates barriers to access at the County Courthouse.

Kim Kerr, county risk manager, admits that administrators were taken by surprise.

"We're not sure if we are or are not in compliance," she said. "We don't have anybody who does this every day. It's very difficult to say [what needs to be done] unless you're an expert in the area.

"We've got very old buildings and there's a question about the extent that we have to upgrade them, to make them accessible," Kerr said. "Are we required, based on the standards of a building at the time it was built, to make the adjustments?"

A major problem faced by county supervisors is the fact that the board never completed a document known as a transitional plan as required by the ADA law when it went into effect in 1993. At a meeting Feb. 27, just 10 days ago, they approved a request for proposals to hire a company to assess disability compliance. With more than 100 county-owned structures, the assessment will be a big task.

"It's a requirement of the law," said Kerr, but in the meantime, "We don't have something to work off of right now" because the County never completed the plan.

Administrative Services Director Lindsey McWilliams, the former clerk, explained in a recent memo to the Board of Supervisors: "In the early 1990s the county embarked on a survey of facilities for ADA compliance. While a committee was formed and institutional memory recalls a great deal of work accomplished and plans formulated, the principals involved are no longer with the county and the intended product of the committee's work was not completed in full."

How much will it cost the county and where will the money come from?

"Once we get the report back we'll have an idea where we are financially," Kerr said.

Will having a plan protect the county from further lawsuits?

Not necessarily, Singleton warned.

"They will still be subject to suit if there are many barriers to access or if there are barriers to access that can be quickly and inexpensively eliminated and they didn't eliminate them promptly; for example, the door pressure on the doors that is quite stiff. Something like that is just an adjustment. It takes a mechanic 10 minutes to adjust the doors."

The Eureka Chamber of Commerce is learning the hard way about the ins and outs of the ADA. Attorney Thomas Frankovich, head of a San Francisco firm that specializes in disability law, recently filed suit against the chamber over alleged access violations at the visitor center on Broadway.

J. Warren Hockaday, chamber executive director, (photo below) has a stack of papers three inches thick on his desk, material he has gathered from the Internet. He's educating himself on access rules in part to form a response to the lawsuit and in part to be able to respond to calls from nervous business owners.

"What we're trying to do right now is gather as much information about individual situations and what people can and should do -- not only for those who have been notified they may be in violation but those who have not," he said. "I understand there are some 618 different standards that can apply."

What Hockaday is discovering is that there is a difference between rules for new buildings or expansion projects, and rules for buildings that were built before the regulations were in place.

"People here (at the chamber) were generally of the belief that since this is an old building, it doesn't necessarily fall within all of the compliance requirements of ADA," he said.

What he has discovered, however, is that all businesses must make "readily achievable" changes to come into compliance. In the case of the chamber, a hand-lettered "employees only" sign has appeared notifying travellers its restroom is off limits.

What are "readily achievable" changes?

"It has to do with the nature of the changes and the expense to the business," Singleton said. "For example a large corporation like Costco, for them not to spend $4,000, $5,000, $6,000 -- or $10,000 -- to eliminate the real significant barriers to access, that's ridiculous. That would be readily achievable for them because of their economic resources.

"If you're talking about a mom-and-pop grocery store and you're asking them to rip out a structural wall to widen the bathroom 3 inches, that's probably not readily achievable. You have to look at how severe of a barrier to access you're talking about, you have to look at the expense, and then you look at the economic resources of the business owner."

"No one here or among the membership of the chamber is opposed in the slightest to providing access to people with disabilities," said Hockaday. "Businesses are not in business to say, `I don't want you eating in my restaurant or buying something in my store.' Certainly here in our visitors center we want to welcome everyone who comes to the area.

"It's about a lack of clarity as to what people and businesses are required and expected to do," he said. "We want to provide information to our members, to keep businesses in business and keep them thriving. But when you're paying out $10,000, $20,000 or $30,000 settlements -- on something that you really had no idea was a violation -- it makes it tough to stay in business.

"We're trying to do what we should do and can do to improve the situation. If it's not enough, I guess we'll find out when the next attorney shows up with a tape measure."

When it comes to a building like the Waterfront Café, (photo at left) the "reasonably achievable" question gets very complicated. The building was constructed long before the ADA or even the state's companion law, Title 24, came into effect. In fact it is certified as a historic structure.

