Pages

2.21.2008

ER - Gundersen case headed to trial

Gundersen case headed to trial

By EMILY WILSON, The Eureka Reporter
Published: Feb 21 2008, 1:01 AM

An hearing took place Wednesday for Blue Lake Police Chief David Ray Gundersen, in the Humboldt County Courthouse.

In a closed courtroom, a preliminary hearing date of Feb. 27 at 8:30 a.m. was confirmed. Deputy District Attorney Kelly Neel represented the prosecution, expected to be personally led by District Attorney Paul Gallegos.

Gundersen — still in custody with a $500,000 bail — was not present. His attorney, Russell J. Clanton of the Arcata-based firm, Russell J. Clanton and Associates was represented by a member of the firm, attorney Benjamin Okin.

Gundersen has been charged with 12 felony counts of Penal Code 262 (A)(2), and one count of each PC 136.1 (B)(1), PC 166 (A)(4), and BP 4060.

In non-legal terms, he is accused of raping his spouse — on 12 occasions throughout the past year — with an intoxicating or anesthetic substance.

Additionally, Gundersen is charged with one felony count of dissuading or preventing a witness or victim from testifying, possession of a controlled substance without a prescription and willful disobedience of the terms of a court process or court order.

At the preliminary hearing, the prosecution will present evidence — which may include witness testimony — to persuade the judge that there is probable cause for a trial.

As recently reported in The Eureka Reporter, Gallegos said he will present a recording of the alleged victim’s statement at the hearing.

Questions continue to surround as to who accused Gundersen of raping his wife, but it’s likely they will be cleared up Feb. 27, if not sooner.

In a previous interview, Gallegos said the District Attorney’s Office can only act on an a crime if it was alleged by the victim.

Clanton said — also in a previous interview — that he believes the accusations are rooted in a custody battle that Gundersen has been fighting with his former wife for nearly 10 years.

Gundersen’s wife was present in court at a bail hearing last week, where she confirmed she was there to support her husband.

As previously reported, Gallegos said, “you can’t prove a case without a victim.”

TS Cheri Lyn Moore case: What the grand jury heard

Cheri Lyn Moore case: What the grand jury heard
John Driscoll/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/21/2008 01:27:27 AM PST

The volatile chain of events leading to Cheri Lyn Moore's death in 2006 at the hands of Eureka police is laid out in transcripts of the grand jury proceedings held in November and December, which led to involuntary manslaughter charges against the commanding officers.

One of the leading officers on the SWAT team that stormed into the 48-year-old woman's apartment on April 14, 2006, told grand jurors that plans to handle the tense situation were still being developed when orders were given to move in.

Eureka Detective Todd Wilcox said four initial plans had been generated to deal with the circumstances most likely to arise during the early part of the standoff in which Moore brandished a flare gun. Wilcox was pulled back to the command post in the building just before the SWAT team entered, a little more than two hours into the standoff.

While the team began to formulate plans to better communicate with Moore, a spotter across from her apartment at 516 G St. said Moore had put down the gun, Wilcox said.

That signal was agreed upon as the order to go, he said. The officers used a battering ram to smash in the door, Moore pointed the flare gun at them and was shot to death, according to testimony.

An expert witness testifying on behalf of accused commander Lt. Anthony Zanotti called it a “clear case of suicide by cop.” George Williams testified that Moore's threats and actions leading up to her death are typical of someone intentionally drawing police to a scene and acting in a criminal manner that makes police use deadly force.

Moore was despondent on the anniversary of her son's suicide, had called mental health workers and police, told them she had a flare gun and threatened to blow up the building, Williams said.

”Because when a reasonable person presented with overwhelming force gives up,” Williams answered Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos, “and she intentionally arms herself and causes this shooting, that's suicidal, sir.”

Wilcox had been to the apartment four days before for a welfare check on Moore, who made unspecified threats that she might burn down the building or a church. He and another officer had pounded on Moore's door, but ended up leaving without incident.

When Gallegos asked Wilcox what was different about how police responded on those two days, Wilcox said Moore had threatened to burn down the building and had pointed a weapon -- the flare gun -- at officers on April 14.

