Pages

3.10.2008

Expert: Rape victims can be forced to take witness stand

It was Valentine's Day, and Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen stood before the court, clad in a red jumpsuit with his hands cuffed in front of him, accused of a dozen counts of spousal rape.

The alleged victim in the case, Gundersen's wife, also appeared in court that day, reportedly prepared to make a statement in support of her husband's release on his own recognizance.

According to documents in Gundersen's case file, his wife talked to District Attorney's Office investigators twice on Feb. 8, stating that Gundersen had repeatedly raped her while she was incapacitated by sleeping pills over the last year. Later that same day, she told investigators the sex was consensual.

District Attorney Paul Gallegos has since referred to the alleged victim as a hostile witness and, at a later hearing, asked the judge to order her to appear at Gundersen's preliminary hearing.

Similar situations play out in courtrooms across the state, and the country, raising questions about a rape victim's rights, whether a prosecutor should be able to compel them to testify and why their stories are liable to change.

Speaking in general terms and not about the Gundersen case, North Coast Rape Crisis Team Community outreach coordinator Paula Arrowsmith-Jones said a myriad of factors can cause a rape victim to recant his or her allegations.

”It doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the facts of the case or the reality of something having happened,” Arrowsmith-Jones said. “It's about whether they feel it is their best interest to be involved in the case.”

And that, Arrowsmith-Jones said, can become very complicated. She said familiar pressures, threats from the perpetrator, financial dependency, child-custody issues and even a fear that society will re-victimize them can all play a role.

”Any survivor of any gender knows that when they come forward, some people will blame them,” Arrowsmith-Jones said, adding victims can be criticized for their lifestyle, manner of dress or even for their choice of spouse. “We would hope that the public would understand that there are a lot of valid reasons that we can never understand as to why a survivor might step back from that process.”
Love can also play a big roll, said Nancy Lemon, a lecturer at University of California Berkeley School of Law and a domestic violence expert witness.
”Typically batterers can be wonderful, loving, sweet people, sometimes, and victims are often hoping they will return back to the person they have been,” Lemon said. “There's always the hope that he will change.”

Over at The EMMA Center, Executive Director Marybeth Bian agreed.

”A lot of times (the victims) love the person, and they just want them to not abuse them anymore,” she said.

Because our system of law attempts to balance the rights of the victim with the rights of society as a whole, a prosecutor can choose to proceed with a case against the victim's wishes, and Lemon said sexual assault victims can be ordered to testify.

The California Civil Procedure Code states that a victim of sexual assault can be ordered to testify, and found in contempt if he or she fails to do so. The only protection afforded sexual assault victims is they can not be sent to jail if found in contempt.

The maximum sentence under the code is for a judge to order the victim to attend up to 72 hours of a domestic violence program for victims and order them to perform up to 72 hours of community service.

Getting victims to take the stand for the prosecution can be such an obstacle that it is the subject of an entire section of a California District Attorney's Association publication titled “Investigation and Prosecution of Domestic Violence.”

The publication points out that victims can feel a lot of guilt in helping the prosecution's case against a loved one, and suggests that prosecutors do everything possible to make the victim feel that the decision whether to prosecute is the district attorney's. The publication even suggests that prosecutors order the victim to appear, as Gallegos did with Gundersen's wife.

”Once the ultimate authority, the court, directs the witness to answer questions, most victims comply,” the publication states. “Many victims feel considerable relief at being able to tell the defendant that the decision to testify is out of their hands, as they have been ordered to do so by the court.”

With April -- Domestic Violence Awareness Month -- around the corner and two high profile sexual assault cases in the media, Arrowsmith-Jones said it is a good time to raise awareness about domestic violence and create a societal environment that is more encouraging of victims coming forward.

”The kinds of violence that are in the paper right now are happening in our community all the time, and it's only every once in a while that it comes to public attention,” she said. “But, these types of issues are going on all the time.”

