THE FINANCIAL ROOTS OF HEADWATERS
by Daniel Ihara
The roots of the Headwaters Forest controversy extend not only down into the soil of Humboldt County, but also back in time to the financial shenanigans of the 1980s. It is important to understand these roots as the federal government, stockholders and the courts search for resolutions to Headwaters-related issues.
First, Maxxam could not have taken over Pacific Lumber if not for junk bonds and the "Junk Bond King," Michael Milken. Junk bonds -- politely called "high yield, high risk" bonds -- have been around for a long time. But they didn't hit it big until Milken realized that a collection of junk bonds paid higher returns than safer investments, even taking into account the proportion of bonds that defaulted on interest payments.
And second, Maxxam could not have taken over Pacific Lumber if vast changes had not occurred in the savings and loan industry. In the late 1980s at the close of the Jimmy Carter presidency, interest rates and inflation shot up into the double digits. This left savings and loan institutions stuck with home mortgages paying 3 percent while banks and money market funds were paying triple that amount to depositors.
This was the first savings and loan crisis. But instead of biting the bullet and letting these savings and loans collapse, the Reagan administration, in the spirit of deregulation, allowed them to take on higher yielding, riskier investments.
At the same time, and also in the spirit of deregulation, the government reduced the number of government regulators reviewing savings and loan activity. What was retained, though, was government insurance of saving and loan deposits used for riskier investments.
Savings and loans now had funds and authorization to buy high-yield investments while being insured by the government, and Milken had the junk bonds to sell them. All that was lacking was something to buy with junk bond money. Enter corporate raiders and leveraged buyouts.
Corporate raiders borrow money to buy control of companies. Although their own assets may be small, corporate raiders borrow by using the assets they will acquire as collateral, or backing, for the millions (sometimes billions) of dollars that they borrow.
Corporate raiders make no profit if the amount they borrow simply equals the value of the assets they purchased, but there are ways such corporate takeovers can make sense.
One, if the company being taken over has assets worth more than the value of all that company's stock, then someone who gains control of all this stock could sell off the company's assets, pay off money borrowed to buy the company and come out ahead.
Or two, a corporate takeover could break implied contracts, agreements or practices that had allowed the targeted company to function in the past. For example, a company's management might have an unwritten commitment to provide long-term employment in exchange for employees' agreement not to strike for higher wages. Or there might be an unwritten policy that the company would practice voluntary sustained yield harvesting for long-term stability instead of short-term profits and fluctuating employment levels. There are those who argue such was the case with Pacific Lumber before the Maxxam takeover.
Pacific Lumber's Articles of Incorporation state:
"The board of directors ... when evaluating any offer of another party ... to merge or consolidate this corporation with another corporation ... shall ... give due consideration to ... all relevant factors, including without limitation the social, legal, environmental and economic effects on the employees, customers, suppliers, and other constituencies of this corporation ... on the communities and geographical areas in which this corporation and its subsidiaries operate or are located."
-- Articles of Incorporation 1981, Article 10
In addition,
"any dissolution or liquidation of this corporation (as would occur in a corporate merger) shall require the affirmative vote of not less than eighty percent (80 percent) of the outstanding shares of this corporation entitled to vote, if ... any other corporation, person or entity beneficially owns or controls, directly or indirectly, five percent (5 percent) or more of the outstanding stock of this corporation." (Article 6)
A lawsuit in Humboldt County Superior Court alleges that when the PALCO board or directors agreed to the merger Oct. 22, 1985, it "was under the erroneous assumption that Hurwitz held less than 5 percent of Pacific Lumber stock and therefore needed only 50 percent ownership (instead of 80 percent) to effectuate a merger."
Further, this suit alleges that
"Hurwitz ... along with convicted felons Milken, Drexel Burnham Lambert, and Ivan Boesky engaged in ... securities manipulations as part of the continuing plan, scheme, and unlawful conspiracy .... to defraud Pacific Lumber shareholders with resulting injury to the non-shareholder constituencies of Pacific Lumber, (which) constituted and was part of a pattern of racketeering activity." (Thompson et al vs. Hurwitz et al. )
Pete Stark and 12 other representatives in Congress last month asked the Securities Exchange Commission to "consider an enforcement seeking the disgorgement of any wrongful gains that may have resulted from the takeover of Pacific Lumber."
Finally, the latter part of the 1980s saw the collapse both of junk bond prices and many savings and loan institutions. One of the largest to collapse was United Savings Association of Texas, controlled by Charles Hurwitz. Its demise cost U.S. taxpayers $1.6 billion to bail out. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. is seeking recovery of $250 million and the federal government's Office of Thrift Supervision might recover more than $1 billion because of the collapse of Hurwitz's Texas saving and loan. The OTS suit is scheduled to be heard beginning Sept. 22 in Houston.
(Note: For additional information, The Last Stand by David Harris, now in paperback, tells the dramatic story of the takeover with its vivid cast of characters.)
Daniel M. Ihara is the economics consultant for Humboldt County and Redwood Region Economic Development Commission, and an economics instructor at Humboldt State University.
5.01.2007
The high cost of "Humboldt Baykeeper"
Someday it would be interesting to see a study done on the costs to society caused by the 'orgs.' They have become a scared cow by touting the benefits of their activities, which are taken at face value, but there is a flip side. It's not just the costs incurred in paying out go-away money. or in paying lawyers to help defend against this predatory litigious "group" - its the time and the meetings spent having to deal with it all:
NORTH COAST RAILROAD AUTHORITY (NCRA)
BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 ~ 10:00 a.m.
Humboldt County Supervisors Chambers
825 5th Street, Eureka
Humboldt County
DRAFT AGENDA
AGENDA NOTE
All items appearing on the agenda are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to change by the Board.
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. ROLL CALL
C. AGENDA APPROVAL
D. MATTERS FROM THE BOARD
1. Recognition of Outgoing Board Member – Peter LaVallee
E. COMMITTEE REPORTS
1. Operator Committee Report – Chairman Hemphill
2. Policies and Procedures Committee Report – Director Kelley
F. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Approval of Minutes – November 2006
2. Approval of Financial Statements - November 2006
3. Approval of Financial Statements – December 2006
4. Approval of Warrants Issued – November 2006
5. Approval of Warrants Issued – December 2006
6. Approval of Executive Directors Expenses - November & December 2006
7. Approval of 2007 Board Meeting Schedule
8. Approval of Extension of Lease – Talmage Office
G. PUBLIC COMMENT
Comments will be limited to three minutes per person and not more than ten minutes per subject, so that everyone can be heard. “Public comment” time is limited to matters under the jurisdiction of the Authority that may not have been considered by the Authority previously and are not on the agenda. No action will be taken. Members of the public may also comment during specific agenda items when recognized by the Chair.
H. CONDUCT OF BUSINESS
1. Election of Officers
2006 2007
Board Chair – Allan Hemphill __________________________
Board Vice Chair – Vacant __________________________
Finance Committee
Vacant – Chair ___________________________
Paul Kelley ___________________________
Bob Simonson ___________________________
Property Committee
Bob Simonson – Chair ___________________________
Paul Kelley ___________________________
1 Vacant Seat ___________________________
Ad Hoc Operator Committee
Allan Hemphill –Chair ____________________________
Bob Simonson
1 Vacant Seat ____________________________
____________________________
Humboldt Bay Harbor District Joint Advisory Committee
John Woolley -Chair _____________________________
Charles Ollivier _____________________________
1 Vacant Seat _____________________________
AD- Hoc Policies and Procedures Committee
John Woolley ______________________________
Paul Kelley ______________________________
1 Vacant Seat ______________________________
2. Authorize Staff to Execute Contract for NCRA Planning, Engineering, and Project Management Services.
I. STAFF REPORTS
1. Operator’s Report - John Williams – NWP Co.
2. Engineer’s Report – Dave Anderson - NCRA Project Manager
3. Executive Director – Mitch Stogner
a. Proposition 1B Application / CTC Update
b. Reintroduction of SB 792 (Chesbro)
c. FEMA/OES Equipment
d. Sign Removal Eureka to Arcata
4. Legal Counsel - Chris Neary
J. CLOSED SESSION
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-Existing Litigation (3 Cases)
Government Code Section 54956.9 (a)
(a) NWPY Arbitration
(b) Humboldt Baykeeper vs. Union Pacific, NCRA et al.
United States District Court, # C-06-02560 JW
(c) Humboldt Baykeeper vs. Simpson, NCRA et al\
United States District Court, # C-06-4188 JL
2. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-Initiation of litigation
Government Code Section 54956.9 (c) one case
Announcement of the litigation would jeopardize NCRA’s
Ability to conclude existing settlement negotiations to its advantage.
3. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-Initiation of Litigation
Government Code Section 54956.9 (c)
Litigation to be discussed: Enforcement of Billboard Removal on NCRA property.
K. ANNOUNCEMENT OUT OF CLOSED SESSION
L. ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT MEETING
February 14, 2007 - 10:00 a.m.
Willits City Council Chambers
111 East Commercial Street, Willits
Mendocino County
M. ADJOURNMENT
AGENDA NOTE
All items appearing on the agenda are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to change by the Board.