He described those as “exigent circumstances,” that warranted entry into Moore's apartment. Police weren't trained to deal with a fire that might have broken out if the flare gun had been fired, Wilcox said, and he also testified he wasn't entirely confident that firefighters could have responded and doused a fire, either.

Wilcox explained how SWAT officers generally “stack” before entering a residence or room. The first breaches the door, then moves out of the way for officers carrying guns, followed by officers with less-lethal weapons. The reason for this is to ensure that the first officers can respond with deadly force if they are faced with deadly force, he said.

Officer Rocky Harpham was the first man to enter the apartment, carrying a 12-gauge shotgun. Harpham testified that he moved in and saw Moore in the room with her back to him, and the weapon -- the flare gun -- sitting on a table or shelf. He yelled for her to put her hands up, he said. Moore turned around with a look of shock on her face, he testified.

”She picked up the weapon and she started to bring it up to where she could point it at the direction of myself and the rest of the team and when she started to bring the weapon across towards me that is -- or towards where I was at, that is when I began firing,” Harpham testified.

Harpham said that he believed Moore would shoot him and that he had no other option but to shoot.

Harpham and officers Mike Johnson, Rodrigo Sanchez, Tim Jones and Terry Liles were the officers who initially entered Moore's apartment. None of them were indicted by the grand jury, and testified under protection of immunity in the proceedings.

Wilcox also answered Gallegos about the threat of fire to the building. If the threat of fire was so grave, Gallegos asked, why was the SWAT command center set up in the same building? Wilcox answered that it was probably lack of foresight.

Gallegos repeatedly questioned officers and police negotiators about their attempts to contact Moore. Moore had music blaring in the apartment much of the time, and law enforcement repeatedly tried to get her to answer the phone and hold a conversation.

Officers testified that they held a discussion about whether to cut power to the apartment, but decided against it, since it was believed her phone was cordless and required electricity. Gallegos also asked whether commanders considered using a “throw phone” -- a special phone provided to a suspect during negotiations -- or the PA systems on police vehicles to communicate.

County Health and Human Services Director Phil Crandall testified that police never asked for assistance with the situation, but also said there was no mechanism in place to get mental health workers to the scene.

While the building was largely evacuated that day, one neighbor of Moore's was believed to be too sick to be taken out, and remained inside with two female caretakers during the incident. Another witness, neighbor Jeffrey John Hemsted, testified that he was never asked to leave by police, or told there was a threat of fire.

Eureka Fire Capt. Patrick Joseph Lynch told the grand jury that a fire crew had staged a block and a half away, and had been told there was a possibility that a gas line had been broken in the apartment, which could have had dire consequences if Moore had discharged the flare gun.

John Driscoll can be reached at 441-0504 or jdriscoll@times-standard.com.

TS - Douglas, Zanotti set to be arraigned today in Moore shooting

Douglas, Zanotti set to be arraigned today in Moore shooting
Kimberly Wear/The Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/21/2008 01:32:00 AM PST

District Attorney Paul Gallegos' involuntary manslaughter case against the two officers in charge when Cheri Lyn Moore was killed hinges on whether they should have obtained a warrant before a SWAT team was ordered into her apartment, according to recently unsealed grand jury transcripts.

Gallegos told the grand jury that former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Tony Zanotti ordered an illegal entry into the apartment, and acted with criminal negligence by failing to “adequately supervise” police, SWAT team members and the negotiation team during the April 14, 2006, standoff.

Douglas and Zanotti are scheduled to be arraigned today on charges of involuntary manslaughter.

In order to hand up an indictment of involuntary manslaughter, Gallegos said 12 of the 18 grand jurors needed to find that Douglas and Zanotti committed at least one of those acts. There was probable cause to indict them if there were no exigent circumstances, that it was an unlawful entry and that the entry resulted in Moore's death, Gallegos said.

”Was -- were the acts of Lt. Zanotti and Dave Douglas criminally negligent? This is not standard negligence, civil negligence, you made a mistake,” Gallegos said. “You made a real bad mistake. Criminal negligence is a whole different animal. It is a disregard.”

Moore, who had a history of mental illness, was shot by Eureka police officers in her apartment at Fifth and G streets after a two-hour standoff in which she brandished a flare gun, threw items from her apartment and threatened to burn the building down.