Back at the EMMA Center, Bian said she's seen many cases die because the victim has a change of heart or the prosecution can't build a strong enough case even with the victim's cooperation. More disturbingly, she said, she's seen some victims simply suffer in silence.

”I know people come in here who don't even report because they're ashamed,” she said. “There's still that stigma in society, that it's the victim's fault.”
***
Thadeus Greenson
Article Launched: 03/10/2008 01:30:14 AM PDT
The North Coast Rape Crisis Team has a 24-hour, confidential, crisis hotline at 445-2881. Collect calls are welcome.

3.08.2008

TS - Feds eye firearms in Gundersen case

TS Feds eye firearms in Gundersen casee (w/ video)

The U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms is involved in an investigation into Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen and the stash of high-powered submachine guns found at the department during a February search.

District Attorney Paul Gallegos said the agency has been informed and has a hand in the investigation.

”Whenever you have firearms involved in a case, there is going to be some ATF involvement,” Gallegos said.

The ATF will be considering whether there are federal firearms violations regarding the possession, sale or transport of the three types of submachine guns allegedly found in Blue Lake, or the submachine gun, the pistol fixed with a silencer or other weapons reportedly found in Gundersen's home.

Both state and federal law are fairly clear about possessing a submachine gun or a pistol with a silencer: It's illegal in California, and illegal in the United States without a special permit from the ATF. Under California law, the penalty for possession of a machine gun is an unspecified prison term, up to a $10,000 fine, or both. For possession of a silencer it's the same.

But state law allows a law enforcement agency to buy machine guns, and for officers to have them and silencers -- as long as they use them in an official capacity and within the scope of their duties. In fact, there is no limit on the number of submachine guns an agency can have, said California Department of Justice spokesman Abraham Arredondo.

The Use of Firearms section of the Blue Lake Police Department Manual does not make any reference to submachine guns or silencers.

Any machine gun may be imported by a licensed importer -- H&K is a German manufacturer -- for sale to a law enforcement agency, wrote ATF Senior Special Agent Nina Delgadillo in an e-mail. There is no federal limit on the number or type of machine guns a police agency can possess, Delgadillo also wrote.

No records of 10 H&K UMP 9mm submachine guns found in the search of the Blue Lake department were filed with the state, while other guns there were state-registered, according to the District Attorney's Office. Whether a police department is strictly required to register a submachine gun when it comes into the department's possession is unclear.

Melva Paris, records supervisor for the Humboldt County Sheriff's Office, said when the sheriff's department purchases firearms, they are immediately registered into the California Law Enforcement Telecommunications System, or CLETS.

”We purchase them, and then when we get them they have to go into the CLETS system as an 'institutional weapon,'” Paris said. “(The Department of Justice) has to know who those weapons belong to.”

That's all done with good reason, according to James Broder, a former FBI agent and U.S. State Department employee who now works as an expert witness.

”Obviously, it's done so they can identify them and trace them if they are involved in a crime in the future,” Broder said, adding that agencies want to be able to track officers' lost or stolen weapons, or prevent their use by rogue officers. “The whole key is identification, that's why we do this stuff -- so you can identify the firearm in the event it is used for an illegal purpose.”

So far, Gallegos has charged Gundersen with two gun crimes. They are related to the H&K MP5 submachine gun reportedly found in a safe in his garage and the pistol with a silencer. Gallegos alleges Gundersen was in unlawful possession of both under violations of penal codes related to individuals.

Gundersen has also been charged with 12 counts of spousal rape, one count of kidnapping with the use of a firearm with the intent to rape -- in connection to another alleged victim -- threatening a witness and other crimes.

He has pleaded not guilty to all 19 counts and is currently being held in the Humboldt County Correctional Facility on $1.25 million bail.