AMERICAN WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA) REQUESTS
To request disability-related modifications or accommodations for accessible locations or meeting materials in alternative formats (as allowed under Section 12132 of the ADA) please contact the NCRA office at 707 463-3280, at least 72 hours before the meeting.
ADDITIONS TO AGENDA
The Brown Act, Section 54954.2, states that the Board may take action on off-agenda items when: a) a majority vote determines that an “emergency situation” exists as defined in Section 54956.5, or b) a two-thirds vote of the body, or a unanimous vote of those present, determines that there is a need to take immediate action and the need for action arose after the agenda was legally posted, or c) the item was continued from a prior, legally posted meeting not more than five calendar days before this meeting.
CLOSED SESSION
If agendized, NCRA may adjourn to a closed session to consider litigation or personnel matters. Discussion of litigation or pending litigation may be held in closed session by authority of Government Code Section 54956.9; discussion of personnel matters by authority of Government Code Section 54957; to confer with their negotiator regarding real property by authority of Government Code Section 54956.8.
NORTH COAST RAILROAD AUTHORITY (NCRA)
BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING
Wednesday, January 10, 2007 ~ 10:00 a.m.
Humboldt County Supervisors Chambers
825 5th Street, Eureka
Humboldt County
DRAFT AGENDA
AGENDA NOTE
All items appearing on the agenda are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to change by the Board.
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. ROLL CALL
C. AGENDA APPROVAL
D. MATTERS FROM THE BOARD
1. Recognition of Outgoing Board Member – Peter LaVallee
E. COMMITTEE REPORTS
1. Operator Committee Report – Chairman Hemphill
2. Policies and Procedures Committee Report – Director Kelley
F. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Approval of Minutes – November 2006
2. Approval of Financial Statements - November 2006
3. Approval of Financial Statements – December 2006
4. Approval of Warrants Issued – November 2006
5. Approval of Warrants Issued – December 2006
6. Approval of Executive Directors Expenses - November & December 2006
7. Approval of 2007 Board Meeting Schedule
8. Approval of Extension of Lease – Talmage Office
G. PUBLIC COMMENT
Comments will be limited to three minutes per person and not more than ten minutes per subject, so that everyone can be heard. “Public comment” time is limited to matters under the jurisdiction of the Authority that may not have been considered by the Authority previously and are not on the agenda. No action will be taken. Members of the public may also comment during specific agenda items when recognized by the Chair.
H. CONDUCT OF BUSINESS
1. Election of Officers
2006 2007
Board Chair – Allan Hemphill __________________________
Board Vice Chair – Vacant __________________________
Finance Committee
Vacant – Chair ___________________________
Paul Kelley ___________________________
Bob Simonson ___________________________
Property Committee
Bob Simonson – Chair ___________________________
Paul Kelley ___________________________
1 Vacant Seat ___________________________
Ad Hoc Operator Committee
Allan Hemphill –Chair ____________________________
Bob Simonson
1 Vacant Seat ____________________________
____________________________
Humboldt Bay Harbor District Joint Advisory Committee
John Woolley -Chair _____________________________
Charles Ollivier _____________________________
1 Vacant Seat _____________________________
AD- Hoc Policies and Procedures Committee
John Woolley ______________________________
Paul Kelley ______________________________
1 Vacant Seat ______________________________
2. Authorize Staff to Execute Contract for NCRA Planning, Engineering, and Project Management Services.
I. STAFF REPORTS
1. Operator’s Report - John Williams – NWP Co.
2. Engineer’s Report – Dave Anderson - NCRA Project Manager
3. Executive Director – Mitch Stogner
a. Proposition 1B Application / CTC Update
b. Reintroduction of SB 792 (Chesbro)
c. FEMA/OES Equipment
d. Sign Removal Eureka to Arcata
4. Legal Counsel - Chris Neary
J. CLOSED SESSION
1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-Existing Litigation (3 Cases)
Government Code Section 54956.9 (a)
(a) NWPY Arbitration
(b) Humboldt Baykeeper vs. Union Pacific, NCRA et al.
United States District Court, # C-06-02560 JW
(c) Humboldt Baykeeper vs. Simpson, NCRA et al\
United States District Court, # C-06-4188 JL
2. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-Initiation of litigation
Government Code Section 54956.9 (c) one case
Announcement of the litigation would jeopardize NCRA’s
Ability to conclude existing settlement negotiations to its advantage.
3. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL-Initiation of Litigation
Government Code Section 54956.9 (c)
Litigation to be discussed: Enforcement of Billboard Removal on NCRA property.
K. ANNOUNCEMENT OUT OF CLOSED SESSION
L. ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT MEETING
February 14, 2007 - 10:00 a.m.
Willits City Council Chambers
111 East Commercial Street, Willits
Mendocino County
M. ADJOURNMENT
AGENDA NOTE
All items appearing on the agenda are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to action by the Board of Directors. Staff recommendations are subject to change by the Board.
AMERICAN WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA) REQUESTS
To request disability-related modifications or accommodations for accessible locations or meeting materials in alternative formats (as allowed under Section 12132 of the ADA) please contact the NCRA office at 707 463-3280, at least 72 hours before the meeting.
ADDITIONS TO AGENDA
The Brown Act, Section 54954.2, states that the Board may take action on off-agenda items when: a) a majority vote determines that an “emergency situation” exists as defined in Section 54956.5, or b) a two-thirds vote of the body, or a unanimous vote of those present, determines that there is a need to take immediate action and the need for action arose after the agenda was legally posted, or c) the item was continued from a prior, legally posted meeting not more than five calendar days before this meeting.
CLOSED SESSION
If agendized, NCRA may adjourn to a closed session to consider litigation or personnel matters. Discussion of litigation or pending litigation may be held in closed session by authority of Government Code Section 54956.9; discussion of personnel matters by authority of Government Code Section 54957; to confer with their negotiator regarding real property by authority of Government Code Section 54956.8.
4.29.2007
NCJ - Activist must pay fees
Activist must pay fees
Local activist Bob Martel received an expensive setback this week in his ongoing battle against Pacific Lumber and its parent company, MAXXAM. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Martel's appeal to an earlier decision in MAXXAM's favor and ordered him to pay the company legal fees of more than $110,000.
The case concerns the failure in 1988 of a savings and loan association in which MAXXAM and its chairman, Charles Hurwitz, were investors. Martel contends that Hurwitz exercised control over the company; Hurwitz denies the charges. Related cases are still pending, but the court ruled that Martel's case was "frivolous."
Martel disputes that claim, saying that the suit cost him $250,000 and took five years of research. That, he said, "doesn't actually fit the definition of frivolous."
As to how he might pay the legal fees awarded by the court, Martel said he hasn't earned "more than six thousand dollars in a year in recent memory"
MAXXAM spokesman Josh Reiss said that the corporation intends to pursue the claim.
Local activist Bob Martel received an expensive setback this week in his ongoing battle against Pacific Lumber and its parent company, MAXXAM. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Martel's appeal to an earlier decision in MAXXAM's favor and ordered him to pay the company legal fees of more than $110,000.
The case concerns the failure in 1988 of a savings and loan association in which MAXXAM and its chairman, Charles Hurwitz, were investors. Martel contends that Hurwitz exercised control over the company; Hurwitz denies the charges. Related cases are still pending, but the court ruled that Martel's case was "frivolous."
Martel disputes that claim, saying that the suit cost him $250,000 and took five years of research. That, he said, "doesn't actually fit the definition of frivolous."
As to how he might pay the legal fees awarded by the court, Martel said he hasn't earned "more than six thousand dollars in a year in recent memory"
MAXXAM spokesman Josh Reiss said that the corporation intends to pursue the claim.
Labels:
"Humboldt Watershed Council",
Bob Martel,
Ken MIller,
PL Suit
NCJ - Order to pay attorney fees (Bob Martel)
An interesting piece of the puzzle. The genesis of Humboldt Watershed Council? A failed lawsuit, the first of many.
Order to pay attorney fees
A taxpayer and a local nonprofit group have been ordered to pay legal fees for two separate lawsuits involving Pacific Lumber and its chief stockholder, Charles Hurwitz.
In 1995, Humboldt County resident Robert Martel filed suit against Hurwitz, alleging he had defrauded the federal government of $1.6 billion in the collapse of the United Savings Association of Texas 11 years ago, according to a report in the Times-Standard. Now Martel has been ordered by U.S. District Court Judge Lynn Hughes to pay Hurwitz' $110,123 in legal fees and expenses.
Hughes ruled that Martel's suit was "abusive litigation" because Martel had based much of his suit on information garnered from newspaper reports. Hughes also said Martel, who had filed the suit as a taxpayer, lacked standing to sue on behalf of the federal government.
Neither Martel nor Hurwitz could be reached for comment.
In a separate case, the Garberville-based Environmental Protection Information Center was ordered to pay Pacific Lumber $17,731 in legal costs as a result of a June 1997 lawsuit. EPIC sued PL in March of 1995, maintaining that the California Department of Forestry should have prepared an environmental impact study before it granted the company a salvage-logging permit for spotted owl habitat now protected as part of the Headwaters Reserve.