"I didn't even know I wasn't compliant," said Diane Barmore, who owns and operates the restaurant in Old Town. "I have a building that's on the National Register of Historic Places and my understanding has always been that I could not alter the exterior of the building."

Barmore runs two restaurants in Eureka, the Waterfront and Casa Blanca, a Mexican restaurant down the street.

"At this point Casa Blanca is not involved in the suit, but that's a great source of concern. I don't even know how I could do it [bring it into compliance]. It's a beautiful place and I'd love to continue to have it be a restaurant, but it's still running in the red. That's supposed to be a factor in these cases."

According to Barmore there were no complaints received preceding the lawsuit -- no calls, no letters.

"I was just flat out presented a lawsuit," she said.

Once served, she said she has had a difficult time finding someone who knew the requirements for a historical building.

"There is no agency who could tell me what I was supposed to do," she said.

"I want to do the right thing. I already have had an architect make plans for a ramp. It will be a hassle and it will be expensive, but I'm doing it because I want to comply. I just don't like to be bullied and threatened -- and that's how I feel.

"Now I know what I'm supposed to do and I'm doing it. But the hard part is I'm still being penalized," she said.

Barmore said she had planned on upgrading her refrigeration systems this year, replacing several cooling units in response to a Health Department report. Now she's not sure if she will be able to undertake a project requiring that kind of financial commitment.

"I can't even think about doing anything else right now because I don't know how much money this suit is going to take."

She paused for a second, then added, "I don't know if I want to be in business. That's really what this has done. I don't know if I can afford to be in business."

Sidebar: Just the FACTS:

THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA) is a broad civil rights law prohibiting discrimination on the basis of disability. It was signed into law in 1990 by President George H.W. Bush.

The ADA follows the Architectural Barriers Act (ABA) of 1968, which requires access to facilities designed, built, altered or leased with federal funds, and the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 Section 504, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability in federal and federally funded programs and services.

The ADA is divided into 5 titles: Title I covers employment; Title II, government buildings and services; Title III, privately owned public accommodations; and Title IV, telecommunications access. Title V prohibits retaliation against those who assert their rights.

Technical requirements are laid out in ADA Accessibility Guidelines for Buildings and Facilities (ADAAG). ADA requires public agencies and private facilities to remove barriers independent of remodeling. This differs from past accessibility laws where architectural accessibility was typically triggered by new construction or alterations.

California access laws date back to 1968 when publicly funded buildings were covered. Privately funded buildings followed in 1970. In 1982 accessibility provisions were adopted into the California building code (Title 24).

For technical assistance concerning Titles II and III of the ADA, call the ADA information line: 800-514-0301 (TTY) 800-514-0383

See the U.S. Department of Justice Americans with Disabilities Act Home Page

Humboldt Access Project provides informal assistance to businesses concerned about access issues. HAP has technical manuals on hand and offers unofficial oversite and referrals free of charge. The office is at 955 Myrtle Ave., Eureka. 445-8404 (TTY) 445-8405.
***
May 2008 - Singleton is back in the news in Eureka - Arctic Circle closes due to ADA lawsuit

Eureka's Arctic Circle franchise has closed its doors after the restaurant was sued for noncompliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Jack Williams, who has owned the franchise with his wife, Peggy, since 1989, said the couple decided to close the business Tuesday because they can not afford the renovations required by the lawsuit.

According to an Arctic Circle spokesperson, the suit was filed by local attorney Jason K. Singleton, who has filed similar suits in recent years against a number of local establishments, including Village Pantry, Broadway Cinema, the Eureka Chamber of Commerce and several others.

The Eureka restaurant had been in business since 1967. Arctic Circle reportedly settled the suit out of court.


Interesting lInk provided by an anon on the TS story - adaabuse.com/singleton Singleton gets his own page. If you have knowledge of the abuse of an ADA claim or lawsuit, or unethical, unlawful, inappropriate or unfair business practices by an attorney or claimant... contact these guys - ADAaccountability and Citizens Against Predatory Lawsuits. Whenever possible, please provide the case number and court in which a lawsuit was filed. You can fax information toll free to (888) 453-1262.

ER - Walin filing latest in recent rash of gag order requests

Walin filing latest in recent rash of gag order requests
by Kara Machado, 4/22/2007

A protective order is being sought in the Elliott Michael Walin case.