John Driscoll can be reached at 441-0504 or jdriscoll@times-standard.com and Thadeus Greenson can be reached at 441-0509 or tgreenson@times-standard.com

TS - Blue Lake's gun arsenal called shocking

Blue Lake's gun arsenal called shocking

Until recently, the Blue Lake Police Department had a chief, a sergeant, two officers and 27 submachine guns.
It's the last part that is raising some eyebrows and some concerns.

The Feb. 8 arrest of Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen on charges of spousal rape, and the subsequent investigation, has shed a new light on one of Humboldt County's smallest police forces. And some information coming out of Gundersen's case file has some wondering what was going on in the department.

The Blue Lake mayor called the news “troublesome,” and the City Council is reviewing whether it needs a police department.

An investigation report by the Humboldt County District Attorney's Office in Gundersen's case file includes a list of firearms reportedly taken from the Blue Lake Police Department and, law enforcement experts say, the numbers are staggering.
Among the 46 weapons listed, 27 were submachine guns, according to the report.

Eureka Police Chief Garr Nielsen said EPD's SWAT team, which was disbanded last year, didn't have a single fully automatic weapon.

Nielsen also worked on a regional SWAT team in Oregon, which he said had five submachine guns for a team of 18 officers. The SWAT team for Portland -- a city roughly 500 times the size of Blue Lake -- had six submachine guns for its 20 officers, Nielsen said.
”They are specifically used for entry work, the guys going through the door,” Nielsen said of the weapons' use in tactical operations. “It's a close-quarter, when-you-have-to-throw-down-a-bunch-of-bullets-in-a-hurry kind of a weapon.”

Gregory Lee, a retired supervisory special agent for the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration and a former FBI Academy instructor, who now works as an expert witness on police procedures, said the numbers coming out of Blue Lake are shocking.

”You sure as hell don't need 27 machine guns for a department of four officers,” he said.

Reached Tuesday, Blue Lake City Manager Wiley Buck said the department acquired the submachine guns about a year ago, but had no intent to use them and didn't pay for them.

”We didn't purchase any of them,” Buck said. “They were free from other departments or free from companies. ... They were just sitting in boxes; we never used them.”

Buck said Gundersen acquired the guns with the intent of loaning them out to other local agencies. Buck said the department loaned two of the submachine guns to the Rio Dell Police Department in exchange for traffic monitoring devices.

Rio Dell Police Chief Graham Hill confirmed that his department did have two of Blue Lake's Colt AR-15s for a while, but returned them after Gundersen's arrest.

”Initially, we though we might have some kind of practical application for them, but we just determined they really wouldn't be useful for us,” Hill said, adding that the liability associated with the fully automatic weapons and the small size of his force prevented the department from ever using them.

Buck said nearly all of the submachine guns sat in a locker at the Blue Lake Police Department, but one was kept in Gundersen's patrol car.

Buck said the automatic weapons were acquired without the knowledge of the City Council.

”We didn't do a report on it or anything, the main reason being we didn't want to advertise we had all these in the office,” Buck said.

News that his police department had 27 submachine guns came as a shock to Blue Lake Mayor Sherman Schapiro.

”I'm surprised, and yeah, it's troublesome,” Schapiro said Tuesday. “I guess what I would tell you is everything I read in the paper (about this case) is pretty much new to me. It's the first I've seen of most of this, or actually pretty much all of this. ... We don't have SWAT out here. I don't know why they would have automatic weapons.”

Asked how the guns could be compiled without the City Council's knowledge, Schapiro said it is not the council's place to oversee the day-to-day operations of the police department.

”I doubt there are any city councils or governments that go down to see what police lockers contain,” Schapiro said. “You trust your chief to do the right thing.”

As to the practice of law enforcement agencies giving away automatic weapons to other agencies, as Buck said was the case with Blue Lake's arsenal, Lee said it's not that unusual.

”For them to be the recipient of these guns is not unusual,” Lee said, adding that departments will often give away old guns to make way for newer ones. “Again, the question is why would you need 27 of them?”