EPIC spokesperson Kevin Bundy said U.S. District court judge Louis Bechtle dismissed the suit because EPIC "couldn't convince the court (salvage logging) would violate the endangered species act."
John A. Campbell, PL president, recently issued a statement saying PL is entitled to the court costs.
"The favorable court ruling highlighted that salvage and other logging would not cause a take of endangered species," he said. "The court ... made clear in this case that endangered species would benefit from the working relationship developed by Pacific Lumber, federal wildlife agencies and the California Department of Forestry."
Bundy said the amount EPIC must pay is a fraction of the $700,000 PL originally requested to cover fees.
Order to pay attorney fees
A taxpayer and a local nonprofit group have been ordered to pay legal fees for two separate lawsuits involving Pacific Lumber and its chief stockholder, Charles Hurwitz.
In 1995, Humboldt County resident Robert Martel filed suit against Hurwitz, alleging he had defrauded the federal government of $1.6 billion in the collapse of the United Savings Association of Texas 11 years ago, according to a report in the Times-Standard. Now Martel has been ordered by U.S. District Court Judge Lynn Hughes to pay Hurwitz' $110,123 in legal fees and expenses.
Hughes ruled that Martel's suit was "abusive litigation" because Martel had based much of his suit on information garnered from newspaper reports. Hughes also said Martel, who had filed the suit as a taxpayer, lacked standing to sue on behalf of the federal government.
Neither Martel nor Hurwitz could be reached for comment.
In a separate case, the Garberville-based Environmental Protection Information Center was ordered to pay Pacific Lumber $17,731 in legal costs as a result of a June 1997 lawsuit. EPIC sued PL in March of 1995, maintaining that the California Department of Forestry should have prepared an environmental impact study before it granted the company a salvage-logging permit for spotted owl habitat now protected as part of the Headwaters Reserve.
EPIC spokesperson Kevin Bundy said U.S. District court judge Louis Bechtle dismissed the suit because EPIC "couldn't convince the court (salvage logging) would violate the endangered species act."
John A. Campbell, PL president, recently issued a statement saying PL is entitled to the court costs.
"The favorable court ruling highlighted that salvage and other logging would not cause a take of endangered species," he said. "The court ... made clear in this case that endangered species would benefit from the working relationship developed by Pacific Lumber, federal wildlife agencies and the California Department of Forestry."
Bundy said the amount EPIC must pay is a fraction of the $700,000 PL originally requested to cover fees.
Labels:
"Humboldt Watershed Council",
Bob Martel,
Ken MIller
4.28.2007
DEBT FOR TREES PART 1 and PART 2
This is an interesting chronology of the Pacific Lumber/Headwaters saga, complete with the high level players, and the pressure groups, big Foundations and extremist environmental groups:
This is the link to this two part series. It works most of the time.
DEBT FOR TREES PART 1
from there you can link to PART 2.
Both are included below:
DEBT FOR TREES PART 1
By Jon Christian Ryter September 1, 2005 NewsWithViews.com
Houston financier and corporate raider Charles Hurwitz's problems began with the collapse of a little known Texas thrift in 1988, United Savings Association of Texas—only Hurwitz's purported complicity in the collapse of the savings and loan company never surfaced until about the time his company, MCO Holdings (which changed its name in 1995 to Maxxam, Inc.) assumed Pacific Lumber Company in 1986. Once the Pacific Lumber buyout was complete Hurwitz's problems began. But not from the US government— from environmentalists.
One of Pacific Lumber's most valuable assets was a stand of 1,000-plus year old coastal redwood trees in Humboldt County—in a 6,000 acre tract of ancient redwoods in the 90,000 acre Headwaters' Forest know as the Headwaters Grove. Each of the 300 foot tall ancient giant redwoods have a commercial street value—as cut lumber—of at least $100,000. Hurwitz, who used junk bonds to finance his takeover of Pacific Lumber needed to liquidate some of the assets of the newly acquired company to pay down the debt.
Hurwitz became interested in Pacific Lumber when junk bond investment banker Drexel Burnham Lambert advised MCO that Pacific Lumber had made an overpriced offer to buy back its own stock in 1984, causing MCO to take a closer look at the company as a potential hostile takeover since Pacific was not interested in suitors. And the closer Hurwitz looked, the better Pacific Lumber looked. Finally, in October, 1985 he went after it, assuming control of the company in 1986.
Environmentalists feared Hurwitz would clear-cut the Headwaters Grove of its ancient treasures to pay for the takeover. In reality, Hurwitz already planned to sell off specific assets of Pacific Lumber to pay for the takeover—and the Headwaters Grove was not part of his thinking. However, MCO Holdings, which was extremely leveraged, still needed to generate a revenue stream, and planned to clear-cut up to a thousand acres of Pacific Lumber's expansive reserve of Douglas pines, spruce, coastal redwoods and other timber species which the company owned. Within a matter of months, Hurwitz doubled Pacific Lumber's relatively conservative lumber harvesting practices. That convinced the greens that a land-stripper had taken over the 117 year old company.
Pacific Lumber was an institution in northern California, and had been since 1869. It was the largest employer in Humboldt County, owning around 194,000 acres of prime timberland worth billions of dollars at retail. Yet, it was not as profitable as it could have been, or should have been, due to environmentalists who did everything possible to hamstring logging operations for over a decade. The constant inference of Pacific's logging operation by radical green groups made Pacific Lumber "easy pickings" for any corporate raider. When Hurwitz took it over it wasn't long before green groups like Earth First!, the Sierra Club and Greenpeace were targeting Hurwitz, who became the "scorched earth" villain.
In January 1995, Humboldt environmentalist activist Robert Martel filled a lawsuit in US District Court against Maxxam, Industries seeking $1.6 billion to cover the losses suffered by Maxxam's bankrupt S&L, United Savings Association of Texas plus an additional $4.8 billion in punitive damages on behalf of the American taxpayers. Because Martel represented neither the government nor the depositors of United Savings, there was no legal basis for his filing. But, his lawsuit opened Pandora's box. When the federal court—which should never have accepted the action in the first placed—ruled against him, Martel appealed that court's decision to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals. The appellate court not only rejected Martel's appeal, it ordered him to pay Maxxam's legal fees of more than $110,000, saying that Martel's case was "frivolous"
In August of 1995, FDIC Chairman Ricki Tigert-Helfer filed the first of two "recovery" lawsuits in US District Court in Houston. The action, FDIC v Hurwitz, sought $250 million in damages—not from Maxxam (as MCO Holding had been renamed)—but from Hurwitz personally. When she filed her suit, Tigert-Helfer asked the Office of Thrift Management to investigate Charles Hurwitz and Maxxam for wrongdoing. In December, 1995 the Office of Thrift Management filed 13 claims against the defendants of its own lawsuit—against Hurwitz, Maxxam, two other Maxxam companies: Federated Development Company, United Financial Group (which was the parent company of United Savings), and the former and current directors of the S&L. The OTM sought $821 million in damages. The FDIC and the OTM both alleged that Hurwitz's business dealings with Drexel Burnham Lambert contributed significantly to the thrift's failure by not keeping it properly capitalized. They also alleged that Hurwitz "raided" the assets of United Savings to purchase Pacific Lumber, making Hurwitz personally liable for the $1.6 billion the OTM claims United Savings lost.
From the time the dual actions were filed by the FDIC and the OTM, Hurwitz's lawyer, Richard Keeton, was approached by various environmental groups suggesting that the government would entertain a "debt-for-trees" swap. Hurwitz would get to walk away from the FDIC and OTM charges if he agreed to allow the old stand of 300' tall redwoods in Headwaters Grove be deeded to the US government. The government would make the Headwaters redwoods part of the Six Rivers National Forest. In the early 1990s, Howard Hughes' estate engaged in a "debt for nature" swap when the estate traded some wetlands near the Los Angeles Airport to settle a tax bill owed the State of California. Several third world countries swapped land that US environmentalists thought should be protected for the debt they owed the United States. Bolivia traded tropical forests to clear their debt. Land swaps were also done with the Philippines and several other nations as well.
In February, 1997 Deputy Interior Secretary John Garamendi approached Maxxam to arrange for the acquisition of the Headwater Grove. Maxxam's general counsel, J. Kent Friedman, told the Clinton Administration official that Maxxam would consider selling the Headwater Grove to the Interior Department—but only on the condition that the government drop its FDIC lawsuit. "We want this case to go away," Friedman said.
Garamendi reported "...Hurwitz brought that to the table numerous times," but he added, he refused to intervene on Hurwitz's behalf, concluding it would be inappropriate for the Interior Department to get involved in the FDIC's business. Friedman said Maxxam raised the issue about the FDIC case because the action should never have been filed against Hurwitz who had undergone a lengthy, politically-motivated and ultimately unproved investigation by the Clinton Administration and a federal agency that violated its own rules in bringing the action. Hurwitz was not liable for the failure of United Savings because neither he nor Maxxam had controlling interest in United Financial—the holding company that had a minority interest in United Savings—therefore neither Hurwitz nor Maxxam had any legal authority to control the capital levels at the thrift.