A motion for the protective order request, filed by the Humboldt County Public Defender’s Office, will be heard before Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Christopher Wilson on Monday.

If the request for the protective order — also known as a gag order — is granted, it will prevent trial attorneys, court officials and other trial participants from talking to media about the case.

On Friday, Walin’s attorney, Deputy Public Defender Jennifer D. Dixon, declined to comment on why the gag order request was filed.

Humboldt County Deputy District Attorney Arnie Klein said a judge found sufficient evidence — following an April 3 preliminary hearing — to hold Walin to answer to all charges listed on the complaint against him: felon in possession of a firearm, a sawed-off shotgun; felon in possession of ammunition; possession of a sawed-off shotgun; assault with a firearm; felon in possession of a short-barreled shotgun; and grand theft auto, with a special allegation that Walin allegedly did so with a sawed-off shotgun and another special allegation that Walin has a prior felony vehicle theft conviction.

Klein confirmed Walin pleaded not guilty to the charges against him.

When asked to comment about the gag order request in the Walin case, as well as on the rash of gag order requests filed recently by the Public Defender’s Office, Klein said, “I guess this will all get solved in the courtroom.”

“All I know is that the public’s right to know has to be balanced against the defendant’s right to a fair trial,” Klein said. “But at some point, with as many gag orders being filed by the Public Defender’s Office, I think the community has to be somewhat sensitive to their rights to need to know what’s going on.

“The first step toward tyranny is to stifle the news media.”

Humboldt County Public Defender Kevin Robinson was not asked to comment Friday, as the Public Defender’s Office has previously reported Robinson would be out for the week.

Walin’s file was unavailable Friday afternoon, a court official said, because it had already been taken to the judge’s chambers to be reviewed.

Klein said the case against Walin, 23, stems from events that began on March 14.

Klein said, according to preliminary hearing testimony, at about 6:30 a.m. on March 14, Walin allegedly stole a 1996 Toyota truck parked in a Eureka driveway.

During the theft, Klein said, a friend of the truck’s owner attempted to stop it.

When the friend tried to open the passenger door, Walin allegedly fired a shot at the friend and missed.

Walin allegedly drove away in the stolen truck, law enforcement was called and a search for Walin began, Klein said.

On March 18, Klein said, Walin was found at his girlfriend’s Rio Dell residence.

According to preliminary hearing testimony, Klein said, a shotgun shell was allegedly found on Walin’s person.

Authorities also found such items as a sawed-off shotgun and additional shotgun shells at the Rio Dell residence, Klein said.

Klein confirmed Friday that he was still considering adding the following charges to the complaint against Walin “due to the evidence presented at Walin’s preliminary hearing”: robbery of a vehicle by force or fear with the use of a firearm and attempted murder with the use of a gun.

A Humboldt County Correctional Facility official confirmed Friday that Walin was still in custody on a parole hold — which prevents him from bailing out of jail.

If convicted of all the charges against him, including those Klein said he may add, Walin could face a maximum of 27 years to life in prison, Klein said.

Copyright (C) 2005, The Eureka Reporter. All rights reserved.

4.22.2007

Text of speech - Duke lacrosse players cleared

It wasn't just good news, it was one of the most beautifully written speeches I have ever heard. Very impressive. Every word matters. This posting is related to the discussion at watchpaul regarding prosecutors talking to the press too much about ongoing cases.

N.C. attorney general: Duke players 'innocent'
POSTED: 0030 GMT (0830 HKT), April 11, 2007

RALEIGH, North Carolina (CNN) -- North Carolina's Attorney General Roy Cooper announced Tuesday that the three former Duke University lacrosse players who faced sexual assault charges are "innocent" and the charges are being dropped.
Below is a transcript of his announcement and answers to questions at the new conference:

ROY COOPER: On January the 13th of this year, I accepted the request of the Durham County district attorney to take over three Durham cases. At the time I promised a fresh and thorough review of the facts and a decision on the best way to proceed.

I also said that we would have our eyes wide open to the evidence, but that we would have blinders on to all other distractions. We have done all of these things. (Watch: 'No credible evidence that an attack occurred' )

During the past 12 weeks, our lawyers and investigators have reviewed the remaining allegations of sexual assault and kidnapping that resulted from a party on March 13, 2006, in Durham, North Carolina. We carefully reviewed the evidence, collected by the Durham County prosecutor's office and the Durham Police Department.