Police have said they believed Moore had put down the flare gun when the decision was made to storm her apartment. When officers came face to face with Moore, who they say had a flare gun pointed at them, they shot her multiple times.

Superior Court Judge John Feeney ordered the transcripts unsealed Tuesday at the request of the Times-Standard, which argued the nearly 2,000 pages of grand jury testimony should be made public.

At the court hearing, attorneys for Douglas and Zanotti said they were open to handing over most of the testimony, but requested nearly 60 pages of Gallegos' instructions and summation be redacted because “in our opinion he horribly misinstructed the grand jurors.”

Feeney ruled in favor of the Times-Standard, opening the entire transcript.

The documents, made up of five sections, cover about 10 days of testimony, Gallegos' closing argument and jury instructions.
In his last words to jurors, Gallegos raised questions about how dire the Moore situation was, why her building and surrounding businesses weren't completely evacuated, whether enough efforts were made to contact Moore or time given to explore options other than storming her apartment after a little more than two hours.

”This is the life and safety of citizens in this community,” he said. “I am not asking you to hold these officers to a standard of perfection. I believe the evidence establishes that -- I believe there is certainly evidence that belies the claim that there was a fear that this building was going to burn up if they did not act.”

Gallegos also compares the Moore case to a Fortuna standoff that lasted 32 hours, saying Fortuna Police Chief Kris Kitna delayed entry, evacuated the surrounding area and obtained a Ramey warrant before entering the house where a hostage had been held by Michael Allman.

”They use gas. They break windows. They use shields. They use a PA system. I can't recall whether Chief Kitna indicated whether he tried to use the throw phone or not. It was a process that lasted 32 hours,” Gallegos said.

”There is something for us to consider, to look at to see what reasonable people do, what a standard might be. It is a double-edge sword though, because what else do we know? We know that Chief Kitna with the Eureka Police Department and the Sheriff's Department and -- they were there for 32 hours or roughly 32 hours, and what happened? Mr. Allman ended up dead,” he said.

The transcripts show jurors handed up the involuntary manslaughter indictment on Dec. 3.

Kimberly Wear can be reached at 441-0507 or kwear@times-standard.com.

Ramey warrant
A Ramey warrant is issued before a suspect is charged with a crime, sometimes with the intent to get more evidence on a suspected crime. It is a warrant issued by a judge, and does not require a case to be sent to a prosecutor first.
A Ramey warrant differs from an arrest warrant. An arrest warrant is issued by a judge after felony or misdemeanor charges have been filed. That means there must be enough evidence for a district attorney or city attorney to file a complaint, and the judge agrees there is probable cause.

BOX:
Unsealing the transcripts

The shooting death of Cheri Lyn Moore by Eureka police on April 14, 2006, rocked the community.

From the beginning, the Times-Standard believed that the case held enormous importance to the public. The newspaper exclusively videotaped the coroner's inquest that looked into her death in an effort to air as much information as possible.

When Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos announced he'd be taking the case to the grand jury, we petitioned Gallegos to ask the judge to open the proceedings to the public. He argued for that in court, but was turned down by jurors, who needed to approve an open session along with a judge.

When former Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Anthony Zanotti were indicted by the grand jury, the Times-Standard immediately moved to have the transcripts of the proceedings released, a process that included several hurdles. In the beginning, court officials refused to acknowledge the existence of the case or that an open hearing had been held until the paper directly petitioned Judge John Feeney.

The Times-Standard's legal efforts were led by Roger Myers and his associates at the Holme Roberts & Owen law firm in San Francisco. Myers, a former reporter and editor, is one of California's leading First Amendment lawyers, and is general outside counsel for the California First Amendment Coalition.
The paper was blocked from receiving the records by Douglas and Zanotti's defense team. After repeated motions, the defense largely conceded to our position, and Feeney released the transcripts in their entirety.

'Right to know': Not just words

'Right to know': Not just words'Right to know': Not just words
Times-Standard
Article Launched: 02/21/2008 01:32:01 AM PST

The Times-Standard is gratified that Superior Court Judge John Feeney on Tuesday upheld the First Amendment and its counterpart in the California Constitution that say court records are presumed to be open to the public unless they are expressly ordered sealed under strictly defined legal tests.