At the time the Garamendi negotiations were underway, the Rose Foundation for Communities and the Government and several other environmentalist groups managed to convince a federal court that Pacific Lumber and a neighboring lumbering camp, Elk River Timber Company, had both violated the Endangered Species Act by logging pristine forests that sheltered the spotted owl. The federal court issued an injunction forbidding either Elk River Timber or Pacific Lumber from harvesting their land. Nine times the environmentalists filed suit in federal court. Nine times the court issued injunctions forbidding the lumber companies from cutting trees on their own land due to violations of the Endangered Species Act.
(Author's note: While I did not find documents to support my belief that Hurwitz, Friedman and Keeton were very bluntly, off-the-record, advised that they might as well sell the Headwater Grove to the environmentalists and get something for their buck because it was unlikely that, anytime in the foreseeable future, they would be able to harvest any lumber from that area since the Headwaters Forest was home to the spotted owl.)
In 1999 Hurwitz caved in and sold 10,000 acres of Headwaters Forest land to the Department of the Interior for $480 million. The deal was brokered by Sen. Diane Feinstein to preserve the old growth giant coastlal redwoods. In 2002 the FDIC dropped its 250 million action against Hurwitz when the OTM settled their $821 million case under an agreement where Hurwitz paid $206 thousand, made no admissions of wrongdoing, and agreed not to discuss the suit or the settlement.
But in his settlement, Hurwitz never agreed not to file suit against the government. He immediately sued the FDIC, by asking US District Court Judge Lynn Hughes (the presiding judge in the government's case) to award him $72 million in damages to cover his costs to fight not only the FDIC charges, but the costs associated with fighting to keep the government from seizing his redwood trees—and fighting frivolous lawsuits from the Rose Foundation, the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, Earth First! and scores of other green groups who lined up to take their best shot at Maxxam in court while Maxxam and Hurwitz were distracted with the FDIC lawsuit.
Don't miss the concuding Part 2 "whodunnit" to understand how our fine justice system really works.
© 2005 Jon C. Ryter - All Rights Reserved
DEBT FOR TREES
PART 2
By Jon Christian Ryter September 1, 2005 NewsWithViews.com
In 1999 Charles Hurwitz caved in and sold 10,000 acres of Headwaters Forest land to the Department of the Interior for $480 million. The deal was brokered by Sen. Diane Feinstein to preserve the old growth giant coastlal redwoods. In 2002 the FDIC dropped its 250 million action against Hurwitz when the OTM settled their $821 million case under an agreement where Hurwitz paid $206 thousand, made no admissions of wrongdoing, and agreed not to discuss the suit or the settlement.
But in his settlement, Hurwitz never agreed not to file suit against the government. He immediately sued the FDIC, by asking US District Court Judge Lynn Hughes (the presiding judge in the government's case) to award him $72 million in damages to cover his costs to fight not only the FDIC charges, but the costs associated with fighting to keep the government from seizing his redwood trees—and fighting frivolous lawsuits from the Rose Foundation, the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, Earth First! and scores of other green groups who lined up to take their best shot at Maxxam in court while Maxxam and Hurwitz were distracted with the FDIC lawsuit.
Hurwitz, through his lawyers, claimed that the Clinton Administration's FDIC [a] improperly funded another government agency's investigative witch hunt against Maxxam on the same matter; and, [b] his suite alleged that the Clinton Administration used bogus lawsuits in an attempt to force him to surrender over a billion dollars worth of prime coastal redwood trees to settle bogus claims against him and his company.
On Tuesday, August 23, 2005 US District Court Judge Lynn Nettleton Hughes issued his decision in FDIC v Hurwitz. It was a scathing denunciation of a government, pressured by radical environmentalist, to railroad an innocent man solely to steal his land for special interest extremists. In what is now the largest judgment against a federal agency ever awarded, Hughes ordered the FDIC to pay Hurwitz $72.3 million. In his 133-page decision, Hughes compared the federal investigations of Hurwitz and Maxxam to "...secret society of extortionists [that had practiced] craven submission [when faced with pressure from the office of the Vice President of the United States and] the green groups to cause him pain." Hughes said Hurwitz was the victim of a vindictive and politically-motivated federal agency. Hughes referred to the ordeal Hurwitz was forced to endure in terms of the Boston Tea Party, writing that "...Sam Adams would say that somebody needs to dump the FDIC's tea overboard." Hughes found, in his decision, that the FDIC, in close concert with environmental groups, sued Hurwitz to pressure him into a "debt-for-nature" swap, in effect giving the government about a billion dollars worth of trees in exchange for his supposed liability in the failure of the United Savings Association of Texas.
Paul Mason, a lobbyist and green activist for the Sierra Club summed up the view of the environmentalist movement when he noted that Judge Hughes had been hostile to the government's case against Hurwitz from the beginning. "To state that the environmental community was steering the case," Mason told the media, "would strongly overstate the influence we had with the federal government."
The question is, who's telling the truth and who's lying? That's the part of the story you won't read in your local newspaper this evening—nor will you see it on Fox News. The chronology of events is not deeply hidden. A Google search will bring you most of the headlines. A little digging will give you the rest.
For the environmentalists to even suggest that not only were they not steering the Hurwitz case, but that they hadn't engineered it by persuading Vice President Al Gore, Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt and other bureaucrats in the Clinton Administration to run interference for them in filing a lawsuit for damages against Maxxam that would force Hurwitz to agree to a "debt-for-nature" swap to alleviate his liability in the failure of United Savings Association of Texas—when the FDIC and the Clinton Justice Department knew he was not legally culpable for the failure of the S&L.
The radical environmentalist Earth First! hatched up the scheme for the FDIC to sue Hurwitz for the failure shortly after the co-presidency of Bill and Hillary Clinton descended on Washington, DC. In the usual fashion of the green extremists, Earth First! revealed its idea in a Spring, 1993 demonstration in front of the FDIC, demanding that the government take the old-growth redwoods that belonged to Pacific Lumber Company to settle any claims the FDIC should have with another Hurwitz company, the failed S&L, United Savings Association of Texas. Earth First! later insisted that their suggestion was politely offered at that time only because of the fear that Hurwitz would destroy the thousand year old trees that shielded the habitat of the spotted owl and other endangered species that lived in the Headwaters Forest in Humboldt County, California.
From that demonstration in 1993, both the Clinton Administration and Congress became acutely aware of the Headwaters Forest, Charles Hurwitz, United Savings Association of Texas and the implied liability of Hurwitz, whom the environmentalists claimed raided the assets of United Savings to leverage Pacific Lumber. Shortly after the demonstration Greenpeace, the Sierra Club Legal Defense Fund and the Rose Foundation for Community and the Government began to leverage Congress and Mr. Environment—Al Gore, Jr. The Rose Foundation and the Sierra Club became fixtures on Capitol Hill as they made their way from one Congressional and Senatorial office to another, and from the FDIC to the Office of Thrift Management, to the White House and Blair House, asking for legislation that would both implicate and exonerate Hurwitz by arranging a debt-for-trees swap in which the FDIC would exchange Hurwitz's liability in United Savings for 57,000 to 76,000 acres of Headwaters Forest which would be placed in the public trust.
In 1994 Congressman Dan Hamburg [D-CA] introduced a bill in the House of Representatives that would authorize the US Forest Service to "negotiate" the transfer of the Headwaters Forest under eminent domain to the US government and make it part of the Six Rivers National Forest. The bill passed in the House, but the Senate version of the bill, introduced by Barbara Boxer [D-CA], never made it out of committee and onto the Senate floor for a vote. When the GOP Revolution in November of 1994 pushed the Democrats out of all of the committee chairs in both the House and Senate, the odds of enacting the Headwaters bill was greatly diminished. The environmentalists reverted to the suggestion made by Earth First!—convince the FDIC to file suit against Hurwitz and then swap the Headwaters for a release from liability on United Savings Association of Texas.
It was after the defeat of The Hamburg-Boxer Act that Jill Ratner, the lawyer activist head of the Rose Foundation intensified her letter-writing campaign to entice FDIC Chairman Tigert-Helfer to file a lawsuit against Hurwitz and then do a debt-for-trees swap to settle the 1,000 year old redwood tree matter for all time. Ricki Tigert-Helfer replied to Ratner that the FDIC could not compel the defendants of any legal action to consider a debt-for-nature swap since they might decide to use other assets to satisfy their liability. It was obvious that the Bush-41 Administration clearly understood that minority shareholders in companies—unless they are board members—have no fiduciary control over the company, and thus can't be held liable for any capitalization shortfalls of the company. And, it was clear that, by the end of 1994 the Clinton Administration believed they could arbitrarily assign "fault," and in the Headwaters Forest matter, they had arbitrarily decided that Charles Hurwitz was culpable in the United Savings matter because the Sierra Club, Earth First!, Greenpeace and the Rose Foundation convinced the Clinton Administration—without any actual evidence to support their position—that Hurwitz had gutted United Savings Association and used what could be construed as stolen assets to buy Pacific Lumber. Thus, since ill-gotten gains paid for Pacific, it was only fitting to the environmentalists calling for it, that Pacific Lumber assets be used to satisfy the government's case against Hurwitz.