We've also conducted our own interviews and evidence gathering. Our attorneys and SBI agents have interviewed numerous people who were at the party, DNA and other experts, the Durham County district attorney, Durham police officers, defense attorneys, and the accusing witness on several occasions. We have reviewed statements given over the year, photographs, records, and other evidence.

The result of our review and investigation shows clearly that there is insufficient evidence to proceed on any of the charges. Today we are filing notices of dismissal for all charges against Reade Seligmann, Collin Finnerty, and David Evans. The result is that these cases are over, and no more criminal proceedings will occur.

We believe that these cases were the result of a tragic rush to accuse and a failure to verify serious allegations. Based on the significant inconsistencies between the evidence and the various accounts given by the accusing witness, we believe these three individuals are innocent of these charges.

Now, we approached this case with the understanding that rape and sexual assault victims often have some inconsistencies in their account of a traumatic event. However, in this case, the inconsistencies were so significant and so contrary to the evidence that we have no credible evidence that an attack occurred in that house on that night.

Now, the prosecuting witness in this case responded to our questions and offered information. She did want to move forward with the prosecution.

However, the contradictions in her many versions of what occurred and the conflicts between what she said occurred and other evidence like photographs and phone records, could not be rectified.

Our investigation shows that the eyewitness identification procedures were faulty and unreliable. No DNA confirms the accuser's story. No other witness confirms her story. Other evidence contradicts her story. She contradicts herself.

Next week we'll be providing a written summary of the important factual findings and some of the specific contradictions that have led us to the conclusion that no attack occurred.

Now, in this case, with the weight of the state behind him, the Durham district attorney pushed forward unchecked. There were many points in this case where caution would have served justice better than bravado, and in the rush to condemn a community and a state, lost the ability to see clearly.

Regardless of the reasons that this case was pushed forward, the result was wrong. Today we need to learn from this and keep it from happening again to anybody.

Now, we have good district attorneys in North Carolina who are both tough and fair, and we need these forceful, independent prosecutors to put criminals away and protect the public, but we also need checks and balances to protect the innocent.

This case shows the enormous consequences of over-reaching by a prosecutor. What has been learned here is that the internal checks on a criminal charge -- sworn statements, reasonable grounds, proper suspect photo lineups, accurate and fair discovery -- all are critically important.

Therefore, I propose a law that the North Carolina Supreme Court have the authority to remove a case from a prosecutor in limited circumstances. This would give the courts a new tool to deal with a prosecutor who needs to step away from a case where justice demands.

I want to thank everyone in the North Carolina Department of Justice. I want to thank the investigators, our SBI agents, and especially attorneys Jim Coman and Mary Winstead for their hard work in this matter.

Next week we will be distributing a fact summary sheet, and you will have that then, but I'll go ahead and take some of your questions now. Go.


QUESTION: Considering what you just said about the D.A. and about the accuser, what would you say to the three men who were charged?

COOPER: Well, I'm telling them what I tell everyone in North Carolina. We have looked at the charges. We have looked at the law. And we have cleared them of all of these charges. And it is important to note that the Durham County district attorney is now facing ethics charges with the North Carolina Bar Association.

Q: Mr. Cooper, do you feel like -- do you feel the need to apologize in any way, I mean, in terms of what happened here?

COOPER: Well, you know, I think a lot of people owe a lot of apologies to other people. I think that those people ought to consider doing that.

Q: What do you think District Attorney Mike Nifong is thinking, now that you've reviewed all this -- all the evidence, done these interviews? What -- how do you think he came to the conclusion he came to?

COOPER: Well, I'm concerned, although our investigation did not concentrate on this, but I saw the statements and now we've done the investigation. I'm concerned that statements were made publicly about things that turned out not to be true. That's a concern. And right now I think it's appropriate that the North Carolina Bar Association is looking at these ethics charges.

Q: How damaging do you think it will be to the perception...

COOPER: I'm not going to speculate.

Q: I mean, the justice system in North Carolina. How concerned are you that it will have a negative impact to the justice system?

COOPER: I'll tell you about this. Any state in the country, including the federal government, can have a rogue prosecutor who goes on out on his own and does thing continues. Here in North Carolina we have solved the problem, we've corrected the problem. But I propose today a way that I think it can be done more quickly, and I think that that's important.