Lee said that question is all the more pressing in a four officer department in “Podunk” California.

Schapiro said the question of the 27 submachine guns, and a host of others that have appeared in the wake of Gundersen's arrest, have caused the city to rethink the future of its police force.

”We're in the process of reevaluating our police force,” Schapiro said, adding that the city is talking to its insurance carrier and weighing options, which may include permanently disbanding the force. The Humboldt County Sheriff's Office is currently responding to emergency law enforcement calls for the city.

Pressed about the department's idea of getting free automatic weapons and loaning them out to other agencies, Schapiro said he really didn't know much about it.

”Again, you hire your (city) manager and you hire your police chief, and you trust them to do their jobs,” he said.

Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 03/05/2008 01:30:40 AM PST

3.04.2008

TS - Gundersen, alleged second victim were living together, report says

TS Gundersen, alleged second victim were living together, report says

The second woman that David Gundersen is accused of sexually assaulting told investigators she was involved in an intimate relationship with the Blue Lake police chief and said she reported the incident to Eureka police in 1999, according to recently filed court documents.

Gundersen has pleaded not guilty to 19 charges, including 12 counts of spousal rape and one count of transporting or kidnapping a second victim with the use of a firearm for the purpose of rape. He remains in the Humboldt County Correctional Facility, held on $1.25 million bail.

Court documents filed last week shed new light on charges that Gundersen allegedly raped a second woman in March 1999, and state that Gundersen and the alleged victim were living together and involved in an intimate relationship.

The documents also list in greater detail the firearms reportedly seized from Gundersen's home and the Blue Lake Police Department, and offer a glimpse into the case the prosecution is preparing for the embattled police chief's March 20 preliminary hearing.

According to a Humboldt County District Attorney Office investigation report, district attorney personnel first received word of a second alleged victim through a letter from the woman's friend five days after Gundersen was arrested.

In an interview with investigators, the friend provided more information but was unable to say where the woman was now, according to the report. The district attorney's office was able to track her down after Chief Investigator Mike Hislop noticed a personnel file belonging to a person by a similar name in the evidence room while serving a search warrant on the Blue Lake Police Department, according to the report.

The report states the woman was interviewed by Hislop on Feb. 25.

”Victim 2 told me she had an intimate relationship with Gundersen in 1998,” the report states.

She is described as saying the relationship lasted about two years with the two living together for the relationship's final six months.

While planning the couple's wedding, the woman said she got into an argument with Gundersen after discovering he was still married to his now ex-wife, according to the report.

”Gundersen grabbed Victim 2 with both hands and started pushing her into the living room and then down the hallway towards their bedroom,” the report of the interview states. “Once in the bedroom, Gundersen pushed her on the bed. ... At this point, Gundersen took his handgun out of his holster. Victim 2 was threatened by the gun and was concerned what Gundersen was going to do.”

In the report's description of the alleged rape, Gundersen is said to put down the gun, at which point the woman states she contemplated picking it up and shooting Gundersen but she said couldn't bring herself to do it because Gundersen's two sons were in the other room.

The report states the woman said she left Gundersen the next day, and made a report to Eureka Police Sgt. Len Johnson 19 days later. She told Hislop she never heard back from the Eureka Police Department, according to the report.

Hislop spoke with Johnson, according to the report, but Johnson said he did not recall any specifics or what the alleged second victim had contacted him about.

The woman also told Hislop that she worked under cover for Gundersen in both Trinidad and Blue Lake. It is unclear if she worked for the Blue Lake or Trinidad police departments. Calls to city officials were not returned.

According to the district attorney's investigation report, Gundersen reportedly attempted to look up the woman using a law enforcement data base in September 2007. That lead to Gundersen being charged with “unlawfully accessing government records,” District Attorney Paul Gallegos wrote in a motion to increase Gundersen's bail.