Ratner even raised the issue of debt-for-nature with Maxxam lawyers on several times. One one occasion, Maxxam spokesman Joshua Reiss dismissed Ratner's swap suggestion as a flawed premise since, he said, there is no debt to swap. Hurwitz, he told the media, had done nothing wrong. Since he did not possess controlling interest in United Savings, he had no legal authority to influence their policies.
John V. Thomas, associate general counsel for the FDIC wrote to a green activist, Larry Helbrook of Eleva, Wisconsin on August 23, 1994. Helbrook inquired about a possible debt-for-nature swap to protect the ancient Sequoia giants. Thomas responded, saying "We are mindful of the possibility that if Pacific Lumber's parent can be held liable for our losses, issues involving the redwood forests might be brought into play."
Shortly after she filed suit against Hurwitz, Tigert-Helfer wrote a letter to then US Congressman David E. Skaggs in which she said, in response to his question: "You may be assured that the government remains open to any appropriate settlement of this claim—including a debt-for-nature swap."
Throughout the last months of 1994 there was a flurry of high level meetings between the environmentalist lobbyists from Greenpeace, the Sierra Club, and the Rose Foundation, several liberal Congressmen and Senators, some high level Clinton Administration officials, and Vice President Al Gore who functioned as "control central" on the Hurwitz-Headwaters Forest matter. The high level meetings produced a compromise between the environmentalists and the Clinton Administration. The Al Gore emissary, Deputy Interior Secretary John Garamendi, was sent to Sacramento to meet with Hurwitz and his lawyers and negotiate the "surrender" of the Headwaters Forest.
For the environmentalists and former Clinton-Gore officials to claim they did not originate the debt-for-nature swap, or attempt to influence the filing of charges against Charles Hurwitz by the FDIC specifically to pressure him into settling the lawsuit by trading a billion dollars worth of redwood trees for a handful of spotted owls. Judge Lynn Hughes was right—the government lied. FDIC officials "...discarded the mantle of the American Republic for the clock of a secret society of extortionists. If the Vice President called, they responded. If a lobbyist called, they responded. They heeded every call but that of duty and honor."
FDIC spokesman David Barr said the agency will appeal the judgment. If the 5th Circuit Court knows how to do a Google search, without even holding a hearing, it will find enough material to uphold the opinion of Judge Hughes. If, on the other hand, the judges on the 5th Circuit believe that the Clinton-Gore Administration was an honest broker of justice, they will likely overrule one of the most intelligent decisions made by a US District Court Judge in 50 years.
Back to -----> Part 1
© 2005 Jon C. Ryter - All Rights Reserved
Order Jon Ryter's book "Whatever Happened to America?"
http://www.newswithviews.com/Ryter/jon99.htm
This is the link to this two part series. It works most of the time.
DEBT FOR TREES PART 1
from there you can link to PART 2.
Both are included below:
DEBT FOR TREES PART 1
By Jon Christian Ryter September 1, 2005 NewsWithViews.com
Houston financier and corporate raider Charles Hurwitz's problems began with the collapse of a little known Texas thrift in 1988, United Savings Association of Texas—only Hurwitz's purported complicity in the collapse of the savings and loan company never surfaced until about the time his company, MCO Holdings (which changed its name in 1995 to Maxxam, Inc.) assumed Pacific Lumber Company in 1986. Once the Pacific Lumber buyout was complete Hurwitz's problems began. But not from the US government— from environmentalists.
One of Pacific Lumber's most valuable assets was a stand of 1,000-plus year old coastal redwood trees in Humboldt County—in a 6,000 acre tract of ancient redwoods in the 90,000 acre Headwaters' Forest know as the Headwaters Grove. Each of the 300 foot tall ancient giant redwoods have a commercial street value—as cut lumber—of at least $100,000. Hurwitz, who used junk bonds to finance his takeover of Pacific Lumber needed to liquidate some of the assets of the newly acquired company to pay down the debt.
Hurwitz became interested in Pacific Lumber when junk bond investment banker Drexel Burnham Lambert advised MCO that Pacific Lumber had made an overpriced offer to buy back its own stock in 1984, causing MCO to take a closer look at the company as a potential hostile takeover since Pacific was not interested in suitors. And the closer Hurwitz looked, the better Pacific Lumber looked. Finally, in October, 1985 he went after it, assuming control of the company in 1986.
Environmentalists feared Hurwitz would clear-cut the Headwaters Grove of its ancient treasures to pay for the takeover. In reality, Hurwitz already planned to sell off specific assets of Pacific Lumber to pay for the takeover—and the Headwaters Grove was not part of his thinking. However, MCO Holdings, which was extremely leveraged, still needed to generate a revenue stream, and planned to clear-cut up to a thousand acres of Pacific Lumber's expansive reserve of Douglas pines, spruce, coastal redwoods and other timber species which the company owned. Within a matter of months, Hurwitz doubled Pacific Lumber's relatively conservative lumber harvesting practices. That convinced the greens that a land-stripper had taken over the 117 year old company.
Pacific Lumber was an institution in northern California, and had been since 1869. It was the largest employer in Humboldt County, owning around 194,000 acres of prime timberland worth billions of dollars at retail. Yet, it was not as profitable as it could have been, or should have been, due to environmentalists who did everything possible to hamstring logging operations for over a decade. The constant inference of Pacific's logging operation by radical green groups made Pacific Lumber "easy pickings" for any corporate raider. When Hurwitz took it over it wasn't long before green groups like Earth First!, the Sierra Club and Greenpeace were targeting Hurwitz, who became the "scorched earth" villain.
In January 1995, Humboldt environmentalist activist Robert Martel filled a lawsuit in US District Court against Maxxam, Industries seeking $1.6 billion to cover the losses suffered by Maxxam's bankrupt S&L, United Savings Association of Texas plus an additional $4.8 billion in punitive damages on behalf of the American taxpayers. Because Martel represented neither the government nor the depositors of United Savings, there was no legal basis for his filing. But, his lawsuit opened Pandora's box. When the federal court—which should never have accepted the action in the first placed—ruled against him, Martel appealed that court's decision to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals. The appellate court not only rejected Martel's appeal, it ordered him to pay Maxxam's legal fees of more than $110,000, saying that Martel's case was "frivolous"
In August of 1995, FDIC Chairman Ricki Tigert-Helfer filed the first of two "recovery" lawsuits in US District Court in Houston. The action, FDIC v Hurwitz, sought $250 million in damages—not from Maxxam (as MCO Holding had been renamed)—but from Hurwitz personally. When she filed her suit, Tigert-Helfer asked the Office of Thrift Management to investigate Charles Hurwitz and Maxxam for wrongdoing. In December, 1995 the Office of Thrift Management filed 13 claims against the defendants of its own lawsuit—against Hurwitz, Maxxam, two other Maxxam companies: Federated Development Company, United Financial Group (which was the parent company of United Savings), and the former and current directors of the S&L. The OTM sought $821 million in damages. The FDIC and the OTM both alleged that Hurwitz's business dealings with Drexel Burnham Lambert contributed significantly to the thrift's failure by not keeping it properly capitalized. They also alleged that Hurwitz "raided" the assets of United Savings to purchase Pacific Lumber, making Hurwitz personally liable for the $1.6 billion the OTM claims United Savings lost.
From the time the dual actions were filed by the FDIC and the OTM, Hurwitz's lawyer, Richard Keeton, was approached by various environmental groups suggesting that the government would entertain a "debt-for-trees" swap. Hurwitz would get to walk away from the FDIC and OTM charges if he agreed to allow the old stand of 300' tall redwoods in Headwaters Grove be deeded to the US government. The government would make the Headwaters redwoods part of the Six Rivers National Forest. In the early 1990s, Howard Hughes' estate engaged in a "debt for nature" swap when the estate traded some wetlands near the Los Angeles Airport to settle a tax bill owed the State of California. Several third world countries swapped land that US environmentalists thought should be protected for the debt they owed the United States. Bolivia traded tropical forests to clear their debt. Land swaps were also done with the Philippines and several other nations as well.
In February, 1997 Deputy Interior Secretary John Garamendi approached Maxxam to arrange for the acquisition of the Headwater Grove. Maxxam's general counsel, J. Kent Friedman, told the Clinton Administration official that Maxxam would consider selling the Headwater Grove to the Interior Department—but only on the condition that the government drop its FDIC lawsuit. "We want this case to go away," Friedman said.
Garamendi reported "...Hurwitz brought that to the table numerous times," but he added, he refused to intervene on Hurwitz's behalf, concluding it would be inappropriate for the Interior Department to get involved in the FDIC's business. Friedman said Maxxam raised the issue about the FDIC case because the action should never have been filed against Hurwitz who had undergone a lengthy, politically-motivated and ultimately unproved investigation by the Clinton Administration and a federal agency that violated its own rules in bringing the action. Hurwitz was not liable for the failure of United Savings because neither he nor Maxxam had controlling interest in United Financial—the holding company that had a minority interest in United Savings—therefore neither Hurwitz nor Maxxam had any legal authority to control the capital levels at the thrift.
At the time the Garamendi negotiations were underway, the Rose Foundation for Communities and the Government and several other environmentalist groups managed to convince a federal court that Pacific Lumber and a neighboring lumbering camp, Elk River Timber Company, had both violated the Endangered Species Act by logging pristine forests that sheltered the spotted owl. The federal court issued an injunction forbidding either Elk River Timber or Pacific Lumber from harvesting their land. Nine times the environmentalists filed suit in federal court. Nine times the court issued injunctions forbidding the lumber companies from cutting trees on their own land due to violations of the Endangered Species Act.