Q: To follow up just briefly, I just was wanting to know. This brings up a largest contextual concern. These defendants were able to retain counsel. They had -- were able to retain counsel, no doubt at a high cost. What about the people who are in these north county jails or state prisons who cannot afford counsel, who may be innocent of charges?

COOPER: I think there are a lot of broader issues that we have to look at. What we were concentrating on are the facts in this case, and we rendered a decision based on those facts.

Q: How -- how difficult has this decision been for you? And is there any truth to the fact that you went to see a doctor yesterday?

COOPER: Well, what happened yesterday is I was out running and got a little bit dehydrated. I run four, five days a week. Got a little dehydrated. I wanted to make sure that I got it checked out. That's all. I'm fine. I wanted to run to this press conference, but my staff wouldn't let me. So I'm doing just fine.

Q: A relayed (ph) question. Did Mike Nifong ever interview (the victim) before charges were brought? Do you have any evidence about that? And secondly, has she ever told the same story twice?

COOPER: Well, in answer to your second question, she's told many stories. Some things are consistent within those stories, but there were many stories that were told. We're going to release a lot of the specific information next week.

I don't want to say for sure whether Mr. Nifong talked with her before charges were brought. I know he talked with her at some point, but I don't know the answer to that question. We can find that out for you.


Q: Would you recommend to the council of the state that the state of North Carolina defend his liberties as he defends himself?

COOPER: You know, I am not going to speculate or comment on any particular civil litigation that might occur at this point.

Q: No, no, you do have authority to recommend to the counsel of the state whether or not the state picks up his legal fees.

COOPER: Well, we'll deal with that issue when it comes -- comes about.

Q: What conversations have you had with Mike Nifong? And how did that go?

COOPER: Jim Coman and Mary Winstead have talked with Mr. Nifong about this, and I don't know what the results of their conversation were, but they were going to call him and tell him about our decision today.

Q: Did you not talk with him?

COOPER: I don't talk with him, no.

Q: Do you believe the accuser lied in this case? And will there be any criminal charges against her?

COOPER: Well, we have considered that. Our investigators who talked with her and the attorneys who talked with her over a period of time think that she may actually believe the many different stories that she has been telling.

And in reviewing the whole history, there are records under seal that I'm not going to talk about, but we believe it's in the best interest of justice not to bring charges, and we have made that decision, as well.


Q: What about Mike Nifong? Do you think that his actions warrant a criminal investigation?

COOPER: Well, I think it's important that we let the process work with the North Carolina State Bar Association. Our investigation dealt mostly with the facts of this case and making a decision. Their investigation is dealing more with the pretrial comments and with the discovery issues on the DNA that our investigators really did not get into the details of that.
I think once the bar finishes that hearing process, then we will know more about that process when it comes.


Q: Is it a possibility?

COOPER: It's certainly a possibility, but I don't want to -- to speculate at this point. I think all options are certainly on the table.

Q: Mr. Cooper, the charges caused some racial discord, to say the least. How much damage, in your opinion, do you think has been done to the community? And do you think your actions today go very far in fixing the problem?

COOPER: Well, first I think all over the country there is certainly racial and economic injustice. And in my public career and in my private career, I've worked to help right those wrongs and work toward progress. And I think we all need to do it.

But for the purposes of this case, we looked at the facts and the evidence alone and made a decision on it. We promised that we would have blinders to all other distractions, and so we've worked mostly on this case. I'll leave it to other people to decide any kind of long-term effects that this has.


Q: There were many defense attorneys who believe that Michael Nifong should be disbarred for his actions, that he -- that was guilty of obstruction of justice.

I'm wondering, based on your investigation, based on everything you know, do you believe he should be disbarred? And if you cannot answer that question, what do you think should happen? Should he be allowed to continue as district attorney?

COOPER: I think it would prejudice his hearing of the bar if I would preempt their opinion. I want them to go through the process. He should be afforded that process, to have that hearing over there on all of these issues. So we'll let that happen first.

Yes?


Q: Was the woman somewhat mentally unstable? Was that part of the problem? With all these stories. You mentioned she believed some of these different stories. Is there a mental illness?

COOPER: I -- I don't want to characterize that in that way. What I would want to say is that our investigators looked at all of the records, think she actually believed what she -- the many stories she was telling, and we made the decision based on a lot of things. I don't want to talk about what was in those records under seal, but I think it's in the best interest of justice.