After a legal back-and-forth dating back to last year, when a criminal grand jury handed up indictments of former Eureka Police Chief David Douglas and Lt. Anthony Zanotti in the Cheri Lyn Moore shooting case, Judge Feeney found for the Times-Standard and released the transcripts of the testimony and deliberations. Still to be released, pending review by defense counsel, are a video of the hearing and exhibits that were presented.

The lawyers for Douglas and Zanotti were within their rights -- and indeed probably were obligated to their clients -- to argue that release of the transcripts might taint the jury pool, should the case go to trial. The Times-Standard argued, and the judge agreed, that the defense had not offered any basis for concluding that sealing or redacting testimony and arguments would threaten chances for a fair trial.

Making a stand for freedom of information can sometimes be costly, but it's a duty that the American press has been proud to exercise for more than 200 years, and we hope it will always do so.

It's fitting that this decision in Humboldt County comes just before Sunshine Week, March 16-22, a national initiative to open a dialogue about the importance of open government and freedom of information. Participants include not only print, broadcast and online news media, but also civic groups, libraries, non-profits, schools and others interested in the public's right to know.

Open government is important to liberals, conservatives and everyone in between, for without the free flow of information, the democratic system cannot work.

In Humboldt County this week, it worked.

2.20.2008

Major Dos Rios pot bust

Major Dos Rios pot bust

A multi-agency task force led by the County of Mendocino Marijuana Eradication Team raided a major indoor pot grow at a Dos Rios ranch in the mountainous area above the confluence of Outlet Creek and the Eel River just after dawn on February 13. Six men and one woman were arrested, three children are in the custody of Child Protective Services, and agents seized 100 pounds of processed marijuana, $20,000 in cash, two pistols and seven rifles, and eradicated 5,275 pot plants from seedlings to mature plants in full bud during the raid.

The raid involved law enforcement officers from COMMET, Sonoma County Marijuana Eradication Team, the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency and the California Bureau of Narcotics Enforcement Redding Task Force. The raid resulted from an ongoing investigation, according to police.

As officers arrived at the property suspects were spotted fleeing the scene. One group fled on foot and another was seen traveling down a rough dirt trail toward the Eel River in a Jeep.

The helicopter supporting the raid spotted the Jeep abandoned near the river and helped officers locate two suspects Kite Isaac Finds the Feather and Amanda Lee Wood and three children ages 6, 5 and 2.

According to deputies, Finds the Feather and Wood had fled the residence in the Jeep with the children riding unrestrained in the back of the vehicle along the primitive track, through downed trees and over rough terrain.

"It was fortunate this case did not turn into a tragedy and the suspects were found with the children safe. The way they fled placed the children in danger had the suspect lost control of the Jeep on the road," says sheriff's Lt. Kurt Smallcomb.

The children were given warm clothing before being transported by helicopter to CPS. When found, the children were dressed lightly in short sleeved shirts despite the cold temperatures, say police,

When the suspects were taken into custody, Finds the Feather attempted to hide a loaded handgun at the scene, say police.
Finds the Feather and Cook were arrested on suspicion of cultivation and possession of marijuana for sale, child endangerment and being armed in the commission of a felony and are being held on $500,000 bail.

Finds the Feather is one of the founders of Mendo Maté, according to a Mendo Maté marketing spokesman. The spokesman refused to comment on Finds the Feather's current role, if any, with Mendo Maté unless he had a lawyer present.

Two main buildings at the ranch were used for growing plants, say police. One served as a starter room and processing building and the other as the main grow area. About 271 grow lights were found powered by generators. Two generators, a 400 and a 350 kilowatt unit, powered the operation. The diesel supply for the generators was stored in a plastic water tank and at least 25 gallons of waste oil was found at the scene. Mendocino County Environmental Health inspectors are reviewing the site for contamination caused by the operation.

"It was one of the most extensive grows I've seen," says Lt. Rusty Noe.

One man was spotted by deputies walking on Highway 162 near the bust following the raid. Romero Juan Agudo was questioned by police and advised there were seven men working and living at the site. Agudo, 24, was arrested on suspicion of cultivation of marijuana for sale.