(Author's note: While I did not find documents to support my belief that Hurwitz, Friedman and Keeton were very bluntly, off-the-record, advised that they might as well sell the Headwater Grove to the environmentalists and get something for their buck because it was unlikely that, anytime in the foreseeable future, they would be able to harvest any lumber from that area since the Headwaters Forest was home to the spotted owl.)
In 1999 Hurwitz caved in and sold 10,000 acres of Headwaters Forest land to the Department of the Interior for $480 million. The deal was brokered by Sen. Diane Feinstein to preserve the old growth giant coastlal redwoods. In 2002 the FDIC dropped its 250 million action against Hurwitz when the OTM settled their $821 million case under an agreement where Hurwitz paid $206 thousand, made no admissions of wrongdoing, and agreed not to discuss the suit or the settlement.
But in his settlement, Hurwitz never agreed not to file suit against the government. He immediately sued the FDIC, by asking US District Court Judge Lynn Hughes (the presiding judge in the government's case) to award him $72 million in damages to cover his costs to fight not only the FDIC charges, but the costs associated with fighting to keep the government from seizing his redwood trees—and fighting frivolous lawsuits from the Rose Foundation, the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, Earth First! and scores of other green groups who lined up to take their best shot at Maxxam in court while Maxxam and Hurwitz were distracted with the FDIC lawsuit.
Don't miss the concuding Part 2 "whodunnit" to understand how our fine justice system really works.
© 2005 Jon C. Ryter - All Rights Reserved
DEBT FOR TREES
PART 2
By Jon Christian Ryter September 1, 2005 NewsWithViews.com
In 1999 Charles Hurwitz caved in and sold 10,000 acres of Headwaters Forest land to the Department of the Interior for $480 million. The deal was brokered by Sen. Diane Feinstein to preserve the old growth giant coastlal redwoods. In 2002 the FDIC dropped its 250 million action against Hurwitz when the OTM settled their $821 million case under an agreement where Hurwitz paid $206 thousand, made no admissions of wrongdoing, and agreed not to discuss the suit or the settlement.
But in his settlement, Hurwitz never agreed not to file suit against the government. He immediately sued the FDIC, by asking US District Court Judge Lynn Hughes (the presiding judge in the government's case) to award him $72 million in damages to cover his costs to fight not only the FDIC charges, but the costs associated with fighting to keep the government from seizing his redwood trees—and fighting frivolous lawsuits from the Rose Foundation, the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, Earth First! and scores of other green groups who lined up to take their best shot at Maxxam in court while Maxxam and Hurwitz were distracted with the FDIC lawsuit.
Hurwitz, through his lawyers, claimed that the Clinton Administration's FDIC [a] improperly funded another government agency's investigative witch hunt against Maxxam on the same matter; and, [b] his suite alleged that the Clinton Administration used bogus lawsuits in an attempt to force him to surrender over a billion dollars worth of prime coastal redwood trees to settle bogus claims against him and his company.
On Tuesday, August 23, 2005 US District Court Judge Lynn Nettleton Hughes issued his decision in FDIC v Hurwitz. It was a scathing denunciation of a government, pressured by radical environmentalist, to railroad an innocent man solely to steal his land for special interest extremists. In what is now the largest judgment against a federal agency ever awarded, Hughes ordered the FDIC to pay Hurwitz $72.3 million. In his 133-page decision, Hughes compared the federal investigations of Hurwitz and Maxxam to "...secret society of extortionists [that had practiced] craven submission [when faced with pressure from the office of the Vice President of the United States and] the green groups to cause him pain." Hughes said Hurwitz was the victim of a vindictive and politically-motivated federal agency. Hughes referred to the ordeal Hurwitz was forced to endure in terms of the Boston Tea Party, writing that "...Sam Adams would say that somebody needs to dump the FDIC's tea overboard." Hughes found, in his decision, that the FDIC, in close concert with environmental groups, sued Hurwitz to pressure him into a "debt-for-nature" swap, in effect giving the government about a billion dollars worth of trees in exchange for his supposed liability in the failure of the United Savings Association of Texas.
Paul Mason, a lobbyist and green activist for the Sierra Club summed up the view of the environmentalist movement when he noted that Judge Hughes had been hostile to the government's case against Hurwitz from the beginning. "To state that the environmental community was steering the case," Mason told the media, "would strongly overstate the influence we had with the federal government."
The question is, who's telling the truth and who's lying? That's the part of the story you won't read in your local newspaper this evening—nor will you see it on Fox News. The chronology of events is not deeply hidden. A Google search will bring you most of the headlines. A little digging will give you the rest.
For the environmentalists to even suggest that not only were they not steering the Hurwitz case, but that they hadn't engineered it by persuading Vice President Al Gore, Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt and other bureaucrats in the Clinton Administration to run interference for them in filing a lawsuit for damages against Maxxam that would force Hurwitz to agree to a "debt-for-nature" swap to alleviate his liability in the failure of United Savings Association of Texas—when the FDIC and the Clinton Justice Department knew he was not legally culpable for the failure of the S&L.
The radical environmentalist Earth First! hatched up the scheme for the FDIC to sue Hurwitz for the failure shortly after the co-presidency of Bill and Hillary Clinton descended on Washington, DC. In the usual fashion of the green extremists, Earth First! revealed its idea in a Spring, 1993 demonstration in front of the FDIC, demanding that the government take the old-growth redwoods that belonged to Pacific Lumber Company to settle any claims the FDIC should have with another Hurwitz company, the failed S&L, United Savings Association of Texas. Earth First! later insisted that their suggestion was politely offered at that time only because of the fear that Hurwitz would destroy the thousand year old trees that shielded the habitat of the spotted owl and other endangered species that lived in the Headwaters Forest in Humboldt County, California.
From that demonstration in 1993, both the Clinton Administration and Congress became acutely aware of the Headwaters Forest, Charles Hurwitz, United Savings Association of Texas and the implied liability of Hurwitz, whom the environmentalists claimed raided the assets of United Savings to leverage Pacific Lumber. Shortly after the demonstration Greenpeace, the Sierra Club Legal Defense Fund and the Rose Foundation for Community and the Government began to leverage Congress and Mr. Environment—Al Gore, Jr. The Rose Foundation and the Sierra Club became fixtures on Capitol Hill as they made their way from one Congressional and Senatorial office to another, and from the FDIC to the Office of Thrift Management, to the White House and Blair House, asking for legislation that would both implicate and exonerate Hurwitz by arranging a debt-for-trees swap in which the FDIC would exchange Hurwitz's liability in United Savings for 57,000 to 76,000 acres of Headwaters Forest which would be placed in the public trust.
In 1994 Congressman Dan Hamburg [D-CA] introduced a bill in the House of Representatives that would authorize the US Forest Service to "negotiate" the transfer of the Headwaters Forest under eminent domain to the US government and make it part of the Six Rivers National Forest. The bill passed in the House, but the Senate version of the bill, introduced by Barbara Boxer [D-CA], never made it out of committee and onto the Senate floor for a vote. When the GOP Revolution in November of 1994 pushed the Democrats out of all of the committee chairs in both the House and Senate, the odds of enacting the Headwaters bill was greatly diminished. The environmentalists reverted to the suggestion made by Earth First!—convince the FDIC to file suit against Hurwitz and then swap the Headwaters for a release from liability on United Savings Association of Texas.
It was after the defeat of The Hamburg-Boxer Act that Jill Ratner, the lawyer activist head of the Rose Foundation intensified her letter-writing campaign to entice FDIC Chairman Tigert-Helfer to file a lawsuit against Hurwitz and then do a debt-for-trees swap to settle the 1,000 year old redwood tree matter for all time. Ricki Tigert-Helfer replied to Ratner that the FDIC could not compel the defendants of any legal action to consider a debt-for-nature swap since they might decide to use other assets to satisfy their liability. It was obvious that the Bush-41 Administration clearly understood that minority shareholders in companies—unless they are board members—have no fiduciary control over the company, and thus can't be held liable for any capitalization shortfalls of the company. And, it was clear that, by the end of 1994 the Clinton Administration believed they could arbitrarily assign "fault," and in the Headwaters Forest matter, they had arbitrarily decided that Charles Hurwitz was culpable in the United Savings matter because the Sierra Club, Earth First!, Greenpeace and the Rose Foundation convinced the Clinton Administration—without any actual evidence to support their position—that Hurwitz had gutted United Savings Association and used what could be construed as stolen assets to buy Pacific Lumber. Thus, since ill-gotten gains paid for Pacific, it was only fitting to the environmentalists calling for it, that Pacific Lumber assets be used to satisfy the government's case against Hurwitz.
Ratner even raised the issue of debt-for-nature with Maxxam lawyers on several times. One one occasion, Maxxam spokesman Joshua Reiss dismissed Ratner's swap suggestion as a flawed premise since, he said, there is no debt to swap. Hurwitz, he told the media, had done nothing wrong. Since he did not possess controlling interest in United Savings, he had no legal authority to influence their policies.