Q: Do the investigators think that she believed what she was saying from the start, or that she came to believe them over time?

COOPER: I think that -- I think that they believed the belief occurred as she was telling these things. And they don't know, but they've worked real hard with her, but it just doesn't make sense. You can't piece it together.

Q: Mr. Cooper, can I just ask you...

Q: ... how do you feel about this legal abuse of power? What does it say about the legal profession?

COOPER: Well, what I have worked on is what has happened with this case. We've made a decision on this case. We're going to continue to work with the proposal that I have made to make things happen more quickly, and we're going to continue to work hard to do good for North Carolina.
###

And why does it matter, in the context of this blog? Because Paul Gallegos has a habit of talking too much about the guilt of his primary target. Pacific Lumber Company. Because the Public Defenders have taken to asking for gag orders, caused by Gallegos' deputies talking too much about cases and plea bargains. Because there is hope that a good Attorney General can and will go after a corrupt prosecutor. "GAG" Orders w/update

4.16.2007

OC Weekly - Rackauckas - Missing Wives, Lousy Lies & Mob Ties

Missing Wives, Lousy Lies & Mob Ties

Exhaustive grand-jury investigation confirms DA corruption
By Anthony Pignataro and R. Scott Moxley
Thursday, July 4, 2002 - 12:00 am

Photo by Daniel C. Tsang
Eight months ago, an offended Orange County District Attorney Anthony J. "Tony" Rackauckas strenuously denied the existence of a grand-jury investigation into corruption allegations at the DA’s office. A couple of months later, Rackauckas admitted the existence of the probe but claimed it was a "routine" administrative audit undeserving of public attention. Late last month, we learned not only that Orange County’s top law-enforcement officer is fond of employing misleading media spin, but also that he is, indeed, corrupt.

On June 26, the Orange County grand jury rocked the local legal establishment when it declared that Rackauckas routinely abuses his awesome prosecutorial powers to protect friends and punish perceived enemies. According to the grand jury’s fact-filled, 100-page report, "Office of the District Attorney: An in-depth investigation," the DA is Nixonian in the darkest sense of the word: paranoid, petty, partisan, secretive, retaliatory and arrogant. And though this was a civil proceding, it’s easy to conclude that the jury’s findings demand a criminal investigation.

To those who read the Weekly, that description is hardly news. We’ve chronicled Rackauckas’ numerous ethical lapses since he took office four years ago. What’s impressive is that the grand jury—historically a panel of 19, mostly lethargic citizens who avoid the county’s uglier controversies—had the courage to investigate the DA and then report its disturbing findings.

For that public service, the 2001-2002 jurors haven’t been applauded, but rather ridiculed. Rackauckas accused them of political bias. Editorial writers at The Orange County Register questioned the jurors’ integrity and proclaimed the panel was uninterested in discovering the truth. In Register reality, the truth is the DA "may have done some things wrong," but the public should be, as the Register is, "generally pleased with the job he is doing."

The spin didn’t end there. Both the Register and Rackauckas argued that the report would have been more favorable had the jurors received "the complete story." Neither mentioned that it was Rackauckas who hampered the grand jury’s duties. Consider this: when the grand jury subpoenaed Deputy District Attorney Kay Rackauckas, the DA’s wife and a key player in office mischief, Rackauckas claimed he couldn’t locate her. Sources tell the Weekly another key player the grand jury sought—deputy DA Susan Schroeder, the wife of Michael Schroeder, the Orange County Republican Party bigwig and key Rackauckas defender—did not testify.

To their credit, the jurors were not amused by the MIA deputy DAs. They noted, "The grand jury requested the assistance of the district attorney’s office to locate the two witnesses, both of whom are extremely close to the district attorney, and were informed by the district attorney’s office that they were unable to contact them."

Kay Rackauckas went to extraordinary lengths to avoid assisting the grand jury. She took months of personal leave from her six-figure job and then, after she failed to return to the office, was quietly fired on May 27 by Orange County CEO Michael Schumacher. There has been no official explanation.