Evidence found during the raid then led deputies to Antonio Alfonso Agudo, 21, whose wallet was found on the scene, and to the arrest of Agudo; Lucha Lorenzana, 21; Aristeo Hernandez Hernandez, 49; and Nacario Lopez-Cruz, 42, on suspicion of cultivation of marijuana for sale.

All five are believed by law enforcement to be Mexican nationals and are now in Mendocino County jail on immigration holds with no-bail status.

By Linda Williams/TWN Staff Writer (The Willits News) http://www.willitsnews.com
Article Launched: 02/20/2008 11:00:05 AM PST

2.18.2008

McK Press - Falor Accuses County of Grand Jury Meddling

By Daniel Mintz - Press Staff Writer - 2/19/08

One of the thorniest situations in county government has gotten more so, as former County Counsel Tamara Falor is alleging that Grand Jury investigations into her resignation and $289,000 damage claim settlement have been manipulated by county employees and officials.

Falor filed another claim against the county on Dec. 24 that asserts she had suffered damage to her reputation, violation of her privacy rights, negligent and intentional emotional distress, defamation and other injuries. A damage payment amount isn't specified.

The claim was rejected by the county because it was not filed within six months of the alleged offenses. An application to file a late claim, received Feb. 1, was denied by the county on Feb. 7. If Falor decides to press her allegations, she can do so through a lawsuit.

The crux of Falor's claim is that a June 2007 Grand Jury report on its investigation into the controversial settlement was intentionally led astray by county officials - including current County Counsel Wendy Chaitin. The claim describes Chaitin as someone who "had an involvement" in the situation that led to Falor's "separation" from county work. And Falor's claim states that this year's Grand Jury - which is completing the investigation - submitted a letter of recommendation supporting Chaitin's "quest to be appointed as county counsel." Sources say the letter exists and was submitted to the Board of Supervisors in late November.

Falor also alleges that the Grand Jury was improperly given advice by members of the County Counsel's Office. "These members have conflicts of interest in this matter, some of which may rise to the level of a pecuniary (personal or financial) interest," the claim states.

The application to file a late claim attributes advice - and a pecuniary interest - to "a county legal representative having involvement in the matter." The Grand Jury was advised that Falor was "not able or willing to testify" and that "the statement the Grand Jury published was not defamatory," according to the claim, which also alleges that the representative "signed off" on the Grand Jury report.

Matt Morehouse, the foreman pro tem of last year's Grand Jury and the foreman of this year's, said no one from the County Counsel's Office has given advice. "The County Counsel's Office at all times refrained from commenting on anything to do with the Falor case - and they still do," he said.

Asked who had legally advised the Grand Jury, Morehouse said it "received no legal advice on this matter." He declined comment when asked if this year's Grand Jury is being advised.

Morehouse declined comment on other aspects of the claim.

The claim also refers to pre-settlement circumstances. It states that Falor "is informed and believes" that one or more county officials "used their positions" to obtain the unsigned settlement agreement and "then disclosed that information." In a letter sent to the county's outside attorney last December, Falor's former lawyer, Wendy Wyse, said that the unsigned settlement document was released to a deputy county counsel. County officials have said that the counsel's office was not involved in the settlement dealings or the Grand Jury probes.

Names of people listed as being responsible for Falor's injuries include Chaitin, former Interim County Counsel Ralph Faust, "certain employees of the County Counsel's Office" and supervisors John Woolley, Bonnie Neely and Jimmy Smith. All three supervisors had voted to appoint Chaitin, who is considered an interim counsel but will be evaluated for permanent appointment.

The claim lists "other county employees and representatives who published and/or released information about Ms. Falor in violation of her rights" as well. Also included are members of the 2006-07 Grand Jury, and the "county employees which led the members... to publish defamatory information about Ms. Falor."

Tainted findings?

Last year's Grand Jury concluded that supervisors approvedthesettlement "secretly and quickly," and "there was considerable written evidence and oral testimony to the effect that Ms. Falor's job performance had been less than satisfactory for several years."