”That charge relates to the defendant requesting CLETS [California Law Enforcement Telecommunication System] information on Jane Doe 2 through the Humboldt County Sheriff's Department on September 27, 2007,” Gallegos wrote. “This presents a unique concern regarding the safety and welfare of Doe 2.”

Another investigation report from the District Attorney's Office lists weapons reportedly seized from Gundersen's home and the Blue Lake Police Department.

In addition to the Hekler & Koch MP5 machine gun and the pistol with a silencer attached, both of which led to possession charges, law enforcement also reported seizing 22 other firearms from Gundersen's residence, including seven unregistered hand guns.

A total of 46 firearms were reportedly seized from the department, according to the report. A separate report indicates Blue Lake City Manager Wiley Buck requested that the District Attorney's Office take all the department's guns for “safekeeping.”

Gundersen's court file also contained a list of exhibits the prosecution intends to introduce at the upcoming preliminary hearing: Four photographs of a nude woman (one of which, the list states, was allegedly taken while the woman was asleep), a CD interview of Jane Doe 1, transcripts of an interview with Jane Doe 1, photographs of a Hekler & Koch MP5 machine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer, a copy of the Use of Firearms section of the Blue Lake Police Department's manual, a copy of the Emergency Protective Order filed against Gundersen which expired last month, a copy of computer aided dispatch call information from the Eureka Police Department and a copy of the Wikipedia page for the Hekler & Koch MP5 machine gun.

Thadeus Greenson can be reached at 441-0509 or tgreenson@times-standard.com
Thadeus Greenson The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 03/04/2008 01:31:19 AM PST

TS - Gallegos asks Supreme Court to review Palco ruling

Gallegos asks Supreme Court to review Palco ruling

Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos is asking the state Supreme Court to review an appellate court's ruling that allowed his fraud suit against the Pacific Lumber Co. to be tossed out. He also is requesting that the Supreme Court order “depublication” of the opinion.

”We would like the court to review it,” Gallegos said Monday.

Palco Vice President Frank Bacik said in a news release that the “filings contain a series of slogans that lack reason, explanation or basis for either depublication of the appellate court's opinion or grant by the Supreme Court for a review of that opinion.”

”The new filings appear in the form of vague assertions that everybody is wrong except Paul Gallegos. The trial court is wrong, the court of appeal is wrong, Palco is wrong,” Bacik said.

The lawsuit, filed in February 2003, claimed Palco submitted faulty studies during the Headwaters Forest negotiations to get the California Department of Forestry to adopt a less restrictive long-term logging plan. Gallegos' second amended complaint was thrown out of Humboldt County Superior Court by visiting Judge Richard Freeborn, a ruling upheld by the appeals court.

The logging plan was part of the agreement to sell the 7,400-acre Headwaters Forest and other groves for $480 million. Gallegos argued that the company secured it by submitting false data on landslides in one watershed and not submitting a correction until the last minute.

The appeals court judges determined that Palco's lobbying efforts with the state were the real force behind CDF's decision to drop the stricter logging plan and adopt a less restrictive one. They found the California Environmental Quality Act proceedings during the Headwaters discussions were the appropriate venue to consider if any evidence presented was false.

Those lobbying efforts are privileged under state unfair competition laws, the ruling reads. The court also determined that Palco is protected by the Noerr-Pennington Doctrine that shields anyone petitioning the government or government agencies against civil liability, unless they are engaged in a “sham.”

Palco's efforts didn't meet the definition of a sham, the judges wrote in the ruling.

The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 03/04/2008 01:21:16 AM PST

ER - DA petitions Supreme Court

DA petitions Supreme Court

Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos is asking the California Supreme Court to review his fraud lawsuit against Pacific Lumber Co. that has failed three times to pass legal muster.

Gallegos said this time the influential environmental group Sierra Club is also asking the court to hear the case.

“We’ll see what happens,” Gallegos said in a phone interview Monday.