According to the grand jury report, Kay Rackauckas’ absence was an illusion. While they were searching for her, she was using a taxpayer-paid cell phone to call in orders—at times highly questionable if not unethical—to more senior prosecutors, records show. Despite her relatively modest management experience, the jurors found that the DA’s wife "was left, in large part, to her own devices." One of those devices was to convert part of the DA’s public offices and resources into a de facto campaign headquarters for Stephanie George, a personal friend and fellow deputy DA who was a winning Superior Court judge candidate in 2000.

But the biggest question emerging from the grand jury report is a question neither the Register nor the Los Angeles Times has asked: Why was Kay Rackauckas—a public servant sworn to uphold justice—afraid to testify?

Telling the truth about Tony Rackauckas can come at a cost. Just ask Michael Jacobs. The tough, veteran prosecutor had endorsed Rackauckas’ DA run in 1998 and was rewarded with the top assignment in the homicide unit. Cordial relations didn’t last. Jacobs became frustrated with Rackauckas’ ethical lapses and lack of professionalism. Afraid the misconduct would continue unless confronted by outside authorities, Jacobs shared his concerns with state investigators in 2000. Then, according to the grand jury, someone in the DA’s office left the equivalent of a horse’s head in Jacobs’ bed one night. Several local news reporters anonymously received official DA office "confidential" files containing negative and highly personal information on the prosecutor. The message was clear: speak out and you’ll be publicly punished.

The threats didn’t work. Jacobs refused to back down and Rackauckas eventually fired Orange County’s most acclaimed homicide prosecutor. A wrongful-termination lawsuit is pending.

If challenging Rackauckas can be painful, becoming his pal is advantageous. The grand jury documented in impressive detail dozens of cases when the DA used his position to aid friends and contributors in law-enforcement matters. In two key cases, for example, jurors determined:

•Tony Rackauckas didn’t know millionaire Newport Beach businessman Patrick Di Carlo before 1998. That changed as soon as Rackauckas launched his candidacy. Di Carlo—who admits that organized crime cops have for years considered him a mob associate—invited Rackauckas to his Harbor Island estate for dinner and a sleepover; raised thousands of dollars in campaign contributions; and even paired the soon-to-be DA with his son as a potential business partner in a Las Vegas-based corporation. When Rackauckas won, Di Carlo hosted and paid for an elaborate private celebration. In 2000, Di Carlo asked the DA to block the organized-crime unit from investigating his business activities. Rackauckas complied. The officers cried foul; Rackauckas placed them on leave. Signaling his contempt for his officers, Rackauckas bought Di Carlo a $600 Glock handgun and helped secure him a concealed weapons permit. Remarkably, Di Carlo says he wanted the gun to protect himself from the DA’s agents. Rackauckas told the grand jury that he and his new friend "talk on the telephone several times a week and go to lunch together anywhere from once a week to once a month."

•Rackauckas had no experience handling consumer-fraud prosecutions, but that didn’t stop him from rescuing Newport Beach billionaire George Argyros in his struggle with the DA’s prosecutors. Without explanation, Rackauckas met privately with Argyros’ attorneys and then overruled his staff’s position that his political benefactor had personally directed the massive fraud scheme against approximately 11,000 local Vietnamese and Latino apartment tenants. The shakedown allegedly netted Argyros more than $33 million during a three-year period. The grand jury ruled that the DA had "not paid proper attention to a possible appearance of impropriety" in the matter and should not have been privately negotiating with his powerful friend.

•The DA created and refused to disclose information about a partially taxpayer-funded "charitable" foundation that glorified Rackauckas while giving official-looking law enforcement badges to Di Carlo and other businessmen who contributed money.

In any other major metropolitan area, a carefully researched and well-written 100-page rebuke of the DA’s ethics might spark a public backlash or prompt an apology or resignation. But this is Orange County and—though the last grand jury did its job—there is no guarantee that any other legal body will do theirs.

Initially embarrassed by the report, Rackauckas’ arrogance and claims of invincibility seem to grow each passing day. In a June 27 memo to staff, the DA was upbeat, confident and "proud of this administration’s accomplishments."

Meanwhile, there are sure to be dedicated, law-abiding local prosecutors who are biting their tongues and have yet to come forward in public about Rackauckas’ abuse of authority. We know because the grand jury also issued an ominous warning: "Of great concern to the grand jury were those deputy district attorneys and even members of the [DA’s] management team that expressed fear of retaliation should the confidentiality of their testimony be violated."

Alarms should go off when good prosecutors fear their own boss.