The Grand Jury report also asked why Falor wasn't fired and whether her job performance had been adequately evaluated. The unfinished investigation was handed off to this year's Grand Jury - and Falor has given testimony. But her application to file a late claim outlines alleged problems with the follow-up process, including the Chaitin recommendation letter.

The claim also states that a letter was sent by the current Grand Jury to the Board of Supervisors, informing that one witness - which would be Falor - had testified and "if the board persisted in not testifying, a one-sided report would issue." The claim objects that "no similar letter was sent to claimant before the 2006-2007 Grand Jury issued a one-sided publication from an incomplete investigation that was defamatory to the claimant."

It also gets more specific on some aspects of last year's probe, saying that "defamation and violation of (Falor's) right to privacy were perpetrated by two members of the County Counsel staff, through their testimony to the Grand Jury."

According to the 2006-07 Grand Jury report, testimony was given by the two unnamed county counsel staffers, all five members of the Board of Supervisors and "three other county officials." The report states that "no supervisor or anyone else with detailed knowledge of this incident would reveal the exact reason Ms. Falor was awarded $289,000."

But the claim asserts that one or more members of the Board of Supervisors had "off the record" contact with one or more members of the Grand Jury to talk about "the substance of the matter involving (Falor)."

Responding to the county's assertion that the Dec. 24 claim was untimely, the late claim application states that "It is not reasonable to expect the claimant could have anticipated that county legal representatives would have exerted such extraordinary influence on the Grand Jury process."

Escalating division

The contents of the recent documents likely relate to the situation that led to the controversial settlement.

Falor's absence from her post near the start of 2006 provoked lots of speculation. Sources say management/staff tension within the Counsel's Office had intensified and a letter complaining about Falor was signed by most of the members of the office's staff, including Chaitin.

Sources say the staff complaints were brought to the attention of Supervisor John Woolley during a meeting with him and that the complaint letter was submitted to the Board of Supervisors. And eventually, the county sought outside legal advice on how to fire Falor. Related billing by a Los Angeles law firm began Jan. 3, 2006.

But Falor also took action. By the end of January, the county had received her claim for damages related to things that happened between Nov. 6, 2006 and Jan. 7, 2007. The nature of the claim wasn't specified. Instead, it cited the six general categories open to damage claims, which include defamation,discrimination, harassment, breach of contract and wrongful termination. The claim cited $290,000 as a "minimum" damage amount.

A final agreement on the settlement - and the acceptance of Falor's resignation - was approved by a majority of the Board of Supervisors (Supervisors Jill Geist and Jimmy Smith voted against it) in closed session on March 13, 2006. It concluded a series of Falor-related closed session meetings that began in early January of that year.

Chaitin and County Administrative Officer Loretta Nickolaus both said that that the County Counsel's Office has not advised either the former or current Grand Jury, or supervisors, on the Falor matter. Many of the parties listed in the recent claim were contacted but declined comment.

McK Press - Rape Case Proceeds Against Blue Lake Police Chief

By Daniel Mintz - Press Staff Writer - 2/19/08

Blue Lake Police Chief Dave Gundersen has been charged with drugging his wife to facilitate raping her, but his attorney has said the alleged victim is actually supporting Gundersen's innocence- which the District Attorney's Office attributes to threats and coercion.

Gundersen, a McKinleyville resident, is in jail and charged with 12 counts of spousal rape through use of an "intoxicating substance," and additional counts of witness coercion, violating a court order and possession of a controlled substance without a prescription followed his arrest. He's being held at county jail on $500,000 bail and has pleaded not guilty to all of the charges. Russ Clanton, his Arcata-based attorney, has said that the case is directly related to Gundersen's family court battle with his ex-wife over the custody of their 12-year-old son, who was living with Gundersen and his wife when the alleged crimes happened.

The case against Gundersen began with his arrest by District Attorney investigators on Feb. 8 at the McKinleyville Sheriff's Substation. At a press conference two days later, District Attorney Paul Gallegos said Gundersen's wife, a sergeant in the Blue Lake Police Department, had notified the county Sheriff's Department of the alleged rapes, which the D.A. says span a period from last March to February.