John V. Thomas, associate general counsel for the FDIC wrote to a green activist, Larry Helbrook of Eleva, Wisconsin on August 23, 1994. Helbrook inquired about a possible debt-for-nature swap to protect the ancient Sequoia giants. Thomas responded, saying "We are mindful of the possibility that if Pacific Lumber's parent can be held liable for our losses, issues involving the redwood forests might be brought into play."
Shortly after she filed suit against Hurwitz, Tigert-Helfer wrote a letter to then US Congressman David E. Skaggs in which she said, in response to his question: "You may be assured that the government remains open to any appropriate settlement of this claim—including a debt-for-nature swap."
Throughout the last months of 1994 there was a flurry of high level meetings between the environmentalist lobbyists from Greenpeace, the Sierra Club, and the Rose Foundation, several liberal Congressmen and Senators, some high level Clinton Administration officials, and Vice President Al Gore who functioned as "control central" on the Hurwitz-Headwaters Forest matter. The high level meetings produced a compromise between the environmentalists and the Clinton Administration. The Al Gore emissary, Deputy Interior Secretary John Garamendi, was sent to Sacramento to meet with Hurwitz and his lawyers and negotiate the "surrender" of the Headwaters Forest.
For the environmentalists and former Clinton-Gore officials to claim they did not originate the debt-for-nature swap, or attempt to influence the filing of charges against Charles Hurwitz by the FDIC specifically to pressure him into settling the lawsuit by trading a billion dollars worth of redwood trees for a handful of spotted owls. Judge Lynn Hughes was right—the government lied. FDIC officials "...discarded the mantle of the American Republic for the clock of a secret society of extortionists. If the Vice President called, they responded. If a lobbyist called, they responded. They heeded every call but that of duty and honor."
FDIC spokesman David Barr said the agency will appeal the judgment. If the 5th Circuit Court knows how to do a Google search, without even holding a hearing, it will find enough material to uphold the opinion of Judge Hughes. If, on the other hand, the judges on the 5th Circuit believe that the Clinton-Gore Administration was an honest broker of justice, they will likely overrule one of the most intelligent decisions made by a US District Court Judge in 50 years.
Back to -----> Part 1
© 2005 Jon C. Ryter - All Rights Reserved
Order Jon Ryter's book "Whatever Happened to America?"
http://www.newswithviews.com/Ryter/jon99.htm
HC - File suit, fail and repeat as needed in Hurwitz case
File suit, fail and repeat as needed in Hurwitz case
By LOREN STEFFY
Oct. 18, 2006, 12:05PM Copyright 2006 Houston Chronicle
Blog: More on the FDIC and Charles Hurwitz, including filings and ruling at
http://blogs.chron.com/lorensteffy/2006/10/sanctioning_fut.html
IF at first you don't succeed, spend more taxpayer money.
That seems to be the attitude of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. in its relentless pursuit of Houston financier Charles Hurwitz.
Two weeks ago, the FDIC filed an appeal in its long-running battle with Hurwitz. The 90-page "brief" basically rehashes the same allegations that the FDIC has made for years. Two judges have ruled that those claims lack merit.
It's as if the FDIC believes that repetition is a substitute for proof.
"It really sounds like they're out on the street corner saying, 'Please believe us,' " says J.C. Nickens, Hurwitz's attorney.
It's unusual for an appeals motion to reargue the facts of a case, and such tactics rarely succeed. Nickens describes the FDIC's filing as having "very little law, lots of complaints about the factual findings."
That's not surprising. More than a year ago, U.S. District Judge Lynn Hughes issued a scathing rebuke of the FDIC's case and awarded Hurwitz $72 million in sanctions, probably the biggest fine a federal agency has ever been ordered to pay an individual.
Hughes likened the agency's tactics to those of the Mafia and accused several FDIC attorneys of perjury.
FDIC spokesman David Barr says the agency disagrees with the size of the sanctions and Hughes' findings, adding that the FDIC concluded that Hurwitz's motion for sanctions "was frivolous."
In its motion, the FDIC basically claims that Hughes is a dunderhead who got
all the facts of the case confused.
The FDIC's lawsuit stems from the failure in 1988 of United Savings Association of Texas, a Houston thrift indirectly controlled by Hurwitz's Maxxam Corp. The federal bailout cost taxpayers $1.6 billion.
The FDIC sued Hurwitz in 1995, claiming he should have done more to prevent the collapse.
The case became mired in a scheme to settle the FDIC's claims by getting Hurwitz to surrender 7,500 acres of old-growth redwoods in California owned by another Maxxam subsidiary, Pacific Lumber Co.
Hurwitz long has contended — and documents unearthed in a congressional investigation support him — that the FDIC was a pawn in a Clinton administration ploy to appease environmentalists by grabbing the redwoods without paying for them.
The FDIC vehemently denies that it was involved in any plan to get the trees and in its brief says that the plan was Hurwitz's idea.
A congressional investigation in 2000, though, found that the so-called debt-for-nature swap was first proposed by environmentalists in California, and that the FDIC pressed its saving and loan case against Hurwitz even though its own lawyers thought the agency was likely to lose.
Time has come and gone
What the FDIC doesn't seem to get, and what it hasn't gotten for many years now, is that it's way past time to argue the facts of this case.
In 2001, an administrative law judge issued a ruling in which he said the case was so flimsy it never should have been filed.
The FDIC, like some legal equivalent of Emily Litella, essentially said "never mind" and withdrew a parallel case that it had pressed in federal court for seven years.
By that point, Hurwitz was so outraged by the government's conduct that he asked Hughes to sanction the FDIC, which Hughes did.
"There's been two judges that have found against them," Nickens says of the FDIC.
Nearly 20 years later
So now the case could be headed back to court yet again, though it would probably be next spring — almost 20 years after United Savings' failure — if the appeals court hears the arguments. The burning question is why.
If its original savings and loan case had any merit, the FDIC had two chances to prove it. It came up empty twice.
Now, it hopes the third time will be a charm. It's easy to hope with other people's money.
The Hurwitz case has become a legal sinkhole, one from which the FDIC cannot hope to emerge. Even if it persuades the appeals court to throw out or lessen the sanctions, the FDIC's shoddy handling of the case remains.
It botched the thing that matters most in court: proving its claims.
While it's asking for a review of the facts, there's one the FDIC has overlooked: It has failed and failed again. The third time is no charm, just more money wasted on a case the FDIC has known for a long time it can't win.
Loren Steffy is the Chronicle's business columnist. His commentary appears Sundays, Wednesdays and Fridays. Contact him at loren.steffy at chron.com. His blog is at http://blogs.chron.com/lorensteffy/.
By LOREN STEFFY
Oct. 18, 2006, 12:05PM Copyright 2006 Houston Chronicle
Blog: More on the FDIC and Charles Hurwitz, including filings and ruling at
http://blogs.chron.com/lorensteffy/2006/10/sanctioning_fut.html
IF at first you don't succeed, spend more taxpayer money.
That seems to be the attitude of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. in its relentless pursuit of Houston financier Charles Hurwitz.
Two weeks ago, the FDIC filed an appeal in its long-running battle with Hurwitz. The 90-page "brief" basically rehashes the same allegations that the FDIC has made for years. Two judges have ruled that those claims lack merit.
It's as if the FDIC believes that repetition is a substitute for proof.
"It really sounds like they're out on the street corner saying, 'Please believe us,' " says J.C. Nickens, Hurwitz's attorney.
It's unusual for an appeals motion to reargue the facts of a case, and such tactics rarely succeed. Nickens describes the FDIC's filing as having "very little law, lots of complaints about the factual findings."
That's not surprising. More than a year ago, U.S. District Judge Lynn Hughes issued a scathing rebuke of the FDIC's case and awarded Hurwitz $72 million in sanctions, probably the biggest fine a federal agency has ever been ordered to pay an individual.
Hughes likened the agency's tactics to those of the Mafia and accused several FDIC attorneys of perjury.
FDIC spokesman David Barr says the agency disagrees with the size of the sanctions and Hughes' findings, adding that the FDIC concluded that Hurwitz's motion for sanctions "was frivolous."
In its motion, the FDIC basically claims that Hughes is a dunderhead who got
all the facts of the case confused.
The FDIC's lawsuit stems from the failure in 1988 of United Savings Association of Texas, a Houston thrift indirectly controlled by Hurwitz's Maxxam Corp. The federal bailout cost taxpayers $1.6 billion.
The FDIC sued Hurwitz in 1995, claiming he should have done more to prevent the collapse.
The case became mired in a scheme to settle the FDIC's claims by getting Hurwitz to surrender 7,500 acres of old-growth redwoods in California owned by another Maxxam subsidiary, Pacific Lumber Co.
Hurwitz long has contended — and documents unearthed in a congressional investigation support him — that the FDIC was a pawn in a Clinton administration ploy to appease environmentalists by grabbing the redwoods without paying for them.
The FDIC vehemently denies that it was involved in any plan to get the trees and in its brief says that the plan was Hurwitz's idea.