OCWeekly - Kay Rackauckas - DA’s Wife Missing!

http://www.ocweekly.com/news/news/das-wife-missing/21824/

DA’s Wife Missing!

May just be home
By Anthony Pignataro
Thursday, May 30, 2002 - 12:00 am
Photo by Daniel C. Tsang
On March 5, while Orange County District Attorney Anthony "Tony" Rackauckas celebrated his overwhelming reelection at the Sutton Place Hotel in Newport Beach, observers noticed his wife, Kay, was nowhere to be found. Her absence, explained as a need to stay home with a sick baby, still registered as an oddity.

In fact, by then, Kay Rackauckas—a deputy DA in her husband’s controversy-plagued office—had already been absent for months. She still hasn’t reported to work, and colleagues can’t agree where she’s supposed to be.

Kay Rackauckas’ mysterious absence from the DA’s office comes at a convenient time for her and her husband. For the past six months, the Orange County grand jury—acting in concert with state Attorney General Bill Lockyer—has investigated what sources familiar with the investigation call "possible felonies" concerning Tony Rackauckas’ past four years in the DA’s office.

Neither the grand jury nor the attorney general’s office will officially comment on the direction of the probe or even whether it exists. But sources familiar with the investigation say the DA’s top officials, including Rackauckas himself, testified last month. The Republican DA also retained as his counsel prominent Democrat Tom Umberg. Umberg, a Clinton administration official, has no criminal-defense experience but is tight with Lockyer, a fellow Democrat.

Those same sources say Kay Rackauckas’ missing-in-action status coincides with the grand jury’s wish to make her testify.

"She has been subpoenaed but hasn’t appeared before the panel," said a source. "She’s MIA, and you’re not going to find her until after the grand jury disbands."

Sources couldn’t say exactly why the grand jury would subpoena Kay Rackauckas. Working since 1990, she makes more than $110,000 per year, according to the county Human Resources department. By virtue of marriage, she also has access to the highest officials in one of the county’s most powerful offices.

In 1997, then-deputy DA Kay Anderle married then-Judge Tony Rackauckas. A year later, Judge Rackauckas was elected district attorney. Almost immediately, critics labeled Kay another Hillary Clinton, the real power behind the DA throne.

"I’m not part of the management," she told Orange County Register reporter John McDonald shortly before her husband took over as DA in January 1999. "Now I’m in [the department investigating] sexual assault [cases], and that’s where I want to stay."

Attempts to contact Kay Rackauckas were unsuccessful. A call to the Westminster branch of the DA’s office where she worked until June 2001 produced nothing, save a staffer’s annoyed suggestion to try the central office. Calls there yielded nothing.

Reluctantly, we contacted Tori Richards, the DA spokeswoman who recently stopped acknowledging our phone calls and e-mails.

"Kay Rackauckas never received an OC grand jury subpoena," she wrote in a May 22 e-mail.

But Richards admitted in a subsequent e-mail she had no idea if the grand jury was trying to deliver a subpoena to Kay Rackauckas. As for Rackauckas’ whereabouts, Richards wrote, "She is currently on family leave because she had a baby."

If true, then Kay Rackauckas has been on family leave a long time. Her baby was born on Valentine’s Day, 2001—15 months ago.

Information obtained by veteran private investigator Mike Madigan—co-author of the 1989 book The Twisted Badge, which exposed corruption in Orange County Sheriff and DA organized-crime units—seems to indicate that Kay Rackauckas has been on nearly continuous family leave since her baby’s birth. According to correspondence between Madigan and county media-relations manager Diane Thomas, Kay Rackauckas received $2,000 in family home leave from Feb. 9 until April 26, 2001. Thomas said Rackauckas then continued on unpaid leave until Jan. 15 of this year but didn’t provide further pay figures. (Madigan has posted the information on his website, twistedbadge.com.)

Sources familiar with the DA’s office recall Kay Rackauckas visiting work with her newborn on at least one occasion last year but can’t remember seeing her in the office this year.

At this rate, it’s unlikely the current grand jury will ever see Kay Rackauckas. The panel dissolves on June 30, leaving barely a month to conclude its investigation into DA Rackauckas. The grand jury’s options range from recommending indictments to doing nothing.

"Good luck finding her," one DA’s office source said with a laugh. "We’ve even heard rumors she’s gone to Mexico. You’re not going to find her."