Gallegos wouldn't comment on whether the alleged rapes took place in the home, but he did say some of the offenses may have taken place in Blue Lake. His investigators searched Gundersen's home and seized many items from it, he continued, adding that "it is not unusual for us to seize computers and such, and it is not unusual for us to discover evidence of criminal activity in computers."

But at a press conference the next day, Clanton said the D.A.'s Office "has put their nose into the bedroom of Chief Gundersen and his current wife" and has failed to realize the link to Gundersen's custody battle with his ex-wife. "Allegations have been made to gain advantage in that particular case that are directed tied to the allegations in this case," said Clanton.

A 1999 court report cited by the Times-Standard daily newspaper includes an allegation by Gundersen's ex-wife that he drugged her and raped her. Clanton said Gundersen's current wife is ready to support him in court.

"Her position is that the allegations are untrue, and that the conduct prescribed in the penal code… in fact are not present between she and her husband," he continued.

But in court and in an interview, Gallegos said that taped phone conversations made during Gundersen's jail stay demonstrate that the chief has attempted to coerce the alleged victim into recanting. Referring to Gundersen's wife as Jane Doe, Gallegos said she has been victimized in various ways.

"Jane Doe is the victim, she is the one who came forward to give us information and she is also the victim of an attempt to dissuade," he said.

In a Thursday, Feb. 14, bail hearing, Clanton indicated Gundersen's wife would support his opposition to the charges and that the taped conversations have been misrepresented by the D.A. Asked about that in an interview, Gallegos said the tapes will be further discussed and perhaps played in court during a preliminary hearing, which is set for Feb. 27.

Will Gundersen's wife support his stance in the case? "If that exists, it will be brought up at the preliminary hearing," said Gallegos. "Whether it's convincing is another thing - but it sounds like something the defense would bring up in court."

Gallegos said he's never met Jane Doe, and has only seen her in photographs and videotaped interviews. Gallegos said he couldn't comment on whether Jane Doe has been interviewed since Gundersen's arraignment and bail hearing, but added that "at the preliminary hearing, one would expect more information."

As he did in court, Gallegos asserted that Gundersen should remain in jail. "We think he's a danger to the community and certainly the community includes Jane Doe," he said.
###
One week's coverage:
✓ TS Blue Lake police chief arrested for alleged rape 2/9/08
✓ ER Blue Lake Police Chief arrested on suspicion of rape 2/9/08
✓ TS DA: Allegations stem back a couple years, may have been continual occurrence 2/10/08
✓ ER Blue Lake police chief accused of multiple assaults 2/11/08
✓ TS News spreads quickly in sleepy Blue Lake
✓ KMUD Daniel Mintz interview with Gallegos. Click on KMUD Local News, 6:00 pm edition, Monday, February 11, 2008 6:00 pm
✓ TS No charging decision made in Gundersen case, says DA 2/12/08
✓ TS Attorney: Gundersen claims 'false'
✓ TS Gallegos sticks to his guns regarding investigation into Blue Lake police chief
✓ ER Defense attorney announced for Blue Lake Police Chief 2/13/08
✓ ER Blue Lake residents speak out against police chief 2/13/08
✓ TS Gallegos sticks to his guns regarding investigation into Blue Lake police chief 2/13/08
✓ TS In tense meeting, council puts off action on jailed police chief 2/13/08
✓ TS Gundersen hit with 12 counts of rape
✓ TS Gundersen pleads not guilty to 12 rape charges 2/14/08
✓ ER Police Chief denied release from jail — $500,000 bail stands 2/15/08
✓ TS Judge denies police chief's release 2/15/08
✓ ER Gundersen: No stranger to bumpy roads 2/16/08

BLOGS:
☛ Heraldo - Blue Lake Police Chief Arrested for Rape
☛ The Wasp - Gallegos the Sneak
☛ The Wasp = Correction/Update
☛ The Wasp - Gold stars for Thad and John...but something's amiss
☛ Fred: What???
☛ Fred: Prosecutions
☛ SoHum Parlance - Blue Lake police chief denied OR

BACKGROUND/PAST HISTORY
✓ Legal Defense Fund http://www.porac.org/ldf/articles/february%201%201998.html
Adelanto Showdown: Officers vs Counci February 1998