The district attorney’s case, filed in 2003 in Humboldt County Superior Court, and subsequent amended suits were dismissed on demurrer, which effectively throws out the suit on a lack of legal merit.

After hearing legal arguments from Gallegos and a city of San Francisco attorney on his behalf in December, the California Appellate Court justices blasted his case and concluded in a rare 23-page published ruling and opinion in January that Gallegos failed to prove — on his third attempt — any “reasonable possibility” that his case could be corrected to move forward.

Gallegos confirmed Monday that he has petitioned the state’s top court seeking judicial review of the Appellate Court’s ruling, which he wrote is in “clear error” and effectively denies the government a platform to prosecute cases where the underlying administrative proceedings were corrupt.

In addition to seeking judicial review, Gallegos is asking the Supreme Court to order the depublication of the appeal court’s opinion, which would prevent other courts from citing it as case law.

Gallegos’ suit alleges that PALCO intentionally committed fraud in an effort to increase timber harvesting by manipulating watershed sediment reports during the environmental review that led to the signing of the controversial Headwaters Deal in 1999.

But the courts have maintained that PALCO’s submission of an allegedly erroneous report and the subsequent resubmission of corrected data was protected by the “litigation privilege” that protects communications made as part of a judicial or quasi-judicial proceeding.

Gallegos argues that to grant immunity to an applicant who submits false information erodes the integrity of the system and disempowers the administrative agencies from fulfilling their mandate.

Except in certain death penalty cases, the California Constitution affords no automatic right to appeal before the Supreme Court, which is only granted as a matter of discretion, according to the Supreme Court Web site.

In his letter to the California Supreme Court, Gallegos said the “reasons why courts must shield litigants from derivative litigation are the very same reasons why courts must allow an exception to these evidentiary shields when the path to truth was muddied beyond the point of recourse.”

“In such an instance, a collateral attack under the (Unfair Competition Law) is the only form of equitable relief through which the government can stop an ongoing fraud,” Gallegos wrote.

In a response, PALCO Vice President and General Counsel Frank Bacik described Gallegos’ new filings as “vague assertions that everybody is wrong except Paul Gallegos.”

“The trial court is wrong, the court of appeal is wrong, Palco is wrong,” Bacik said.

Bacik said Gallegos argues that the Supreme Court should carve out an exception to the company’s constitutional right to petition administrative agencies, and also create a special provision for criminal prosecutors who feel like reopening final administrative and environmental review proceedings in order to have the last word on the accuracy and truthfulness of the process.

“His filings contain a series of slogans that lack reason, explanation or basis for either de-publication of the appellate court’s opinion or grant by the Supreme Court for a review of that opinion,” Bacik said.

As an example, Bacik cited Gallegos’ statement to the court that “the clear errors that the trial court committed and the appellate court affirmed obstruct not only the sanctity of 211,000 acres of Humboldt forest timberland, but also the very ‘paths which to lead to [sic] the ascertainment of truth.’”

“Whatever that means, it hardly presents a reasoned legal argument,” Bacik stated. “We’re eager to hear what the California Supreme Court makes of it, and interested to see how long Mr. Gallegos intends to continue beating this long-dead horse at considerable expense to the taxpayers of Humboldt County.”

It is unclear how much the five-year legal battle has cost taxpayers because Gallegos indicated in an e-mail correspondence previously that his office doesn’t keep such records.

“We have an overall budget,” Gallegos wrote. “There are attorney hours, which we don’t keep. I do not believe we had any other costs.”

Gallegos indicated he is still waiting to receive PALCO’s claim of costs, which the court ruled the county would have to pay.

PALCO officials declined to disclose the amount of legal fees it has incurred defending the lawsuit.