A congressional investigation in 2000, though, found that the so-called debt-for-nature swap was first proposed by environmentalists in California, and that the FDIC pressed its saving and loan case against Hurwitz even though its own lawyers thought the agency was likely to lose.
Time has come and gone
What the FDIC doesn't seem to get, and what it hasn't gotten for many years now, is that it's way past time to argue the facts of this case.
In 2001, an administrative law judge issued a ruling in which he said the case was so flimsy it never should have been filed.
The FDIC, like some legal equivalent of Emily Litella, essentially said "never mind" and withdrew a parallel case that it had pressed in federal court for seven years.
By that point, Hurwitz was so outraged by the government's conduct that he asked Hughes to sanction the FDIC, which Hughes did.
"There's been two judges that have found against them," Nickens says of the FDIC.
Nearly 20 years later
So now the case could be headed back to court yet again, though it would probably be next spring — almost 20 years after United Savings' failure — if the appeals court hears the arguments. The burning question is why.
If its original savings and loan case had any merit, the FDIC had two chances to prove it. It came up empty twice.
Now, it hopes the third time will be a charm. It's easy to hope with other people's money.
The Hurwitz case has become a legal sinkhole, one from which the FDIC cannot hope to emerge. Even if it persuades the appeals court to throw out or lessen the sanctions, the FDIC's shoddy handling of the case remains.
It botched the thing that matters most in court: proving its claims.
While it's asking for a review of the facts, there's one the FDIC has overlooked: It has failed and failed again. The third time is no charm, just more money wasted on a case the FDIC has known for a long time it can't win.
Loren Steffy is the Chronicle's business columnist. His commentary appears Sundays, Wednesdays and Fridays. Contact him at loren.steffy at chron.com. His blog is at http://blogs.chron.com/lorensteffy/.
HC - It seems like Charles Hurwitz just can't catch a break
It seems like Charles Hurwitz just can't catch a break
Business: Loren Steffy
Jan. 23, 2007, 11:13PM Copyright 2007 Houston Chronicle
Victory seems to forever elude Charles Hurwitz.
In 1999, he hammered out an agreement with California and federal officials to preserve old-growth redwood trees while allowing his logging company, Pacific Lumber, to cut enough new-growth trees to make a profit.
The deal, known as the Headwaters Agreement, was supposed to broker peace between Hurwitz and environmental groups that opposed his company's logging operations.
More importantly, it should have been a model for how private industry can work with other groups to preserve the environment.
Last week, Pacific Lumber filed for bankruptcy, strangled by new regulations made outside the agreement.
"We were dealt a hand where we couldn't do anything," Hurwitz told me Monday. "It's a pure breach of contract."
Regional water boards, which weren't included in the Headwaters Agreement and therefore argue they aren't bound by it, ruled that runoff from Palco's logging was affecting rivers and streams in Northern California's scenic Humboldt County.
The boards imposed new restrictions.
Palco's timber harvest has fallen steadily as a result, to 145.5 million board feet in 2005 from 166.3 million in 2003, according to its annual filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
At the same time, the quality of the harvest shifted to lower grades of redwood and Douglas fir, which sell at a lower price.
The company wasn't making enough money to service its debt, part of which was incurred when Palco refurbished its mills for the newer growth trees as specified in the 1999 deal.
Over the years, the battle between Hurwitz and the environmentalists has grown personal. The protesters bristle at the thought of a single tree felled by Hurwitz's hand.
In a news release, Karen Pickett, director of one such group, the Bay Area Coalition for Headwaters, summed up the filing this way:
"The one thing we can look forward to ultimately is a Maxxam-free and Hurwitz-free company."
Unattractive
Then what?
What chance does Palco have for survival? It can't, under the latest environmental restrictions, produce enough lumber to turn a profit, whether it's owned by Hurwitz or someone else.
Bankruptcy may eliminate some of the company's debt, but it won't make Palco attractive to outside buyers. The threat of unending tree sittings and sabotage to logging operations makes Palco an unappealing purchase.
Hurwitz's adversaries spin a heartwarming myth about returning Palco to its days as an ecofriendly, family-run logging company.
But returning Palco to its old style of operations also returns it to the reality that left it vulnerable to Hurwitz's takeover 20 years ago. Palco was a mismanaged operation. Its executives hadn't done an accurate inventory of its timber lands in more than 30 years, and the "family" company's stock — which was traded on the New York Stock Exchange — languished.
In today's lumber industry, the margins have gotten thinner and the competition has increased. A return to Palco's past would promptly be followed by a return to bankruptcy court.
'Root of all evil'
For his part, Hurwitz has paid a hefty price for his ownership of Palco.
"This is the root of all evil for us," he said. "Everything that's bad in my business life has come out of this."
The environmental issues formed the basis for the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.'s decadelong legal battle against Hurwitz. The lawsuit involved the failure of United Savings Association of Texas, but documents released as part of a congressional investigation revealed that regulators pursued a flimsy case to extract a settlement that would have included forfeiting Palco's old-growth redwood forest.
Hurwitz won, but the government appealed. With the case headed back to court, the victory is hollow. Palco's bankruptcy represents another eroded triumph, the collapse of the Headwaters Agreement.
The cycle remains unbroken and as vicious as it was before. Hurwitz and his foes in the environmental movement seem locked in perpetual conflict.
In many of these battles, Hurwitz has been right. But as last week's bankruptcy filing shows, you can be right and still lose.
Loren Steffy is the Chronicle's business columnist. His commentary appears Sundays, Wednesdays and Fridays. Contact him at loren.steffy at chron.com. His blog is at http://blogs.chron.com/lorensteffy/.
Business: Loren Steffy
Jan. 23, 2007, 11:13PM Copyright 2007 Houston Chronicle
Victory seems to forever elude Charles Hurwitz.
In 1999, he hammered out an agreement with California and federal officials to preserve old-growth redwood trees while allowing his logging company, Pacific Lumber, to cut enough new-growth trees to make a profit.
The deal, known as the Headwaters Agreement, was supposed to broker peace between Hurwitz and environmental groups that opposed his company's logging operations.
More importantly, it should have been a model for how private industry can work with other groups to preserve the environment.
Last week, Pacific Lumber filed for bankruptcy, strangled by new regulations made outside the agreement.
"We were dealt a hand where we couldn't do anything," Hurwitz told me Monday. "It's a pure breach of contract."
Regional water boards, which weren't included in the Headwaters Agreement and therefore argue they aren't bound by it, ruled that runoff from Palco's logging was affecting rivers and streams in Northern California's scenic Humboldt County.
The boards imposed new restrictions.
Palco's timber harvest has fallen steadily as a result, to 145.5 million board feet in 2005 from 166.3 million in 2003, according to its annual filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
At the same time, the quality of the harvest shifted to lower grades of redwood and Douglas fir, which sell at a lower price.
The company wasn't making enough money to service its debt, part of which was incurred when Palco refurbished its mills for the newer growth trees as specified in the 1999 deal.
Over the years, the battle between Hurwitz and the environmentalists has grown personal. The protesters bristle at the thought of a single tree felled by Hurwitz's hand.
In a news release, Karen Pickett, director of one such group, the Bay Area Coalition for Headwaters, summed up the filing this way:
"The one thing we can look forward to ultimately is a Maxxam-free and Hurwitz-free company."
Unattractive
Then what?
What chance does Palco have for survival? It can't, under the latest environmental restrictions, produce enough lumber to turn a profit, whether it's owned by Hurwitz or someone else.
Bankruptcy may eliminate some of the company's debt, but it won't make Palco attractive to outside buyers. The threat of unending tree sittings and sabotage to logging operations makes Palco an unappealing purchase.
Hurwitz's adversaries spin a heartwarming myth about returning Palco to its days as an ecofriendly, family-run logging company.
But returning Palco to its old style of operations also returns it to the reality that left it vulnerable to Hurwitz's takeover 20 years ago. Palco was a mismanaged operation. Its executives hadn't done an accurate inventory of its timber lands in more than 30 years, and the "family" company's stock — which was traded on the New York Stock Exchange — languished.
In today's lumber industry, the margins have gotten thinner and the competition has increased. A return to Palco's past would promptly be followed by a return to bankruptcy court.
'Root of all evil'
For his part, Hurwitz has paid a hefty price for his ownership of Palco.
"This is the root of all evil for us," he said. "Everything that's bad in my business life has come out of this."
The environmental issues formed the basis for the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.'s decadelong legal battle against Hurwitz. The lawsuit involved the failure of United Savings Association of Texas, but documents released as part of a congressional investigation revealed that regulators pursued a flimsy case to extract a settlement that would have included forfeiting Palco's old-growth redwood forest.
Hurwitz won, but the government appealed. With the case headed back to court, the victory is hollow. Palco's bankruptcy represents another eroded triumph, the collapse of the Headwaters Agreement.
The cycle remains unbroken and as vicious as it was before. Hurwitz and his foes in the environmental movement seem locked in perpetual conflict.
In many of these battles, Hurwitz has been right. But as last week's bankruptcy filing shows, you can be right and still lose.
Loren Steffy is the Chronicle's business columnist. His commentary appears Sundays, Wednesdays and Fridays. Contact him at loren.steffy at chron.com. His blog is at http://blogs.chron.com/lorensteffy/.