By NATHAN RUSHTON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Mar 3 2008, 10:23 PM

3.01.2008

TS - Judge raises Gundersen's bail to $1.25 million

TS - Judge raises Gundersen's bail to $1.25 million

A judge ordered David Gundersen's bail to be increased to $1.25 million Friday in light of new charges filed this week against the embattled Blue Lake police chief.

Gundersen has pleaded not guilty to 19 counts, including 12 charges of spousal rape using an intoxicating or anesthetic substance, attempting to prevent a victim from reporting a crime and possessing both a machine gun and a pistol with a silencer.

Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles raised Gundersen's bail in light of four new counts filed Wednesday, which include the charge of kidnapping or transporting a victim for the purpose of committing rape with the use of a firearm. Miles said the raise was in accordance with the court bail schedule.

Prior to Miles' decision, Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, asked Miles to leave the bail as previously set at $500,000.
”The current bail in effect, given Chief Gundersen's resources, is no bail,” Clanton said. “It's unattainable ... I think it's just piling on at this point to increase the bail.”

District Attorney Paul Gallegos didn't see it the same way.

”If it's unattainable, it shouldn't really matter,” Gallegos said, adding that, because of the serious nature of the charges, the bail should reflect the bail schedule.

Miles agreed.

”I would note Mr. Gundersen is charged with 13 violent felonies,” she said. “The court finds no reason to deviate.”

After Miles reset Gundersen's bail, Clanton said the defense was willing to waive time, and asked that the preliminary hearing scheduled to begin Monday be moved back three weeks. Gallegos agreed, and the hearing is set to begin March 20.

Clanton also expressed frustration at the rate that his office has received discovery -- a court term for the exchange of information between the attorneys involved in a case.

”I would like to note one thing for the record, there is a lack of discovery that is making it difficult for us to prepare,” he said.
Gallegos assured the court he would get all the discovery to the defense as soon as possible.

After the hearing, Clanton said the combination of a lack of discovery provided by the prosecution and new charges filed Wednesday made it impossible to prepare for the preliminary hearing as initially scheduled for Monday.

”There is no way, given the stakes of these charges, we were going to be able to prepare to address these charges and cross examine witnesses,” he said.

Clanton said the decision to waive time was a difficult one, as it means his client will spend another three weeks in jail awaiting his preliminary hearing.

”It's extremely difficult, but there's no way around it,” Clanton said, adding that his client was willing to serve the additional time in jail now in order to have a better prepared defense.

Gundersen was arrested Feb. 8 after his wife alleged earlier in the day that he had sex with her the night before, without her knowledge or consent, after she had taken sleeping pills, according to a document used to request an arrest warrant. Gundersen's wife said it had happened “hundreds of times,” the document states.

By the end of that same day, the alleged victim changed her story and was describing the sex as consensual, according to Sheriff's office reports contained in the court file.

A search warrant issued on Gundersen's home and vehicles allegedly led to the seizure of dozens of prescription pill bottles, some of which were issued to people other than Gundersen or his wife, and some that were inscribed with Blue Lake Police Department case numbers, according to a district attorney's office report.

A machine gun and a pistol with a silencer attached were also reportedly seized, according to the report, as well as digital cameras, video recorders and computers.

The Blue Lake Police Department was also searched, according to court records, and firearms and computer equipment were reportedly seized from that location as well.

Gallegos filed a criminal complaint last week charging Gundersen with 12 counts of spousal rape, as well as three charges allegedly committed while in custody.

On Wednesday, when Gundersen's preliminary hearing was scheduled to start, Gallegos filed an amended criminal complaint with four additional charges alleging Gundersen kidnapped or carried away a second victim for the purpose of committing rape, acted unlawfully with department records and was in possession of the machine gun and a pistol with a silencer.
Clanton said Friday he's waiting to receive all the discovery.
”I'm just looking forward to getting ourselves in a position where we can begin to counter punch, and that's going to be fairly soon,” Clanton said.

Thadeus Greenson/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 03/01/2008 01:31:22 AM PST

Related coverage, with links